Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Soil destruction decimates food security – lowers production, raises prices, and causes cascading insecurity

Pozza and Field 20 – Research Associate at the the University of Sydney Institute of Agriculture and School of Life and Environmental Sciences; Professor of Global Soil Security & Soil Science Education at the Unviersity of Sydeny [Liana E.; Damien, J. “The Science of Soil Secuirty and Food Security” ScienceDirect. 11/11/2020.]

Without secure soil, nutritious food will be much harder to produce into the foreseeable future, and how we access food influences the relationship individuals and communities have with the soil. To visually demonstrate this, it is possible to map the relationship between Food and Nutrition security and Soil Security, in line with a subset of the UN Sustainable Development Goals (Fig. 4).

Fig 4 ommited

Fig. 4. Soil Security and the nexus between global existential challenges and UN sustainable development goals. SDGs highlighted in blue refer to goals common to both Soil Security and Food Security.

The realisation of Sustainable Development Goals (UN General Assembly, 2015) has been a major step in placing the importance of soil care on the international agenda. Soil directly relates to seven of the goals, with the remainder indirectly related through the contribution of soil to ecosystem services (Keesstra et al., 2016). Those indicated by blue boxes within Fig. 4 are goals which are related to both soil and food, and thus highlight areas in which interactions between Soil Security and Food and Nutrition Security lie. In this section we delve deeper into such interactions which provide the basis of addressing key issues.

Natural factors such as climatic and environmental systems, and anthropogenic factors such as socioeconomic and political systems affect the interaction between Food Security and Soil Security; the perceived strength of these interactions are identified in Table 1. Degree of interaction was based upon intensity of literature findings and how the different dimensions are discussed. For example, a paper discussing soil salinity and cropping is strongly related because food availability is heavily dependent upon the condition of the soil. If interactions were strong, they were denoted with an Asterix. Under each of the Food and Nutrition security dimensions we discuss systematically the interaction with Soil Security dimensions.

Table 1. omitted

5.1. Availability

Food production and forecasting is dependent upon understanding the capability (moderate interaction, Table 1) of the soil to support certain agricultural systems and functions. If the soil is unable to support production, human intervention is often used to overcome this, for example through irrigation, the addition of fertiliser, or application of soil amendments. To reduce the need for human intervention and inputs over time, agricultural uses for the soil, where possible, should be tailored to the soil type, or its capability, based upon what the soil is able to support, rather than the other way around. This may sometimes be easier said than done, as land use or management decisions may be politically motivated or driven by commodification, often overriding best land management practices. To achieve a shift is possible but will require a concerted effort from all levels who derive their wealth from the land – be it individuals, organisations, or government.

Land suitability assessment is a useful approach to ensure the soil is suited to its intended use, but the soil may be suitable for multiple production systems, potentially leading to competition between the different production systems – a common dilemma today (Tilman et al., 2009). A possible way to help inform policy and reduce the chance of conflicting interests is by mapping of land versatility (Kidd et al., 2015), which is influenced by the capability and condition of the soil. To ensure fair decisions on land management and prevent negatively impacting upon the soil, cooperation and communication is required between all stakeholders to develop fair policy and support those working on and living off the land.

As identified in the review of Food Security publications earlier, production of food for the rapidly growing population is partially addressed by a move towards agricultural intensification. This intensification is possible by increased application of synthetic fertilisers and pesticides, and the selection of higher-yielding crop varieties, often grown as a monoculture (Matson et al., 1997). The consequence in some areas has been the decline in the soils condition (strong interaction, Table 1), including loss of soil structure, erosion, nutrient depletion and loss of biodiversity in the soil (Tsiafouli et al., 2015). Decline in soil condition in turn impacts upon agricultural productivity and diminishes natural ecosystem services the landscape provides (Squire et al., 2015). To maintain ecosystem services and the condition of the soil, rather than focussing on a single system, a broader landscape approach is needed to allow for multiple systems and crops to coexist on the land and preserve the condition of the soil (Lal, 2020; Landis, 2017; Pretty et al., 2018).

The value of land is based on relative land prices, the production potential and/or land evaluation approaches. Land evaluation and natural capital assessment (weak interaction, Table 1) often only takes the above-ground component of soil (i.e. the production potential) into account, resulting in the soil being undervalued and overlooked in key management and policy decisions (Hewitt et al., 2015). Being overlooked and not realising the full value of soil can lead to land degradation, reduced productivity and economic losses. This is illustrated by Kidd et al. (2015) who uses a gross margin approach estimate the value derived from soil. This estimates the value of agriculturally productive and effectively, but drastically underestimates the world heritage protected National park that covers much of the west of the state of Tasmania and provides significant ecosystem and recreational services.

