Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

CP causes runaway convention

Condray and Conlan 19 (Patrick, MA from George Mason, Public Policy PhD student with the Schar School (George Mason University), Timothy J. Conlan is University Professor of Government at George Mason University. He holds a Ph.D. in Government from Harvard University and an undergraduate degree in Political Science from the University of Chicago, Article V Conventions and American Federalism: Contemporary Politics in Historical Perspective, Publius: The Journal of Federalism, Volume 49, Issue 3, Summer 2019, Pages 515–539, https://doi-org.ezproxy.library.unlv.edu/10.1093/publius/pjz009 )

In 2013, a group called Citizens for Self-Governance (CSG) initiated the Convention of States (CoS) Project, which seeks to amend the U.S. Constitution through an Article V Convention. With funding and support from conservative entities such as the Koch Brothers and the American Legislative Exchange Council, the Project promotes amendments designed to “impose fiscal restraints on the federal government,” “limit the power and jurisdiction of the federal government,” and “limit the terms of office for federal officials” (Guldenschuh 2015). As of early 2019, fourteen states had issued calls for a convention to consider these amendments. Another conservative effort bringing new life into state calls promoting a convention to adopt a Balanced Budget Amendment has generated a total of twenty-eight applications as of 2018. Meanwhile, on the left, a smaller and less well-funded effort has led to six states issuing calls for an Article V Convention focused on campaign finance. They seek to amend the Constitution in order to overturn the Supreme Court decision overturning various campaign-finance limits in Citizens United v. FEC, 558 U.S. 310 (2010). Active state Article V Convention calls continue to be debated in multiple state legislatures. For example, as of March 2019 the Convention of States call (pushed by CSG, which modestly describes itself as the “largest Article V grassroots organization in the country”) has been the subject of active legislation in fourteen state legislatures in 2019 (Convention of States 2019). Arkansas and Utah passed the CoS call in 2019. Efforts such as these have drawn renewed attention to the state convention method of amending the U.S. Constitution. Article V of the Constitution allows two-thirds of the states to call for a convention of states for proposing Constitutional amendments. Unlike the alternative and more familiar process of advancing Constitutional amendments by a two-thirds vote of the Congress, followed by state ratification, the power to call for a Constitutional convention rests with the states. As Article V states, in part: “The Congress … on the Application of the Legislatures of two thirds of the several States, shall call a Convention for proposing Amendments…” Because the convention method has never been employed under the U.S. Constitution, the prospect of a convention raises many questions and alternative assessments. Must all of the state calls be expressed in identical language? Can such a convention be limited in scope or would it constitute an entity immune from preconditions? What role (if any) do the courts play in deciding such questions? Uncertainty about these and other issues has long posed a political hurdle to utilizing the convention approach, with many observers raising the prospect of a “runaway” convention that might trample on the Bill of Rights or other provisions (Goldberg 1983). Accordingly, these and other aspects of an Article V convention have prompted considerable discussion and analysis by lawyers, scholars, and public officials (Caplan 1988; Vile 1993). Less is known, however, about why and how states have articulated Article V applications over time and how contemporary movements to call a convention may align with or differ from historical patterns. Over the course of American history, states have issued at least 354 distinct calls for an Article V convention. Some, such as the efforts to provide for the direct election of Senators or to require a balanced federal budget, have come close enough to garnering support from two-thirds of the states that they provoked a preemptory response from Congress. Others have prompted momentary interest and then faded away. Many have been motivated by states’ interest in enhancing their power relative to the national government, but others have been focused on important policy issues of the day. Can these and other patterns from the past inform our understanding of today’s efforts to amend the Constitution through a convention of the states, or are there features of contemporary calls for an Article V convention that are different and unique?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.