vote neg to endorse queer hauntology đ»
Freccero 06 (Carla Freccero is Chair of the Department of Literature and Professor of Literature, History of Consciousness, and Womenâs Studies at the University of California, Santa Cruz. January 16 2006, âQueer/Early/Modern,â accessed 7/8/2022, pg. 75-80, IBSN:9780822387169, 0822387166)//sfs
Yet this intertwining of multiple brutal logics of erasure reappears again and again. The historical and political appropriation of ââBrandon Teenaââ as ââknownââ cannot lay to rest the haunting that persistently destabilizes the anchors of identity and meaning. As Halberstam explains, if ââhaunting is an articulate discourseââ and ââa mode within which the ghost demands something like accountability,ââ then ââto tell a ghost story means being willing to be hauntedââ (73). This willingness to be haunted is an ethical relation to the world, motivated by a concern not only for the past but also for the future, for those who live on in the borderlands without a home. If the queer appropriation of ââBrandon Teenaââ has been melancholicâan attempt to deal with trauma, in a sense, by refusing it as such, turning it instead into knowledge, into productive organizingâit has also been colonizing. Both gestures, the melancholic and the colonizing, have worked to foreclose how ââhe,ââ as ghost, recurs in ways that are not so clear, and demands not a definition but the creation of a future where categorical definitions so dependent on gender and desire might prove affirmingly impossible and unnecessary. Using spectrality as a hypothesis, then, we might wonder what we would see and hear were we to remain open to ââBrandon Teenaââ âs ghostly returns. One such moment is the point at which one survivor, finding himself haunted, ââlistensââ to the ghost and speaks its reminder. Matthew Shepardâs homophobically motivated murder occurred in 1998, four years after ââBrandon Teenaââ was killed and the year a documentary of the events The Brandon Teena Storyâwas released; it also occurred four months after the torture and murder of James Byrd in Jasper, Texas, for being African American. In a statement bordering on the wishes thus express themselves from beyond the grave. Tellingly, the ghostly performative ventriloquized by Mr. Shepard, as reported in the Washington Post, interrupts the logic of revenge and retribution animating the force of the law: In a dramatic and surprising end to the Matthew Shepard murder case, convicted killer Aaron J. McKinney, 22, today was sentenced to two life sentences for beating the gay University of Wyoming student to death last year. McKinney accepted a deal brokered by Shepardâs parents just as a jury was about to begin hearing testimony about whether he should be put to death.... His son, Shepard said, believed in the death penalty for certain crimes, and had called it justified in the racially motivated murder in Texas of James Byrd Jr., who was dragged to death behind a pickup truck in another hate crime that shocked the nationâs conscience. ââLittle did we know that the same response would come about involving Matt,ââ Shepard said. ââI too believe in the death penalty,ââ he added. ââI would like nothing better than to see you die, Mr. McKinney. However, this is the time to begin the healing process. To show mercy to someone who refused to show any mercy. ââMr. McKinney, Iâm going to grant you life, as hard as it is for me to do so, because of Matthew . . .ââ18 Ghostly returns are thus a sign of trauma and its mourning.19 This trauma, Derrida argues, is a ââpolitico-logic of trauma,ââ that âârĂ©pond Ă lâinjonction dâune justice qui, au-delĂ du droit, surgit dans le respect mĂȘme de qui nâest pas, nâest plus ou nâest pas encore vivant, prĂ©sentement vivantââ (ââresponds to the injunction of a justice which, beyond right or law, rises up in the very respect owed to whoever is not, no longer or not yet, living, presently livingââ).20 This mourning is not a form of nostalgia, a longing for what is gone, but a kind of mourning that is ââen fait et en droit interminable, sans normalitĂ© possible, sans limite fiable, dans la rĂ©alitĂ© ou dans le concept, entre lâintrojection et lâincorporationââ (160; ââin fact and by right interminable, without possible normality, without reliable limit, in its reality or in its concept, between introjection and incorporation,ââ 97).21 Thinking historicity through haunting thus combines both the seeming objectivity of events and the subjectivity of their affective afterlife. As Wendy Brown remarks of spectralityâs modalityâwhat Derrida calls a ââbeing-with spectersââ that is also ââune politique de la mĂ©moire, de lâhĂ©ritage et des gĂ©nĂ©rationsââ (15; ââa politics of memory, of inheritance, and of generationsââ [xviiiâxix])âââWe inherit not âwhat really happenedâ to the dead but what lives on from that happening, what is conjured from it, how past generations and events occupy the force fields of the present, how they claim us, and how they haunt, plague, and inspirit our imaginations and visions for the future.ââ22 Ghostliness and homosexuality have a long history of association, most frequently referenced in the clichĂ©d and homophobic phrase ââthe specter of homosexuality.ââ In its most virulent deployment, that specter is always lurking in an alley or behind a bush, waiting to pounce upon some unsuspecting innocents. When invoked more sympathetically, it hovers secretively around the edges of an otherwise perfectly straight and openâalbeit presumably anxiousâscene. Indeed, Derrida defines the specter in terms strikingly reminiscent of homosexual panic, the sense of a not-quite-visible contaminating near-presence that is also an anxious, often paranoid projection, the material immateriality I tracked through the term queer in chapter 2: Le spectre, comme son nom lâindique, câest la frĂ©quence dâune certaine visibilitĂ©. Mais la visibilitĂ© de lâinvisible. Et la visibilitĂ©, par essence, ne se voit pas, câest pourquoi elle reste . . . au-delĂ du phĂ©nomĂšne ou de lâĂ©tant. Le spectre, câest aussi, entre autres choses, ce quâon imagine, ce quâon croit voir et quâon projette: sur un Ă©cran imaginaire, lĂ oĂč il nây a rien Ă voir. Pas mĂȘme lâĂ©cran, parfois, et un Ă©cran a toujours, au fond, au fond quâil est, une structure, une structure dâapparition disparaissante. Mais voilĂ quâon ne peut plus fermer lâoeil Ă guetter le retour. (Spectres de Marx, 165) The specter, as