Collapse risks Chinese lashout and global nuclear war
David, 8 – professor of international relations at Johns Hopkins (Stephen, Catastrophic Consequences : Civil Wars and American Interests, p. 116-121)
Those who see China as a threat to the United States, and to the West more generally, point to its explosive growth as a source of concern. A stronger China, they argue, will be a more assertive China, which spells bad news for the United States, given the range of issues over which the two countries disagree. A wealthy, militarily strong China may no longer choose to accept the de facto independence of Taiwan, or it may compete aggressively to gain dominance over Asia, or replace American influence among the oil-rich states of the Middle East. Arguments over trade, human rights, and the environment may take a different tone when America is dealing with an adversary of equal or even greater strength. Whether because the United States and China each lead different civilizations, or simply because the rise of a competing hegemon typically creates trouble for the existing world leader, the prospect of a continued rise in China’s power unsettles many in America. 2 These fears may indeed be justified, but continued economic and military growth is not the only possible future for China. It is at least as likely that China in the coming years will fall victim to violent instability, bringing to a screeching halt its seemingly inexorable rise. Instability may come from those angry at not sharing the fruits of China's newfound prosperity, growing discrepancies of wealth in a state founded on principles of equality, mounting corruption by insensitive officials, incompetent governmental policies, and the absence of institutions to channel discontent. This anger matters because it is directed at a government whose "mandate of heaven" is increasingly shaky, since no one—including the leadership elite itself—believes in the Marxist-Leninist ideology that is trotted out to justify its rule. All of this takes place in an environment where the regime's ability to monitor and suppress antigovernment activity has never been lower. If economic growth can somehow continue its upward spiral producing enough benefits to coopt key groups, China may be able to avoid nationwide instability in the coming years. However, if as seems likely, the Chinese economy stalls and the escalating expectations of the Chinese people are no longer met, widespread civil conflict becomes all but certain. While some American policymakers would greet the prospect of a China mired in internal conflict with relief, a crippled China presents its own threats to American interests, threats that are in many ways more dire than those posed by a rising China. American and Chinese economies have become closely inter- twined with huge amounts of American investment in China and even larger Chinese purchases of American bonds. If domestic unrest undermines this relationship, any hope of China becoming prosperous would be dashed, while the American economy would be throw n into recession —or worse. China is a great power with a population of 1.3 billion people, bordering on 14 countries. Its collapse would threaten the stability of close American allies such as South Korea and Japan, create opportunities for mischief by Russia and North Korea, and produce a humanitarian catastrophe unprecedented in world history. Should China choose to stave off internal unrest through aggressive actions against Taiwan, prospects for a Sino-American military confrontation become all too real. Precisely because China needs good relations with its neighbors and the United States to continue on its path of economic growth, there is reason to hope that the Chinese leadership would not deliberately opt for bellicose policies. If China is wracked with instability, however, Chinese leaders may not be able to control what happens within and outside their borders, endangering key American concerns. Understanding the consequences of a failing China for the United States re- quires first grasping why a stable China is so important to American concerns. As will be seen, China plays a central role in American economic and strategic interests. Why China, despite its seeming prosperity and progress, may fall victim to civil unrest is then examined. Unlike Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and Mexico, China forces us to confront what the collapse of a great power would be like. Far from a welcome occurrence, the implications of such an event are potentially catastrophic for America, China's Asian neighbors, and the world community. American Interests in China The United States cares about what happens in China, because America's prosperity and well-being rests on China remaining stable. China is the second largest trading partner of the United States (after Canada ), a relationship whose disruption would be disastrous for both countries. The low cost of Chinese exports has kept inflation down in the United States, while delighting consumers with S40 DVD players and S20 digital cameras. These benefits, while highly visible, pale in comparison to the critical role played by Chinese purchases of American securities. China holds over one trillion dollars in foreign reserves, one of the largest holders of such reserves in the world. Because China exports so much and imports so little, it accumulates huge amounts of dollars. This would normally cause the Chinese currency (yuan) to gain in value, thus reducing its exports and its mammoth reserves. To preserve its critical export sector, however, China has not allowed the yuan to float freely and instead has kept its value relatively constant by buying dollars to the tune of S20 billion per month, ensuring that its reserves will continue to grow. Approximately 707c of these reserves are in U.S. dollars, with