Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Soft Regs Fail

Kavanagh 19 [Camino Kavanagh has a PhD in information technology and currently works as a nonresident scholar at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, where her research focuses on international security, governance, and emerging technologies, 8-28-2019, “New Tech, New Threats, and New Governance Challenges: An Opportunity to Craft Smarter Responses?”, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, https://carnegieendowment.org/2019/08/28/new-tech-new-threats-and-new-governance-challenges-opportunity-to-craft-smarter-responses-pub-79736, accessed 6-28-2022]

Such projects demonstrate the need to first develop safer versions of this powerful technology and raise important issues related to standards and regulation. The consequences of using such technologies are not contained within national borders, and these effects will likely require some form of transnational mechanism that considers the views of all stakeholders. This calls for a more harmonized approach to biotech policy, especially since rules and practices of gene editing vary significantly from country to country. Meanwhile, all stakeholders, including those funding and supporting research, need to ensure adherence to existing guidance such as the World Health Organization’s (WHO) 2014 set of guidelines for testing genetically modified mosquitoes.132 According to some experts, this push to shore up standards might require the establishment of some form of accountability mechanism that can, at a minimum, oversee adherence to this guidance and identify possible obstacles to implementation.133

Another ecological risk is the potential for biological attacks against food and water resources, which, as discussed further below, would cause economic damage as well as a “loss of confidence in the food supply, and possible loss of life.”134 For example, a recent study determined that scientists’ deepening understanding of the genomes of plants and animals will make it theoretically possible to target vulnerabilities with greater precision or to create new varieties of organisms with potentially harmful properties. The authors posit that “if plant or animal pathogens [a]re engineered to spread widely in the world in crops or herds, respectively, the result could be widespread and lasting food shortages.”135

Other health and safety risks: Incidents like laboratory accidents or research aimed at rendering deadly viruses more contagious or pathogenic pose dangers as well. Relatedly, the publication of such techniques and research outcomes could educate and empower malevolent actors. Concerns of this kind arose from research published by two scientists in 2012 in prominent journals (Nature and Science). Both had succeeded in genetically engineering strains of the avian flu virus (H5N1).136 The controversial decision to publish their research findings stemmed from intense public concerns that the virus could leak out of a laboratory in the event of an accident. More seriously, the research could be leveraged by terrorists to create a biological weapon and unleash a devastating pandemic.

National guidance, regulations, and codes of conduct by the research community are helping address some of these challenges.137 Globally, the International Standards Organization is developing new standards to harmonize attempts to help laboratories manage biological risk, drawing from EU and WHO efforts to establish and implement effective biorisk management systems.138 But there are still important gaps. As biotechnology becomes cheaper and more readily available, these softer forms of regulation will likely be insufficient for managing the associated risks.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.