its name indicates, is the frequency of a certain visibility. But the visibility of the invisible. And visibility, by its essence, is not seen, which is why it remains . . . beyond the phenomenon, or beyond being. The specter is also, among other things, what one thinks one sees, and which one projectsâon an imaginary screen where there is nothing to see. Not even the screen sometimes, and a screen always has, at bottom, in the bottom or background that is, a structure of disappearing apparition. But now one can no longer get any shut-eye, being so intent to watch out for the return. (Specters of Marx, 101) Like the closet, whose very existence suggests the opening onto what is concealed, Derrida likens the specter to the screen whose structure is always already that of a disappearing appearance. The ghost is thus also structural. Terry Castle observes this phenomenon in relation to the ââapparitionalââ history of the lesbian: ââWhen it comes to lesbians . . . many people have trouble seeing whatâs in front of them. The lesbian remains a kind of âghost effectâ in the cinema world of modern life: elusive, vaporous, difficult to spotâeven when she is there, in plain view, mortal and magnificent, at the center of the screen. Some may even deny that she exists at all.ââ23 For those who live ââon the other sideââ of the expression, ââthe specter of homosexuality,ââ those who might be said to be named, ââghostedââ by that phrase, ghosts are neither scary nor menacing, however terrifying the prospect of being turned into one might be. For one may also reverse the perspective and understand the specter as that which sees without being seen, as what produces the sense of being seen, observed, surveilled.24 HĂ©lĂšne Cixous declared, concerning one famous gynephobic patriarchal figure of woman, ââYou only have to look at the Medusa straight on to see her. And sheâs not deadly. Sheâs beautiful and sheâs laughing.ââ25 To be a ghost among ghosts is to ââseeââ the ghost not as a feared and fearful projectionâthe way Medusa cannot be directly seen by menâbut perhaps as beautiful, though rarely laughing, for the specter is the form a certain unfinished mourning takes. Thus part of what it might mean to live with ghosts would be to understand oneself as ââghosted,ââ and to understand ââlearning to liveââ as something that takes place ââbetween life and deathââ as the âânon contemporaneity with itself of the living present.ââ26 This would then be an approach to historyâand to justiceâthat would neither ââforget the deadââ nor ââsuccessfullyââ mourn them.27 Exploring further the notion of haunting as the way history registers as affect in the social and psychic lives of beings, and the reciprocity of haunting and being haunted, Avery Gordon follows the figure of the ghost and the poetics of haunting in other contexts to understand the specificity of this way of coming to terms with historical trauma.28 Ghostly Matters looks to Toni Morrisonâs Beloved to see how haunting conveys the traumatic effect and affect of the historical event on the subject and the social responsibility that is thereby entailed.29 Thus what Derrida analyzes in the work of Marx and philosophy, Gordon studies in a kind of embodied poetics, tracking how the ghostâs figurative ââmaterializationââ elicits, even as it emblematizes, traumatic repetition and working through.30 In that process of materialization, or poetic embodiment, Hamletâs father undergoes a morphological transformation, from Danish king to African slave and from father to daughter; the ghostly exchange takes place not between a father and his son but between a daughter and her mother; and the ââallegoryââ of haunting moves from Europe to America.31 Like Gordon, in what follows I track a transatlantic passage from an earlier moment and an earlier historical trauma as they haunt both within and outside of their own time. In Premodern Sexualities, Louise Fradenburg and I raised questions concerning the fantasmatic relationship that we, as scholars of the past and scholars working ââqueerlyââ in the history of sexuality, might affirm in relation to the past, ââoursââ or that of others, in the name of pleasure.32 It was an effort, in part, to honor the complex pleasure positivity of queer theory in its resistance to the heteronormatively disciplining discourses that came self-righteously to the fore when aids in the United States became associated with ââhomosexualsââ and ââpromiscuity.ââ It was also a way of examining how desires and identificationsâqueer theoryâs psychoanalytically inflected terminological legaciesâare at work in historical scholarsâ investments in the differences and similarities between the past and the present. Finally, it was a way of noting historiographyâs own (self-)disciplining force, its âârepudiations of pleasure and fantasyââ in spiteâor becauseâof its queer wishes (xvii); thus we argued for a queer historiography that would devote itself to a critical revalorization of the places and possibilities of pleasure within the serious and ââasceticââ work of history. Insofar as queer historicism registers the affective investments of the present in the past, however, it harbors within itself not only pleasure, but also pain, a traumatic pain whose ethical insistence is to ââlive to tellââ through complex and circuitous processes of working through. Thus we concluded the introduction with an ethically impelled wish: The past may not be the present, but it is sometimes in the present, haunting, even if only through our uncertain knowledges of it, our hopes of surviving and living well. The questions we are raising about the practice of history may help us understand better the living and dying of twentieth-century bodies and pleasures. And we hope that consideration of the ways in which historicisms are currently questioning sexuality, and sex studies questioning historicism, will work to affirm the pleasures of mortal creatures. (xxi) The past is in the present in the form of a haunting. This is what, among other things, doing a queer kind of history means, since it involves an openness to the possibility of being haunted, even inhabited, by ghosts. What is transmitted in the cohabitation of ghostly past and present is related to survival, to ââliving well,ââ and to the ââpleasures of mortal creatures,ââ survivals and pleasures that have little to do with normative understandings of biological reproduction.