the great majority in U.S. treasury bonds, widely seen as the most secure investment one can make, since they are backed in full by the American government. A major reason why interest rates in the United States have been kept low is because China buys so many of these bonds. These low interest rates are central to the health of the American economy, fostering economic expansion and high home prices. The housing market is especially critical, as it has been the major engine of growth for the American economy over the past several years, as homeowners (many of whom have saved little) borrow against the ever rising values of their houses, stimulating the economy with their robust consumer spending. If China stops buying American treasury bonds or dramatically slows down their purchase, American interest rates would need to increase in order to attract other buyers, making business expansion more costly , houses much more expensive, and dramatically cutting consumer spending.' China displayed its economic clout the day after the Democrats won control over both houses of Congress in November 2006, when the head of China's central bank declared that the Bank would diversify more of its reserves into nondollar currencies. This prompted an immediate worldwide sell-off of American dollars, which dramatically cut the dollar's value. If such a seemingly benign announcement could produce this effect, one shudders to think of the impact of a major Chinese sell-off of American bonds on the United States.4 Some have taken solace in the view that Chinese self-interest would prevent Beijing from acting in ways that would harm the American economy. If, for example, China halted its purchase of American securities, China too would suffer as the value of the bonds in its possession would also decrease. If China is convulsed with domestic disorder, however, it would be unable to purchase the American bonds, plunging the U.S. economy into crisis. An unstable China also presents major strategic concerns for the United States. Since the death of Mao in 1976, China has largely cooperated with the United States on key foreign policy goals. China has been a prime player in talks with North Korea, striving to contain the damage done by Pyongyang’s development of nuclear weapons. In part because of China’s concerns about its own Islamic minority, Beijing has worked with Washington after 9/11 to confront terrorism. China has become a major international player in the United Nations, contributing more troops to peacekeeping missions around the world than any other Security Council member. 5 With Washington’s endorsement, China joined the World Trade Organization, where it is expected to play a major role in lowering tariffs and establishing rules for free trade that the world (and it) will follow. To be sure, the United States and China do not agree on everything. The United States is concerned about China's lack of democracy, overlooking of human rights abuses in Darfur and elsewhere, border disputes with its neighbors, close ties with Iran, and continuing claims to Taiwan. Nevertheless, in a world increasingly divided between those fostering terror and instability and those seeking to maintain order and enhance prosperity, China clearly belongs in the latter camp, much to America's relief. If China is beset by internal disorder, however, there is no telling what kind of regime might emerge in its wake. The brutal civil war in China in the late 1940s gave birth to an equally brutal government that made life miserable for its neighbors and America for decades. A twenty-first-century civil war could well bring about the emergence of a hostile, expansionist China that, armed with nuclear weapons and a strong economy, posed an even greater threat to American interests and world stability than its Maoist predecessor. A strong China is necessary to preserve Asian stability, a vital interest of the United States. The prosperity of Asian nations is directly linked to the surging Chinese economy. In the 1990s, Asian nations produced goods largely for non-Asian countries, particularly the United States. By 2005, more than half of all regional exports were to other states in the region, with China the most likely destination. China is the number one trading partner of such Asian powerhouses as South Korea and Japan, both of which now provide more direct investment to China (over S5 billion per y ear) than even the United States.6 Moreover, China has emerged as the major player in Asian multilateral organizations, including the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO), and the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum (APEC). None of these organizations could meet their goals of fostering economic and political interdependence without the active cooperation of China. Insofar as economic interdependence and international institutions promote peace and security, the continued economic growth and stability of China is essential for Asia. The importance of a stable China to American strategic interests is best seen by considering what might happen if China unraveled. One of the first consequences would be millions of refugees pouring from China’s borders, unsettling its neighbors. The stability of key American allies such as Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan would be severely tested as they try to cope with this massive human flow along with the economic shockwaves of China's dissolution. Nor would the United States be immune, as mam Chinese may take advantage of corrupt officials or professional human smugglers ("snakeheads') to make their way to America's shores. North Korea, unpredictable under normal circumstances, may flex its military muscle along its borders with China and South Korea, with dreadful results. Ethnic minorities in provinces such as Tibet and