Hotlines for cyber solve misperceptions and miscalcualtions
Ariel (Eli) Levite 19, nonresident senior fellow in the Nuclear Policy Program at the Carnegie Endowment; and Lyu Jinghua, visiting scholar with Carnegie’s Cyber Policy Initiative, 1/24/19, “Chinese-American Relations in Cyberspace: Toward Collaboration or Confrontation?,” https://carnegieendowment.org/2019/01/24/chinese-american-relations-in-cyberspace-toward-collaboration-or-confrontation-pub-78213
Third, enhance mechanisms and channels for routine as well as emergency bilateral information sharing and coordination on cyber events and notification of major military activities. This proposal builds on preexisting bilateral arrangements for sharing information, such as in the cooperation between the respective national CERTs from the two countries. However, what arrangements are now in place do not suffice to dispel misperceptions and prevent miscalculations, and avert explosive incidents especially in the political and military spheres. Blocking communications and blinding or, even worse, spoofing time and navigation systems of civilian and military assets in peacetime are especially prone to lead to escalation. While it is highly necessary to adopt mutually understood rules of the road in this sphere, a first step would be to establish or complement bilateral hotlines and other crises communications and consultation channels among both military commanders as well as high level decisionmakers with corresponding political/policy guidance to endow them with real substance.
It is also worth considering in this context how to apply the MOU on Notification of Major Military Activities in cyberspace. In this memorandum, signed by the U.S. Defense Department and Chinese Ministry of National Defense in November 2014, both sides “affirm their aspiration to establish a voluntary foundation for notifications of major military activities, such as exchange information voluntarily about their respective country’s security policy, strategy, and legal information, including the adjustment of respective national defense policies and strategy, by providing briefings and information about speeches, major government publications such as White Papers, strategy publications, and other official announcements related to policy and strategy,” and allow for “observation of military exercises and activities that should be voluntary and occur within the existing framework of bilateral U.S.-China military relations.”33 Similar voluntary exchange of information, interpretation of cyber strategy and publication, and invitation from either side to observe cyber exercises hosted or co-hosted by the other side could be one part of confidence-building efforts in cyberspace.