Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Just like “horse-trading” could be the link to an agenda politics DA- it could also work for amendments

Gilbert 17 (Michael, Sullivan & Cromwell Professor of Law, University of Virginia, Virginia Law Review, Vol. 103, No. 4 (June 2017), pp. 631-671, https://www.jstor.org/stable/26400253 )

In addition to constitutional failure, these ideas cast light on an important question of constitutional evolution: When to amend and when to convene? Article V authorizes two methods for changing the text of the Constitution: amendments and conventions.146 Other constitutions offer the same basic choice.147 Amendments are more likely to fit the spatial models, which assume decisions happen on one issue at a time. Thus, changing law through amendment will more likely produce the incrementalism and instability described above. Conventions, on the other hand, often involve bargaining across multiple issues. Such bargaining can generate meaningful change. Returning to Figure 5, voter l will not, without more, approve replacing SQ with a law at m. She might, however, support such a change if she gets a change on another issue in ex change. Suppose the dimension in Figure 5 reflects rights for religious minorities, and another unpictured dimension reflects the right to educa tion. Voter l opposes moving rights for religious minorities further from her ideal point—which going from SQ to m would do—but she would nevertheless support it as part of a deal that simultaneously moves the right to education closer to her ideal point. Thus, bargaining can produce large change even when law is entrenched and the incrementalism and pace principles operate. In short, the solution to the constitutional predicament described above is a convention. Voters or their representatives must bargain across issues, not vote individually on each one. Returning to the case of France, after the constitution collapsed in 1958, General de Gaulle's government drafted a new one. Voters cast one vote on the complete package; they did not vote on each provision. According to a key parliamentarian, the new constitution "embodied] the reforms envisaged earlier," meaning the amendments considered but rejected during the Fourth Republic.148 Revision accomplished what amendment could not. France's Fifth Republic endures to this day

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.