Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Impact on BIPOC farmers

Ray Cooper, 21, 7-9-2021, Farmers Trapped in Unsustainable Cycle by Biotechnology, Seed Consolidation, National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, https://sustainableagriculture.net/blog/farmers-trapped-in-unsustainable-cycle-by-biotechnology-seed-consolidation/, 6-28-2022

To many, the advent of the modern seed and biotechnology industry represents the pinnacle of benevolent ingenuity for our food system.

There are certainly conversations to have about the role genetically engineered crops play in increasing yields and boosting productivity of agricultural land per-acre through the reduction of crop loss. However, just as important but less present in mainstream conversations is a frank consideration about whether those gains can be justified given the adverse, long-term impacts that conventional farming has on people, animals, and the land.

When these conversations are better informed by the growing number of studies which point to the benefits of sustainable farming models, as well as its scaleable potential, we are compelled to ask: “Is the status quo worth defending?”

It could be, if the power imbalance between farmers, rural communities, and multinational corporations did not breed adverse consequences for the former. Recall that seed was once treated as public property and openly shared – not only in the 1800s, but for millennia on this continent by Indigenous people. In addition, integrated crop-livestock systems kept pests and weeds at bay while limiting soil disturbance to preserve the microbial community and prevent erosion, among other restorative benefits for soil health. No rising input costs or potentially dangerous chemicals were necessary, unlike today.

In 2019, U.S. farmers spent $118 billion to purchase seed and plants, fertilizers, animal feed, and agricultural chemicals. The cost of total farm input expenditures has increased almost $80 billion since 2009, a classic symptom of an industry that has become too concentrated. Bayer, Corteva, Limagrain, Chem-China, and BASF exclude competitors with control of at least 50 percent of the seed and agrochemicals markets by raising the price of inputs for farmers (including with a novel “technology fee”) without risking their own market dominance.

To strictly analyze the cost of seed, consider that corn farmers who paid $26.65 per planted acre of seed in 1990 paid $93.48 in 2019. This represents a dramatic increase of roughly 350 percent, beyond the rate of inflation, following the biotechnology merger-mania and the co-opting of the seed industry.

Health and human consequences compound this financial loss, with all such liabilities externalized by multinational corporations and placed upon farmers and consumers. In 2015, the International Agency for Research on Cancer classified the active ingredient in Bayer’s Roundup, glyphosate, as “probably carcinogenic to humans.” Farmers and farmworkers in proximity to glyphosate are potentially at-risk, as are consumers who consume GE food with glyphosate residue. Though glyphosate has since been banned or limited in dozens of countries, the Environmental Protection Agency re-approved Roundup to be used in the United States last year – even as lawsuits from 46,800 plaintiffs alleged personal injury from exposure to Bayer’s glyphosate-based products.

Bayer insisted that they would “defend the safety of glyphosate… vigorously.” Then, in February 2021 Bayer announced a $2 billion settlement to cover claims from individuals who developed cancer after being exposed to Roundup. This settlement, reached in private arbitration, is not an admission of guilt. Roundup not only remains on the market but is still the weedkiller favored by farmers. What else would conventional farmers use with their Roundup Ready seed?

Genetically engineered seed has indeed taken over. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) reports that GE soybeans comprise a stunning 94 percent of all soybeans planted in the United States, GE cotton accounts for 94 percent of all cotton planted, and 92 percent of corn planted was GE corn. The multinational corporations that produce and market these GE seed varieties do not only place their products on the market but remove non-GE varieties of seed inherited from acquired seed companies. The result has been an alarming reduction in farmer choice – despite the illusion of many unique seed brands – as well as the decimation of crop biodiversity.

In 1983, a report by the Rural Advancement Foundation International (RAFI-USA) revealed that the United States lost 93 percent of its agricultural genetic diversity in the twentieth century. That was before the consolidation of the seed and biotechnology industries in the mid-1990s, and nationally the trend has continued. This genetic uniformity poses a significant threat to the U.S. food supply. The more that the agriculture sector relies on a few uniform, patented seed varieties, the more susceptible these conventional farms become to epidemic pathogens or unexpected climate events. (We saw what happened during the Dust Bowl when traditional foodways were replaced with industrial, monocrop farming.)

Rather than elevating the long-term resilience and security of our food system, a 2019 AGree report notes that “the tendency for farmers to specialize production to only a few commodities presents risks in the event of any type of shock (e.g., extreme weather, disease or pest outbreaks, price cycles, market fluctuations, etc.).”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.