Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Exclusion DA--Disciplinary International Relations excludes queer perspectives

Weber 14 (Cynthia Weber, Professor of International Relations at Sussex University, European Journal of International Relations 04-03-2014, “Why is there no Queer International Theory?,” http://ejt.sagepub.com/content/early/2014/04/02/1354066114524236)//sfs

My claim is that the presumed non-existence of Queer International Theory cannot be explained merely by its absence from prestigious IR journals and book series because this absence is the (un)conscious effect of how so-called Disciplinary IR codes various types of theory as failures. ‘Disciplinary IR’ — which aspires to be but is not equivalent to the discipline of IR as a whole — is, of course, as imagined as it is enacted, and it changes as social, cultural, economic, and political forces change. Yet, at any particular historical moment, IR scholars have a working knowledge of Disciplinary IR because it embodies the general commitments and standards that regulate, manage, and normalize ‘the conduct of conduct’ (Foucault, 1994: 237) regarding IR publishing, funding, hiring, promotion, and tenure decisions. While there are certainly institutional and national variations in how these standards are enacted (Hoffmann, 1977; Waever, 1998), most IR academics are required to justify their work with regard to these standards at some point in their careers.

Disciplinary IR’s commitments and standards are as much the performative result of so-called ‘mainstream’ agendas of learned societies, universities, independent funding agencies, and governments that support socially, culturally, economically, or politically ‘policy-relevant,’ ‘useful,’ or ‘impactful’ research as they are the performative outcome of so-called ‘dissident’ practices (Ashley and Walker, 1990; also see Soreanu, 2010) that seek to rewrite, resist, or rebel against so-called mainstream agendas, be they ‘scientific,’ ‘positivist,’ or ‘neoliberal,’ for example. Together, these intricately intertwined positions produce a Disciplinary IR that claims to speak for the whole of the discipline of IR because it wields sufficient power to (de)legitimate IR scholars and their work for many user communities. Because of its power, Disciplinary IR is as often contested as it is assimilated to by IR scholars of virtually all intellectual dispositions.4

A central tenet of what I am calling Disciplinary IR is embedded in the work of Martin Wight. Wight claimed that for international theorizing to succeed, it must accumulate knowledge about interstate relations (Smith, 2000; Wight, 1966). My claim is that from a Disciplinary IR perspective, theories — including queer international theories — fail because they are judged not to be making progress toward this goal. This is what explains the subsequent absence of queer international theories from prestigious IR journals and book series and the presumed non-existence of Queer International Theory.

To substantiate this claim, I investigate how Disciplinary IR employs three strategies — homologization, figuration, and gentrification — to make it appear as if there is no Queer International Theory. Homologization describes the act of using a homology to describe relationships, relative positions, and structures in a set of elements in order to prescribe how relationships ought to be ordered and how elements and their aims ought to be valued (e.g. Wight, 1966).5 Figuration describes the act of employing semiotic tropes that combine knowledges, practices, and power to shape how we map our worlds and understand actual things in those worlds (Haraway, 1997). Gentrification describes the replacement of mix with homogeneity while pretending difference and privilege do not exist (Schulman, 2012b).

My analysis is grounded in Martin Wight’s famous homology: ‘Politics is to International Politics as Political Theory is to Historical Interpretation’ (Wight, 1966).This is not only because Wight’s homology illustrates and/or authorizes homologization, figuration, and gentrification. It is also because Wight’s homology elegantly encapsulates how Disciplinary IR has traditionally thought of itself since its formation in the wake of the First World War — as separate but parallel to the discipline of politics and as capable of achieving its aim to produce unique cumulative knowledge about international politics only if it models itself on how political theory is practiced. In the 1960s, Wight mobilized this generalized view to make his case for a historical approach to the study of IR — both as a participant in the first ‘great debate’ over method and methodology between traditionalists and behavioralists and as a historian who founded an International Relations department. This in part accounts for Wight’s contentious claim that international theory can only succeed if it transforms itself into historical interpretation and his contentious placement of the term ‘Historical Interpretation’ in the place one would expect to find the term ‘International Theory’ in his homology. IR debates about methodology and history have certainly moved on since Wight’s time (e.g. Lapid, 1989; Rosenberg, 2006). Even so, the values and relationships expressed in Wight’s homology are still widely accepted in Disciplinary IR, to the point that Wight’s homology remains a generalizable guide to regulating how international theorizing ought to be conducted.

Beginning with Martin Wight’s homology, I trace how Wight’s strategy of homologization equates international theory and the discipline of International Relations with failure, authorizes the figuration of specific types of international theory and specific ways of producing international theory as failures, and embraces a gentrified strategy of substitution as a legitimate response to these failures. Applying these logics to queer international theories, I suggest that homologization, figuration, and gentrification combine to make it appear as if there is no Queer International Theory. In so doing, they authorize the discipline of IR (on Disciplinary IR’s behalf) to dismiss queer international theories as International Theory, resulting in negative consequences not only for the scholars who produce this type of work, but for the discipline of IR as a whole.

I conclude by reflecting on the costs of using Wight’s homology to regulate, manage, and normalize the scholarly conduct of international theorizing — for queer international theories and for the discipline of IR as a whole. I argue that while most scholars in the discipline (un)consciously embrace Wight’s homology as their guide to disciplinary success, my analysis of Queer International Theory reveals that Wight’s homology has three detrimental effects on the discipline: it limits how international politics is enriched by critical inquiry, it cedes consideration of key international phenomena to other disciplines, and it paradoxically leads to disciplinary failure on the discipline’s own terms.

Because the case of Queer International Theory illustrates how Disciplinary IR manages not just queer international theories, but all theories that profess to be International Theory, generalizable lessons can be drawn from this case for the discipline as a whole. Primary among these is that IR’s disciplinary attachment to Wight’s homology compromises possibilities for doing international theorizing and thinking international politics not only on terms the discipline rejects, but on terms the discipline embraces.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.