Homonationalism DA – the perm is a thinly veiled attempt to include queer theorizing in IR when in reality it recreates Homonationalism
Nayak 14 – PhD in Political Science at University of Minnesota and an Associate Professor at Pace University [Meghana, December 2014, Thinking About Queer International Relations’ Allies. International Studies Review, doi: 10.1111/misr.12188, Wiley]
What does it mean to be an ally to not only communities mobilizing for justice but also to a field of study/scholars? I contend that this question is vital and pivotal as we try to grapple with Queer International Relations (IR)/Global Queer Studies’ relationship with the IR discipline. In the context of academic institutions and practices, I see “allies” as those who may not regularly cite, rely upon, study, teach, or participate in a particular field of studies but are interested and invested in the development and endurance of that scholarship. But what is done to and with Queer IR by allies? Are ally politics aiming to deconstruct, dismantle, and radically transform the very systems of which they are beneficiaries? Or are allies leaving power relationships intact because they are actually uneasy with, dismissive of, or unclear about Queer IR theorizing? Scholars working in queer studies, critical race studies, or on allegedly “peripheral” topics have increasingly questioned the politics of their so-called allies, among students, faculty, administration, and the profession as a whole (Carver 2009; Ahmed 2012; Gutierrez y Muhs, Niemann, Gonzalez, and Harris 2012). Perhaps, for some, being an ally means establishing queer-friendly credentials, so they might support the work of a scholar who does Queer IR or devote a week of attention in their IR class to Global Queer Studies to illustrate the “diversity” of IR theories. Or, they might enfold Queer IR insights within slightly “safer” research agendas, such as “human rights.” But how far are they willing to go in creating space for Queer IR to challenge how IR is performed, or how marginalized scholars are treated as different, anomalies, and incompetent? Anecdotal evidence reveals that scholars doing Queer IR, like other marginalized academics, face troubling encounters on blogs and Facebook pages, in conferences, job search committees, tenure and promotion committees, and reviews of journal articles and manuscripts. These interactions include thinly veiled homophobia or transphobia, scornful dismissal of queer studies as “not rigorous enough” or “not legitimate,” and attempts to make deviant and intolerable those doing Queer IR (Weber 2014b). But “well meaning” self-proclaimed allies in fields such as Feminist IR, Global Politics, or Postcolonial IR may also participate in acts of exclusion and dismissal, even as these very scholars may find their allies, including in queer studies, “don’t get it.” In interrogating resistance by not only those adamantly opposed to but also alleged/potential allies of Queer IR, I have been contemplating Queer IR’s promise (and threat) of revealing the instability of IR as a discipline. I contend that it is not just in the mainstream-alternative approaches debate but also in the acts of alleged solidarity and support that we see how tenuously IR operates. My hope is that we do a better job in interrogating ally politics among and between various communities of scholars. In my classes, I have unsurprisingly discovered that many of my students hold a perception that there is a difference between international LGBTQ activism and Queer IR theory. The latter, they claim, is “elitist” and inaccessible. Many queer or allied students see themselves and their struggles as intimately connected with queerness, circumscribed as identity politics or the implementation of rights for “sexual minorities.” When we discuss examples of gay rights movements or trans-rights movements around the world, they respond favorably, understanding such attempts for social justice within a human-rights framework of perpetrator/victim. But when I assign readings that I think of as Queer IR/ Global Studies, regarding homonationalism (Puar 2005, 2007), postcolonial and global antiracist engagement with queerness (Hawley 2001), and heteronormative and cis-normative ontologies underlying global politics and statecraft (Cohn 1987; Weber 1994a,b, 1998a,b, 1999, 2002, 2014a; Richter-Montpetit 2007; Agathangelou et al. 2008; Canaday 2011; Rao 2012; Sjoberg, this forum), many (not all) students see the work, or at least parts of it, as divisive, inaccessible, and even “dangerous” for the “real struggles” of queer communities. It is not uncommon that students may cling to a perceived praxis/theory divide. I see it when I teach feminist theory and try to push past discussions on sexual violence prevention or reproductive rights to also include postcolonial or black feminist theory. I see it when I teach human rights and try to move the conversation beyond successful international criminal legal cases to questioning the very premises of human rights discourses. A significant number of students are indeed willing to sit with the discomfort of acting toward justice while simultaneously questioning and challenging what motivates and counts as “action” and “justice.” However, the students who show resistance want to see IR as a field with terminology, jargon, and “skills” to master so that they can “do something” in the real world to protect people from persecution and harm. Anything else seems too negative, too threatening to their relationship to the IR discipline, which to them holds the promise of allowing them to “understand” global politics and to become career professionals in changing the world. The same students who might excitedly read Feminist IR scholarship or human rights work on sexual minorities, balk or seem taken aback when I mention Queer IR or Queer Global Studies, thinking that this scholarship belongs in some strange, otherworldly “theory” universe. Yet, they would call themselves allies, or part of the “movement” for LGBTQ rights.Optional card—can also be an impact to the K