A multi-functional approach to evaluation of land through the soil is more comprehensive (Dominati et al., 2010). The annual value of the soil based on its extensive contribution to ecosystem services has been estimated a USD$11.38 trillion by McBratney et al. (2017b). We most commonly view soil based upon its production value, but we need to move beyond this if we want to secure food availability for the future.

Food availability is inextricably linked to the relationship the grower has with the land and how much control they have over management decisions (sovereignty) (moderate interaction; Table 1). The degree of sovereignty is driven by the type of tenure and ownership the farmer possesses over the land. Land tenure regulates how the land is used, and the rights of the grower to control and earn a living from agricultural production (Ashley, 2016). If tenure is short or insecure, farmers will be less likely to invest time and money into soil conservation, new technology, and sustainable cropping systems (Besley, 1995; Fraser, 2004; Lovo, 2016).

Landscapes with soil capable of sustaining agro-ecosystems are diminishing around the world, due to desertification, degradation, and urban expansion (Pacheco et al., 2018). With the aim to prevent further degradation, numerous countries have taken measures to govern (strong interaction, Table 1) land use through the establishment of a land classification system, for example Land Environments of New Zealand classification (LENZ; Manaaki Whenua – Landcare Research (2019)), Biophysical Strategic Agricultural Land (BSAL; NSW Government (2019)), and the Provisional Agricultural Land Classification in England and Wales (ALC; Natural England, 2019). These guidelines have been established for differing reasons; in Australia the aim of BSAL is to protect arable land from mining, New Zealand's classification system has been established to protect biodiversity and England's Agricultural land classification has been established to protect arable land from urban expansion.

Urban expansion in many regions is uncontrolled or favoured over agricultural production (Hu et al., 2018; Radwan et al., 2019). To ensure food availability and associated ecosystem services for the future, rather than burying arable land under concrete and moving on we need to explore alternatives. The concept of land degradation neutrality aims to maintain a stable source of ecosystem services and food production, either by preventing degradation and loss, or reversing degradation (Cowie et al., 2018). Degraded sites are a result of overexploitation and are areas in which the soil quality has diminished or heavily eroded beyond economical use (Behrend, 2016), or the site could be heavily contaminated. By remediating heavily degraded land per hectare of valuable land lost, we are on the path to maintaining stable food production and ecosystem services.

5.2. Access (direct)

In this paper we consider people's access to food either indirectly through their local market or supermarket (indirect), or they may be smallholder/subsistence farmer (direct).

For subsistence farmers and their families, access to food is directly related to the capability of the soil (weak interaction, Table 1). If the soil is of poor quality, unable to support diverse crops, or if their allotment is simply not large enough, farmers and their families will not have access to a sufficient quantity and quality of food. This stress may be alleviated if farmers have access to markets, however those in rural or remote areas may not.

The condition of the soil (weak interaction, Table 1) ensuring sufficient access involves the adopting of sustainable management and adapting to the changing climate and is achievable, but more work and support is needed to aid the adoption of these practices (Chivasa, 2019; Yahaya et al., 2018). If not addressed, and if the changes in condition are significant enough, irreversible changes to soil capability may occur, impacting ability to adapt and forcing farmers off their land to more populated areas as environmental refugees (Bernzen et al., 2019; Myers, 2002).

Access by subsistence farmers to food provides sustenance and an income, so they already place a high value on the soil. In many cases, farmers also understand the importance of services provided by ecosystems surrounding and within their agricultural system (Kandel et al., 2018). Placing a higher value on ecosystem services (disconnection, Table 1) and striving to maintain diversity within the soil environment would enable greater production, crop quality and nutritional value, therefore increasing the farmer's income and wellbeing.

In the earlier review the access to land tenure significantly increases connectivity between subsistence farmers and the soil (weak interaction, Table 1), influencing their key land management decisions (Ding, 2003; Hartvigsen, 2014; Obeng-Odoom, 2012). Simultaneously, joining a local co-operative can help ensure farmers receive a fair price for their produce; however, more guidance by governments and NGOs is needed to ensure resilience, as many co-operatives are short-lived or unsuccessful (Borda-Rodriguez and Vicari, 2014). Fairer pricing enables farmers to make a greater profit, enabling them to afford a more diverse diet and allowing them to invest in improved farming technologies and more sustainable land management.

5.3. Access (indirect)

Many of the issues identified for subsistence farmers also impact those indirectly deriving their food. The degradation of land reducing capability of the soil, and poor soil condition, impact the value chain and where food is sourced, impacting food availability and prices (D'Odorico et al., 2014); this may result in economic losses for producers in the affected areas through loss of trade (Gomiero, 2016; D'Odorico et al., 2014). Meanwhile, consumers are becoming more concerned about the provenance of their food; being mindful of where the food has come from, the associated impacts upon the environment, and ethical treatment of animals (Birch et al., 2018).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.