Unsustainable
Ray Cooper, 21, 7-9-2021, Farmers Trapped in Unsustainable Cycle by Biotechnology, Seed Consolidation, National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, https://sustainableagriculture.net/blog/farmers-trapped-in-unsustainable-cycle-by-biotechnology-seed-consolidation/, 6-28-2022
To remain profitable, multinational agribusiness companies must generate and maintain a constant state, or at least a general trend, of overproduction and depressed commodity prices. Input suppliers, including biotechnology and seed corporations, can sell their patented products to a client (farmers) always seeking to expand their operations. Meanwhile, on the other end of harvest season, a concentrated number of food processors are able to purchase commodities for a price driven down by excess supply.
To illustrate the relationship, the following chart demonstrates that corn yields increased rapidly during the decades that these corporations amassed profit and influence – multiplying almost 600 percent since the mid-century dawn of the age of industrial agriculture and consolidation.
It is important to acknowledge that farmers may indeed experience lucrative years and rising commodity prices, often due to increased demand from international export markets. This is an exception, however; it is not a rule. While farmers win on occasion in this system, it is always as the industry collectively spirals downward.
Farmers who seek to permanently raise the price of commodities and otherwise elevate their share of the food dollar find themselves trapped. Realistically, corn farmers have few options to cut their input costs with an industry as consolidated as seed and biotechnology. They need to purchase the genetically engineered seed designed to withstand the herbicides, pesticides, and synthetic fertilizer which they have used for many growing seasons – but use of these chemicals and additional industrial practices, including mechanical tilling, erode soil nutrients until non-GE strands may no longer be able to maintain yields. The conventional farmer is not able to simply save and replant GE seed to save input costs either, for it is protected under utility patent law.
Similar to the biotechnology and seed industry, the farm equipment sector is highly consolidated. Four companies, chief among them John Deere, control at least 45 percent of global farm machinery sales. The farmer who decides to increase their yield to make up for lost income from falling prices may purchase new, productivity enhancing technologies from these companies. Because this decision is invariably made by thousands of farmers every planting season, with everyone reasonably aiming to stabilize their bottom line, a renewed downward pressure on prices is created. “The lower prices, in turn,” according to Darryl E. Ray in a 2003 University of Tennessee report, “become further incentives to adopt more cost-reducing technologies, and prices continue their slide.”
Unless farmers are able to adopt sustainable farming practices or radically alter their business models, they will continue to rely on these patented products year after year, sending half of the checks they write to increase the balance sheets of these corporations.
John Deere’s revenue growth consistently outperforms farm incomes, even as they rise and fall together. Large equipment manufacturers even use patents to prevent farmers from repairing their own heavy machinery (which is more damaging to soil health than previously thought) using independent repair technicians, or continuing to maintain equipment that is no longer supported by the manufacturer. This multiplies the profit streams for companies and perpetuates the need for farmers to continue to invest in the newest available equipment.
The imbalance does not stop there. In recent years, these industries have been acquiring data technology companies to create programs like Monsanto’s Climate View, now owned by Bayer. Farmers who participate in the program supply harvest field data through the sensors on combines manufactured by John Deere and AgCo, which together control 70 percent of the U.S. combine industry, and receive prescriptions sent back to the combine advising farmers which Bayer products to purchase to maximize their yields.
In his recent book, Perilous Bounty, Tom Philpott recounts an interview with an ex-Monsanto executive who “painted a future in which farmers would essentially outsource their decisions to Monsanto, or at least rely on the company to narrow their choices dramatically… This could empower farmers to make better decisions,” he continued, “but the farmers’ interests and the industry’s don’t necessarily align.”
Contrary to the vision of these corporate executives, basic economics instructs that limiting supply would cause commodity prices that farmers receive to rise. The industry, however, is unable to self-correct because no platform exists for all farmers – who are in competition with one another – to agree to cut production in a given year. Even if that scaled coordination were possible, farmers might be pressured to maintain or expand production to justify past investments in heavy machinery or other inputs, and to avoid furloughing staff and laborers. Further, the design of federal crop insurance and commodity programs currently incentivize the maintenance of conventional farming models and levels of production.
Federal crop insurance and commodity programs are designed to maximize yields, directly serving the interests of multinational agribusiness corporations who profit from maintaining a state of overproduction. These subsidies enable the biggest industrial operations to get bigger at the expense of smaller producers, as benefits are siphoned to a limited number of commodity crops and a relatively small number of farmers. The artificial absence of risk for these farmers, as well as bias against alternative operations from financial lending institutions, inhibits what motivation might otherwise exist to adopt diversified production systems as a risk management strategy.
That is why agribusiness lobbyists work to preserve federal support that reduces crop insurance premiums and prevents payment limitations to commodity subsidies. This arrangement maintains the incentive for farmers to overproduce, while also enabling these agribusinesses to signal that their relationship with farmers is indeed symbiotic, rather than parasitic. In reality, however, the public benefits of commodity programs are funneling potential resources away from farms and rural communities. Currently, any farmer or landowner – even multimillionaires and billionaires not actively engaged in farming – can receive unlimited premium subsidies.
As an added consequence, these programs have been fundamental to the acceleration of rural depopulation and the consolidation of farmland. This places small and mid-sized farms, or other low-resource, beginning, and BIPOC farmers, at a competitive disadvantage when it comes to buying land. According to a study by agricultural economists from Cornell University and the University of Illinois, crop insurance contributed to a four to nine percent increase in forage and rangeland values. Another study that looked only at the impacts of direct payments eliminated by the 2014 Farm Bill, found that those payments caused an increase of about $18 per acre in cropland value.
To demonstrate one facet of the impacts of farmland consolidation, 40 percent of farmland in the United States was rented from landowners in 2017. Farmers who do not own but only rent farmland are, sensibly, wary against sinking heavy investments into land which they may be asked to leave at the end of any contract period. This particularly affects small and mid-sized, BIPOC, and beginning farmers who do not have the resources to purchase land at inflated prices. This effectively traps the next generation of farmers and would-be innovators, limiting them to adhere to conventional and unsustainable practices supported by existing farm infrastructure, or only modest and transferable investments.