Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

A commission on bioethics solves dual use – guidelines, research, and framework for development

Childress 17 – professor of ethics at the University of Virginia, founder of the Insitute for Practical Ethics and Public life, author of books and articles in bioethics, served on the National Bioethics Advisory Commission until 2001 [James F. “The Bioethical Approach: The President should establish a commission on bioethics.” UVA Miller Center for Public Policy. May 9, 2017]

In his first year, President Donald Trump should develop a charter for, assign priorities to, and establish by executive order a new presidential commission on bioethics. Even though its membership should be diverse in background, experience, and expertise, it is reasonable for the president to set up a commission that is generally congenial to his administration’s values. The commission’s main function will be to provide advice and counsel to the president. It can also report directly to federal departments and agencies and to congressional committees. Further, its meetings and reports can contribute to public discourse and education about bioethics.

Doing so will build on the best practices of previous presidents, who have used such outside guidance to address complex ethical challenges in the biological sciences, medicine, and health care. The new president can choose from several options in how to design such a commission, and which topics to address. But having such a commission will ensure that thoughtful examination will guide emerging technologies.

Public bioethics is . . . vitally important.

While bioethics, a term coined in 1970, has various meanings, a primary definition features ethical reflection and judgment regarding the biological sciences, medicine, and health care. Bioethical reflection and judgment often focus directly on such activities as clinical care, but public bioethics is also vitally important. It focuses on public policies, many of which fall under the auspices of the executive branch, particularly the office of the president of the United States, who may direct departments and agencies to consider and develop policies on bioethical topics. Many of these initiatives will also involve interactions with Congress and the courts. In addition to public policies, the president may also have a significant impact on public discourse and education in bioethics, which may in turn shape public policies.

Sign warning of ebola virus

In the event of a public health crisis such as a Ebola pandemic, the president should develop ethically acceptable public health policies and practices.

The president’s priorities should include ensuring the retention and implementation of recently updated rules and guidelines for protecting human research participants and, at the same time, facilitating important research; developing a framework for ethically acceptable public health policies and practices in the event of public health crises such as pandemics of Ebola and the Zika virus; and moving forward the still evolving societal and public policy discussion about human gene editing. Each of these subjects involves questions about how best to protect individual liberties while promoting the common good. In addition, other emergent ethical problems, occasioned by scientific and technological breakthroughs, can be helpfully addressed by a presidential bioethics commission just as the advent of human cloning, human embryonic stem cell research, and synthetic biology required the attention of one or more of the last three commissions.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.