Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff’s representation of IR is inherently implicated by gender and sexuality—the ‘perverse homosexual’ in opposition to the ‘sovereign man’

Weber 2016 (Cynthia Weber is a Professor of International Relations at Sussex University, “Queer International Relations – Sovereignty, Sexuality, and the Will to Knowledge”, Chapter 3, Oxford University Press, 2016, accessed 7/17/2022)//sfs

This chapter and the next argue that four figures that consistently appear in the discourse of ‘Western’ / global ‘Northern’ ‘developed’ states as perverse—the ‘underdeveloped’, the ‘undevelopable’, the ‘unwanted immigrant’, and the ‘terrorist’—are among the specific (if surprising) articulations of the ‘perverse homosexual’ in international relations. These particular figurations of the ‘perverse homosexual’ matter for transnational/ global queer studies and international relation because they make possible (by being opposed to) specific figurations of ‘sovereign man’ as ‘(neo) imperial man’ and as ‘(civilizationally) developed man’. All of these figurations of or against ‘sovereign man’ appear to arise out of and in turn produce what Berlant and Warner call heteronormativity, ‘the institutions, structures of understanding, and practical orientations that make heterosexuality seem not only coherent ... but also privileged’ (1998, 548 n. 2). By tracing where, when, and how these ‘perverse homosexuals’ are spoken of in past and ongoing colonial, imperial, and developmental heteronormative discourses that incite them as a concern, stabilize them as a problem, and regulate solutions to the problems they raise through specific policies, these chapters analyze how figurations of the ‘perverse homosexual’ are made to function as instances of ‘statecraft as mancraft’ (Ashley 1989). In these discourses, the ‘perverse homosexual’ is figured as that threat to ‘sovereign man’ who enables the production of (and is produced through) specific order-versus-anarchy binaries. These either/or binaries participate in the regulation of international politics because they establish sexualized orders of international relations. To be clear, I am not arguing that the figure of the ‘homosexual’ as the ‘underdeveloped’, the ‘undevelopable’, the ‘unwanted im/migrant’, and the ‘terrorist’ alone explains all sovereign statecraft as sovereign mancraft. Rather, I am suggesting that if we dig down into the evolutionary theories that produce figurations of and opposed to ‘sovereign man’, what we find is that these theories depend upon understandings of civilization and its relationships to evolutionary time and geopolitical space that are deeply racialized, (dis)ableized, classed, sexed, gendered, and sexualized. This is by no means a new proposition, either empirically or theoretically. For example, even a cursory reading of (neo)imperial discourses and their supporting discourses of racialization makes it explicit that various precursors to and variations of the ‘underdeveloped’ owe their temporal and spatial figurations as perverse in part to how they are coded as perversely sexed, gendered, and sexualized. Institutions and cultural understandings of encumbered versus unencumbered sexuality (Mead 1928), whiteness versus blackness (Fanon 1967), orientalism (Said 1978), savagery and coloniality (Stoler 1995 and 2002), and postcoloniality and imperialism (Spivak 1988) have fueled imaginaries of what came to be known as the ‘underdeveloped’. We see this in figures such as the ‘noble savage’ unencumbered by sexual prohibition in modern Western anthro- pology (Mead 1928), the ‘barbaric savage’ and the ‘colonial’ in Victorian discourse (Stoler 1995 and 2002), the ‘blackman’ marked by race in white colonialism and psychoanalysis (Fanon 1967), ‘the black female body’ (hooks 1982; Hammonds 1999; Spillers 2003), ‘the illiterate peasantry, the tribals, the lowest strata of the urban sub-proletariat’ called the ‘subaltern’ in imperial discourse (Spivak 1988, 283), and ‘the timeless oriental who does not advance with modernity’ in Western discourse (Said 1978), for example. While international relation scholars are increasingly aware of how these figures are produced through complex networks of racialization, (dis) ablization, gender, class, indigeneity, and empire (beginning with Roxanne Doty’s [1996] seminal international relation study of ‘imperial encounters’), they are just beginning to grasp how these figures are also implicated in and produced by complex networks of power/knowledge/pleasure in relation to the figure of the ‘homosexual’. Yet as V. Spike Peterson has long argued (1992, 1999, 2010, 2013, 2014a, 2014b) in her groundbreaking international relation analyses of gender and sexuality, figures like the ‘heterosexual’ and the ‘homosexual’ are foundational to international relation conceptualizations of states, nations, and international politics more widely. My contention in this set of chapters is that figurations of the ‘homosexual’ in Western discourses of statecraft as mancraft and the sexualized organizations of international relations to which they give rise are among those modalities of power/knowledge/pleasure that are the least examined such networks that in part underwrite international relation theories to this day. My suggestion is that to ignore these moves is to not fully understand how international relation theories and practices function, how they can be improved, and how they can be resisted.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.