Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Chinese revisionism won’t undermine territorial sovereignty

Griffiths, 16 - Senior Lecturer in the Department of Government and International Relations at the University of Sydney (Ryan D. Griffiths (2016) States, Nations, and Territorial Stability: Why Chinese Hegemony Would Be Better for International Order, Security Studies, 25:3, 519-545, DOI: 10.1080/09636412.2016.1195628

The rise of China has generated a veritable cottage industry of articles and books, and portents and predictions. Will China be content with current international order, or, like many past rising states, aim to revise it? My analysis is guided by the Sandholtz and Stiles cycle model.58 International rule structures are built on power and the appeal to precedent and normative tradition. In imagining a future where China is hegemonic I have sidestepped questions about what disputes may occur along the way, but I can speculate on how a preeminent China would influence the normative order. I argue that it will aim to modify the international order but, importantly, it will not attempt to redraw borders. It will not be revisionist in a territorial sense. I arrive at this conclusion by examining its current preferences with respect to self-determination and territorial integrity, and I contend that these preferences should endure in a time of Chinese hegemony.

With respect to self-determination, Chinese policy has shown a more limited support for minority nations. China recognizes secession when it is consensual, but when the national government in a secessionist crisis denies the aspiring group, China argues that sovereignty should be respected and that the outcome of the struggle should be resolved internally, without interference from the international community.59 Following Kosovo’s declaration of independence, Liu Jianchao, the spokesperson for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, commented:

China always believes that a plan acceptable to both Serbia and Kosovo through negotiations is the best way to resolve this issue. The unilateral move taken by Kosovo will lead to a series of consequences. China is deeply worried about its severe and negative impact on peace and stability of the Balkan region and the goal of establishing a multi-ethnic society in Kosovo. China calls upon Serbia and Kosovo to continue negotiations for a proper resolution within the framework of the international law and work together to safeguard peace and stability of the Balkan region.60

China criticized the United States for recognizing Kosovo and pointed out the danger of precedent setting. Furthermore, China took a similar position on the recent secession of South Sudan; recognition required a formally consensual divorce from greater Sudan.

China’s more austere interpretation of self-determination is motivated, in part, by its domestic concerns over fragmentation. Complete acceptance of self-determination presents a problem for multinational states. China recognizes the rights of stateless nations in the limited sense that they should have greater autonomy. And since 1958 China has recognized five autonomous regions: Ningxia, Tibet, Guangxi, Xinjiang, and Inner Mongolia. The state, however, draws a line with respect to full independence. Despite the periodic conflicts in Tibet and Xinjiang and the international criticism China has received in its handling of those affairs, and despite the potential war that could arise over the Taiwan question, China adamantly defines these issues as internal problems, and it repeatedly invokes the norm of territorial integrity when doing so.

For China there are precedent-setting concerns when recognizing breakaway regions in the absence of government consent, and these concerns are apparent in both the political and popular rhetoric regarding domestic and foreign secessionist movements. One of the arguments for denying Taiwanese independence is to prevent domino effects, since independence there would embolden “the determination of Tibetan, Uighur, and Mongolian separatists.”61 According to Robert Art, “allowing Taiwan to become independent would set a disastrous precedent.”62 In a 2006 speech, Chairman of the National Committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC) Jia Qinglin stated, “we will never tolerate Taiwan Independence. We will unswervingly oppose and curb secessionist forces and their activities.”63 These domestic concerns are visible in public opinion. A recent article in the China Post stated that “Southern Sudan’s nearly certain secession from the Arab-dominated north is likely to set a dangerous precedent in an Arab world looking increasingly fractured along sectarian and ethnic lines.”64

Overall, in a time of Chinese hegemony the recognition of new states would be pinned to state consent and therefore less frequent. China currently interprets the norm in a more constrained manner, and there is little indication that the government has internalized the norm in any meaningful way. In addition, it has frequently disagreed with the United States, and other Western powers, over cases like Kosovo. The norm of self-determination should endure under a preeminent China, but it would be more constrained.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.