Cyberattacks will not escalate – cyberattacks repeatedly evoke minor responses that don’t lead to escalation
Martin C. Libicki 20, Professor at the Center for Cyber Security Studies at the U.S. Naval Academy, “Correlations Between Cyberspace Attacks and Kinetic Attacks,” May 2020, 2020 12th International Conference on Cyber Conflict, http://195.222.11.251/uploads/2020/05/CyCon_2020_11_Libicki.pdf
Overall, there is little public evidence that hostile events in cyberspace echo strongly outside it. Indeed, rarely do events in cyberspace – much less escalation in cyberspace – lead to serious responses at all. Some research suggests that even severe cyberattacks would generally be less likely than kinetic attacks to induce a response. Although opening cyberattacks can precede kinetic attacks, there are also cases when war comes as a surprise and cyberattacks are not used until the proper accesses to target systems have been gained. Cyberattacks have the potential to put hitherto sacrosanct targets – notably space systems, and other NC3 elements – in play, but cyberattacks have reportedly taken place against satellites while kinetic attacks (weapons tests aside) have not, so far. The failure to respond to cyberattacks may have played a role in enabling missile attacks on Saudi Aramco facilities, but the link is distant (seven years earlier) and tenuous. There is no analog (yet) in the Russo-Ukrainian conflict. Several reasons could be adduced to explain the lack of correlation. One is that while there could be cyberattacks consequential enough to induce echoes in the physical world, none have reached that threshold and it may well be that none could reach that threshold. Even as the attack surface for cyberspace operations keeps growing, hackers grow more talented, and their leaders more aware of the gains available from such operations – defense is not sleeping. Those who own networks are taking cybersecurity seriously (at long last), cloud computing may have helped put defenses in the hands of those for whom protection is a profit center, and the cybersecurity industry itself is robust. Succeeding generations of software – e.g., versions of Windows operation systems – are also more impervious to intrusions. Two is that, in common with many widely-feared phenomena, cyberattacks have evolved from an acute problem (one both rare and fearsome) to a chronic problem (more common, but something that one can adjust to). Three, the oft-expressed belief that cyberwar is war has yet to take hold. Because cyberspace operations are ambiguous (and not easily grasped even when clear) and their effects almost always temporary and not (yet) lethal, they may be considered something separate and apart. Time will tell whether this distinction will continue to be observed.