Narratives of GMO effectiveness prop up the agribusiness industry – lock in low food and environmental standards, degrade soil, and hurt small farmers
Soil Association 20 British baised charity organization that campaigns against intensive farming and emphasized local production [“Stop Genetic Modification.” The Soil Association. Nov 2020]
Don’t believe the hype: New GM techniques In July 2018, the European Court of Justice ruled that new genetic editing techniques count as GM and must be properly regulated. We welcomed this move. These newer techniques, which include so-called ‘gene editing’, continue to be regulated as GM in the UK following Brexit. In 2019/20, the Government announced an aspiration to change this, particularly for new techniques which interfere with DNA, but do not insert genes from foreign species. But GM has a track record of failing to deliver. We are told that GM foods are needed to feed our growing population and to meet the challenges of climate change and pests, yet real world experience has shown that GM crops have not lived up to their promises. This booklet from Claire Robinson (Editor of GMWatch.org) and produced by the Sheepdrove Trust (pdf, 20mb) debunks the myths spread by the producers of GM products and the chemicals they rely on. These newer technologies, like ‘old GM’ are perfectly suited to distract from what is really needed, and to end up concentrating corporate control, putting big agribusiness firmly in the driving seat. We only have to look at the US and Brazil to see what direction GM takes us in - low food and environmental standards, farmers faced with degraded soils that are far from resilient to climate change, and wildlife in crisis. What are the risks of genetic modification? ‘This is a bottle that once opened, cannot be closed. To check the contents first, mistakes and all, is just scientific common sense’. All GM techniques, new and old, should remain subject to risk assessment, traceability and labelling to ensure farmer choice, consumer choice and the safeguarding of health & environment. Regulation is needed not only for novel traits, but also for the process of DNA interference itself. DNA interference is something all GM techniques do, including gene editing. It raises a great deal of scientific uncertainty. Recent research has raised more questions than answers, highlighting unexpected effects in all editing techniques, in the form of DNA errors and changes in gene expression. The repercussions are not well understood. Newer ‘gene editing’ techniques raise another level of uncertainty given their completely novel ability to do a large number of different edits, allowing changes to quickly accumulate. Organic food and farming Organic standards adopt a precautionary approach to new technologies and prohibit GM. The organic sector must be given the possibility and capacity to remain GMO-free. To protect the income and livelihoods of organic farmers and processors, all contamination of non-GMO materials should be prevented by the GMO producer in line with the polluter pays principle.