Amendment process ensures exceptions get written in – independent scenarios for our impacts – AND school prayer rides – AND ensures delay
Thomas Berg 98. Professor of Law, Cumberland Law School, Samford University, “The Constitutional Future of Religious Freedom Legislation,” University of Arkansas at Little Rock Law Review, 20(3), 1998, 20 U. Ark. Little Rock L. Rev. 715, http://lawrepository.ualr.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1623&context=lawreview
Of course, there are other ways to reinstitute a general legal rule that accommodations should be afforded except in cases of overriding government necessity. Advocates of religious freedom could seek to convince the Court to abandon Smith and return to the rule requiring accommodations; failing that, they could seek to amend the Constitution to reverse Smith. Or they could work at the level of individual states, pushing for such a general standard through state statutes or constitutional amendments. The constitutional amendment process is obviously long and arduous, and nothing would happen unless the required three-fourths of the states ratified the amendment. The constitutional amendment process illustrates the power that can be exercised by a few interest groups who are opposed to religious freedom in the cases that concern them. Groups from prison wardens to the architectural preservation lobby to public educators to animal rights activists could force exceptions to be written into the amendment at the front end--or more likely, they could defeat it entirely at the back end by blocking passage in just a few states. The experience could be similar to that of the Equal Rights Amendment, which shot out of the starting gate in 1972 but ran into insurmountable difficulties getting the last few states to ratify.39 The amendment process would also tend to sweep in other issues in the contentious area of church and state, such as various forms of prayer in public schools and financial aid to religious schools-a concern expressed by a number of members of Congress at hearings held last year in the wake of Boerne.'° The state legislative or amendment process is more likely to produce tangible results, but it too would move very slowly. It also is practically guaranteed to produce uneven results, with lobbies that are powerful in particular states enjoying greater ability to force exceptions to the religious freedom law. Already some states have proposed to exempt prisoner claims;4 in other states, lobbyists for groups on the other side of particular disputes may be able to demand exceptions.