“queering IR” creates cracks in the boundaries that allows us to imagine the world in terms other than nationalism
Kangas et al 18 (Anni Kangas, Tampere University, Tampere University School of Management, Faculty Member. Daria Krivonos, inna Perheentupa, Saara Sarma. International Feminist Journal of Politics, Volume 21, 2019 - Issue 3, 11-28-18. “Smashing containers, queering the international through collaging,” accessed 07-21-2022)//sfs
The term queer lacks a straightforward definition. While there are multiple queer traditions, it is possible to argue that three key components underpin most queer perspectives: queer theory, radical activism and gender or gay/lesbian studies (Wickman 2016). However, the term queer is not just another signifier of sexual difference; as a social science notion, it is a broader notion than a synonym for non-heterosexuals. Halberstam argues that queer should be used to mark radical models of sexual politics, “it is important to resist using [it] as an umbrella term for sexual minorities” (Halberstam 2000, 632) or as “an object to be studied” as Richter-Montpetit emphasizes. The radical contingency of queer perspectives distinguishes them from those LGBT perspectives that assume that a (liberal) rights-seeking subject is pre-formed before entering the political field. Refusing to assume such a stable subject, queer perspectives are able to inquire into subject-making as a political process. While sexuality, gender and desire are seen to play a normalizing role in this process, they are examined as a part of wider power relations. This extends IR queer inquiries to also address questions related to racism, imperialism, transphobia, and so on (Richter-Montpetit 2018). The fact that queering is not limited to theorizing sexual identifications is crucial for the attempt to smash containers (Wilcox 2014). We understand queering as a way of thinking and doing – or an analytical category – that resists “proper objects” and avoids exclusionary moves that could be made to signify monolithically (Richter-Montpetit and Weber 2017). Sjoberg characterizes queer as something that is unsettleable, uncaging and engaged in projects of destruction (Sjoberg 2014, 608). The theme of smashing is also present in Richter-Montpetit’s (2018, 3) argument that queer analytics “crack open for investigation” such dimensions of social life and international politics that have been overlooked or misunderstood by mainstream approaches: “Queer analytics have produced insights not only on the political character of sexual norms and logics, but also offer a more expansive notion of the political in IR” (Richter-Montpetit 2018, 3; see also Wilcox 2016). We argue in this article that collaging provides one possibility to acknowledge and visualize such a more expansive notion of the political. Collaging is a form of inquiry that can make visible alternative spaces of justice across various power political dividing lines, spaces that are relational, multiscalar and non-fixed. Arguably, this enables moving beyond forms of methodological nationalism that take nation-states as containers for analysis (see also Wimmer and Schiller 2002). National imaginaries can dominate analyses of sexuality and gender, for example, by creating binary oppositions between “gender equal” vs. “traditional” national societies. At classes where collages were made, we also discussed the ways in which methodologically nationalist thinking easily forms part of debates on the politics of sexuality and how such debates often assume certain binaries. However, the politics of gender and sexuality are frequently analyzed through, within or across national framings. Despite Lauren Berlant and Elizabeth Freeman’s suggestion that queer theorizing’s consent to national normativity must be made provisional (Berlant and Freeman 1993), this may also be the case in queer studies (e.g., Essig 1999). In these discussions, similarities within nationally defined groups are emphasized and differences are identified across state borders. Space is thought about in absolute terms, as a container: it is seen to contain things in the same way as any container contains things. As Berlant and Warner emphasize, queer theorizing challenges us here: It prompts imagining the “world” in terms other than containers, such as established communities or groups: “The queer world is a space of entrances, exits, unsystematized lines of acquaintance, projected horizons, typifying examples, alternate routes, blockages, incommensurate geographies” (Berlant and Warner 1998, 558). Collaging, as we argue in this article, enables crafting such a world into being. The point of the collaging exercise is not to deny the power and influence of states and nation-states in the politics of gender and sexuality but rather to see and imagine other spaces of justice across and beyond national borders. Despite this, some of the collages reproduce the idea of a nation-state as the framework within which politics of gender and sexuality are examined. As one of the participants of the workshop (to be discussed later on) wrote, in my collage, I critiqued the narrow role reserved for Finnish women and the heteronormative assumptions – as well as the assumption of whiteness. But I did not for a minute problematize the fact that by doing that I actually took an imaginary “nation” as the subject of my collage. In the next section we discuss the epistemological potential of collages to trouble container images.