China is winning the tech race--- patents, exports, and GDP prove.
Joseph M. Parent and Paul K. MacDonald 2018 [Paul K. MacDonald is an American political scientist and a Professor of Political Science at Wellesley College, Joseph M. Parent is associate professor of political science at the University of Notre Dame, Twilight of the Titans, Conclusion, “Retrenchment as Reloading,” https://muse.jhu.edu/chapter/2092847//ZW]
Scholars have offered conflicting assessments about the trajectory of American power. Some contend that China’s rise is inexorable and that the United States is already in decline. “There is abundant evidence that American global hegemony is steadily eroding,” Martin Jacques observes, adding, “The rise of China will change the world in the most profound ways.” 18 Arvind Subramanian concludes, “The economic dominance of China relative to the United States” is “imminent” and will be “broad-based.” 19 Others argue that China’s ascendance is fragile and that America’s exceptional features will insulate it from decline. “China is rising, but it is not catching up,” Michael Beckley maintains, in large part because “trends favor continued U.S. dominance.” 20 Joseph Nye similarly argues, “China is nowhere near close to the United States,” warning that “the greatest danger we have is overestimating China.” 21 Politicians echo this skepticism. In a 2014 speech at West Point, President Barack Obama declared, “America has rarely been stronger relative to the rest of the world. Those who argue otherwise—who suggest that America is in decline, or has seen its global leadership slip away—are either misreading history or engaged in partisan politics.” 22 There are many complex issues bound up in this debate. Scholars differ on what metrics to use, what timeframes to examine, and what comparisons to make. We follow the method that yielded the most commonsense cases: lasting ordinal transitions involving relative shares of great power gross domestic product (GDP). Using this approach, the United States is on pace to enter acute relative decline sometime in the next decade. 23 To be perfectly clear, this prediction depends on a number of factors that are hard to predict. Extrapolating out from present trends is notoriously unreliable, and much depends on the baseline year one chooses to begin with. There will be shocks and surprises, and it is impossible to know their frequency, magnitude, or direction. Yet using our terminology, the United States is likely to face a decline that is small or medium in magnitude. This is good news for the United States and for China, since it affords both powers the time and space to manage the impending transition. It deserves emphasis that China is no world-beater, the United States is no weakling, and American decline is likely modest. As always, much depends on the measures used. Power is an intricate concept and sensitive to context. Every measure of power has its drawbacks, and we already detailed many of the fl aws of using GDP in chapter 3. We agree that GDP trends mask a great deal of nuance, cross-national GDP fi gures are imprecise, and China’s fi gures are more suspect than most. Yet GDP is determinate and correlates with a number of compelling metrics, many of which suggest that China is indisputably gaining ground on the United States. Over the past decade, the United States has experienced a decline in global share of high technology exports, trademark applications, market capitalizations of its publicly traded companies, and renewable energy production. Meanwhile, China has gained relative to the United States in terms of patent applications, high technology exports, and information and communication technology service exports. 24 Even when it comes to GDP per capita, which many claim provides “a much more robust indicator of national power,” China is gaining ground. 25 China’s GDP per capita has tripled over the past decade, and the U.S. advantage has declined as a result. Naturally, these are not the only indicators one could point to, and economic measures may lose traction on the political consequences of China’s rise. Yet experts come to similar conclusions: Thomas Christensen finds China’s rise very real, though the United States retains a commanding lead on many measures, and Jonathan Kirshner sees American economic advantages fading. 26 Even U.S. policymakers, who reject the term decline, nevertheless acknowledge that the distribution of international power is shifting. In his West Point speech, President Obama observed, “The world is changing with accelerating speed. This presents new opportunities, but also new dangers.” 27 Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton conceded, “The Asia-Pacific has become a key driver of global politics. . . . Harnessing Asia’s growth and dynamism is central to American economic and strategic interests.” 28 Whether one prefers the term “rising power” or “emerging power,” the implication is the same: the geopolitical landscape is shifting, and U.S. policymakers must plan accordingly.