Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

It’s more controversial than the aff

John A. Eidsmoe 92. 1992, Prof of Law @ Thomas Goode Jones School of Law, United States Air Force Academy Journal of Legal Studies, “A New Constitutional Convention? Critical Look at Questions Answered, and Not Answered, by Article Five of the United States Constitution”, Lexis.

It is no wonder, then, that Lawrence tribe, Professor of constitutional Law at Harvard, warns that a new constitutional convention could lead to domestic political confrontations of “nightmarish dimension” between Congress and the Convention, between Congress and the Supreme Court, and between Congress and the states-not to mention between the Supreme Court and the Convention. Tribe continues, Particularly in a period of recovery form a decade ruptured by war, political assassination, near impeachment and economic upheaval, and particularly in a time when such recovery has already been interrupted by new domestic and international crises, it is vital that the means we choose fro amending the Constitution be generally understood and, above all, widely understood as legitimate. An Article V convention, however, would today provoke controversy and debate unparalleled in recent constitutional history. For the device is shrouded in legal mysteries of the most fundamental sort, mysteries yielding to no ready mechanism of solution. Given the significance of the United States Constitution both for our nation and for others, it would not be surprising if a convention of this magnitude were to result in serious economic instability at home and abroad, as well as substantial disruption of America’s relations abroad.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.