Xinjiang might seize the moment to attempt to break away from Beijing's domination, fostering even greater instability. China's control of its more than 200 nuclear weapons, usually very secure, may be compromised, with the arms eventually falling into unknown hands. The territorial disputes that China has with Russia, Vietnam, India, and others could well degenerate into armed warfare as China loses control over its own military forces and its neighbors seek to take advantage of its internal strife. As Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping remarked (following the 1989 Tiananmen demonstrations), the collapse of Chinese rule would have terrible effects that would go far beyond China's borders: "And if a civil war broke out, with blood flowing like a river, what 'human rights' would there be? If civil war broke out in China, with each faction dominating a region, production declining, transportation disrupted and not millions or tens of millions but hundreds of millions of refugees fleeing the country, it is the Asia-Pacific region, which is at present the most promising in the world, that would be the first affected. And that would lead to disaster on a world scale."9 While Deng may have had reason to exaggerate the effects of the toppling of the Chinese regime, his concerns ring true. American relations with China would be severely damaged in the wake of Chinese unrest. The Chinese regime might single out the United States as an enemy in order to stifle civil strife by fostering anti-American nationalism. If China violently suppressed protests, as it did during the 1989 Tiananmen demonstrations, the American Congress might retaliate with economic sanctions, further escalating tensions between China and the United States. Especially if China takes actions against groups favored by the United States, such as Chi- nese Christians, the American leadership is likely to react harshly against Beijing. Chinese leaders already worry about the United States exploiting internal unrest to remove them from power. Actual American support of insurgent groups even if it is confined to expressions of sympathy, could be taken as a sign that Washington had joined with the rebels, throwing Sino-American relations into crisis. China would very quickly turn from an erstwhile ally into a superpower adversary. The deterioration of the American relationship with China would be especially dangerous regarding Taiwan. Under the best of circumstances, Taiwan presents a flash point in the Chinese-American relationship. China's claims that Taiwan is a renegade province belonging to the People's Republic fly in the face of America's commitment to protect Taiwan, a democratic and prosperous ally. So long as Taiwan does not declare its independence, the United States and China can agree to disagree about Taiwan's future, but should internal unrest engulf China, this uneasy and informal accommodation could unravel. If China falls victim to widespread instability, the pressure to act against Taiwan would be enormous. It would give China the excuse to impose martial law, improving its abilities to suppress any budding revolt. China's claims to Taiwan enjoy near unanimous approval among the Chinese people. Acting against Taiwan would enable the Chinese leadership to fan the flames of nationalism, one of the few means at its disposal to rally support for an otherwise illegitimate regime." A Sino-Taiwanese confrontation could also come about inadvertently if the Chinese leadership decided to provoke a crisis over Taiwan only to find itself at war as popular emotions prevented a peaceful resolution of the crisis. If a Taiwanese leader decided to exploit Chinese unrest by declaring independence, the Chinese government might have no choice but to launch an attack. As the political scientist Susan Shirk argues, no Chinese regime can stand aside and allow Taiwan to announce its independence without going to war if it expects to survive in power.12 Whether through miscalculation or brinksmanship, war with Taiwan producing a Sino-American confrontation could well be the unintended out- come of Chinese civil conflict. China is well prepared to take forceful action against Taiwan if it decides to do so. China has been constantly upgrading its air and sea capabilities for a possible invasion across the Straits of Taiwan. 13 If China chooses not to invade, it could launch the hundreds of ballistic missiles deployed on its coast against Taiwan or it could blockade its two principal ports. Given that Taiwan is critically dependent on foreign trade (75% of its GDP) and imports of fuel for energy consumption (95% of its energy needs come from outside the country), either of these actions would cripple the island state. 14 It is difficult to see the United States remaining indifferent to a brutal assault against one of its allies. Perhaps most worrisome, we simply do not know all of the effects that the collapse of China would bring. The prospect of civil unrest in China threatens an existing great power poised perhaps to become the major power of the twenty-first century. The impact of civil conflict in China cannot be isolated to one or a handful of consequences. As seen in the French Revolution of 1789– 1799 and the Russian Civil War of 1918– 1920, great powers do not suffer civil violence quietly, or alone. Given China’s central role in the world economy, enormous population, nuclear arsenal, and growing international influence, the unraveling of China cannot help but be shattering for the world. Change can be beneficial, and the weakening of a prospective superpower competitor would be celebrated in some American quarters. Nevertheless, an uncontrolled, cataclysmic transformation in China would threaten American interests as much as, if not more than, the purposeful designs of Maoist China a generation ago.