Carbon neutrality isn’t enough
Kirkpatrick 19 [David Kirkpatrick, journalist and founder of Techonomy, 11-14-2019, “Carbon Neutral Isn't Enough”, Techonomy, https://techonomy.com/carbon-neutral-isnt-enough/, 6-28-2022]
Many people believe that if we all just drove electric cars, used LED lightbulbs, and even did things like sail across the ocean rather than fly, the resulting reduction in pollution could somehow stop global warming. Unfortunately, it isn’t true. Yes, the world has to radically reduce emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) and other global warming gasses. But to avoid planetary catastrophe, we also must remove a vast amount of CO2 that’s already in our atmosphere.
The United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) says average global temperatures cannot be allowed to exceed, at the very most, 2 degrees centigrade above the average that prevailed before industrialization. If possible, the increase shouldn’t exceed 1.5 degrees. Otherwise, we face even more violent weather, damaging wildfires, rising sea levels, water scarcity, an unstable food supply, and who knows what other horrors. And here is a key but little-discussed passage from an important 2018 IPCC report: “All pathways that limit global warming to 1.5°C with limited or no overshoot project the use of carbon dioxide removal (CDR).” Note the word–“all.”
“We’ve got to keep temperature rise to 1.5 degrees, and that can’t be done without carbon removal,” summarizes James Mulligan, who works fulltime on this issue at the World Resources Institute (WRI), a large global non-profit focused on natural resource sustainability. Adds Leslie Jones, a vice president and climate expert at the Environmental Defense Fund (EDF): “The National Academy of Sciences has concluded that if we’re going to have a fighting chance to limit warming to 1.5 or even 2 degrees, we’ll have to do two things–aggressively slash greenhouse gas emissions and deploy carbon removal, both natural approaches and emerging technologies.”
Containing emissions will be all the more challenging given the world’s other needs. The United Nations’ 17 Sustainable Development Goals for 2030 articulate many things we must achieve for a fairer, healthier world. Goal number 13 is “Climate Action.” But other goals demand economic inclusion and societal health. Those can’t be achieved without ongoing economic growth, particularly in developing countries that were excluded from the industrial world’s 20th century accumulation of wealth. The legitimate demands of previously excluded people will thus place more pressure on global atmospheric CO2.
Warming gasses are still getting worse in the atmosphere, but it won’t be enough to make them stop, go down, or even disappear. We literally have to suck them up. Neutral is not enough. To meet the 1.5 degree target, says the EDF’s Jones, “We need to reach net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, and keep that trend line going down to net negative.” Already 60 nations have committed themselves to “net zero” emissions, including Britain, France, and Germany. Eliminating all CO2 emissions will almost certainly be impossible. (There’s little near-term likelihood of electric airliners, for example.) So we’ll need rapid progress in CDR just to get to “net zero,” and far more to go “net negative.” Here’s the bottom line: carbon removal at large scale is indispensable for maintaining a livable earth.