Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Constitutional amendments are a key mechanism of democratic backsliding- they’re off the table now but reviving them kills democracy

Huq and Ginsburg 18 (Aziz and Thomas, Professors of Law, University of Chicago Law School, "How to Lose a Constitutional Democracy," 65 UCLA Law Review 78 (2018), https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=13666&context=journal_articles )

1. Constitutional Amendment Imagine that a political party had disciplined majorities in both houses of Congress and the thirty-eight states necessary to utilize Article V. Or alternatively, suppose that the growing chorus of calls for a new constitutional convention yielded fruit.281 It would then be feasible to reform core elements of the American Constitution. The content of such reforms is not hard to imagine. Perhaps, following patterns in other illiberal democracies, a first target might be the Twenty-Second Amendment, which constitutionalized term limits in the wake of Franklin Roosevelt’s presidency. Or simply examine the various liberty-restricting constitutional amendments that have been proposed in Congress over the years, mainly to overturn court decisions.282 To be sure, there are other amendments that have been proposed that would enhance liberty. But the point is that there is nothing structural in Article V that prevents this disciplined national majority with sufficient political support at the state level from using constitutional amendment to entrench its power and restrict liberty. Nevertheless, we do not think that constitutional amendment will play a significant role in promoting the retrogression of constitutional liberal democracy for two reasons. First, American political parties have historically lacked discipline relative to their counterparts in other democracies—a complex result of history, geography, and our electoral system. And the very veneration of the Constitution suggests that amendments are likely to receive a good deal of attention, working as focal points for constitutional resistance by regime opponents.283 As a strategic matter, more subtle mechanisms are likely to be more effective and hence more likely to be deployed.284 Second, Article V of the Constitution establishes “some of the most onerous hurdles in the world for the ratification of amendments.”285 Indeed, it has been so rarely used that some scholars have argued that it has fallen into desuetude.286 In most other contexts in which amendment has played a large role in facilitating backsliding from democratic practices, by contrast, the amendment rule has been less demanding.287 There is an irony here: Article V has been condemned roundly by commentators, especially on the political left.288 Yet the rigidity of the formal constitutional procedure largely takes off the table at least one potent instrument of constitutional retrogression at a moment when liberal commentators might well feel their priorities most imperiled.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.