Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

International de-centralized cooperation key---over-centralization and nationalist efforts both fail.

David Livingstone and Patricia Lewis 16, associate fellow in the International Security program; leader of the International Security program at Chatham House, September 2016, “Space, the Final Frontier for Cybersecurity?”, https://www.chathamhouse.org/sites/default/files/publications/research/2016-09-22-space-final-frontier-cybersecurity-livingstone-lewis.pdf, International Security Department \\SYang

The response to a complex and specifically internationalized cybersecurity problem needs to be based on an international coherent approach, which can be defined as a regime – that is, a set of: … implicit or explicit principles, norms, rules and decision-making procedures around which actors’ expectations converge in a given area of international relations. Principles are beliefs of fact, causation and rectitude. Norms are standards of behaviour defined in terms of rights and obligations. Rules are specific prescriptions or proscriptions for action, decision-making procedures are prevailing practices for making and implementing collective choice. There is an urgent requirement to develop a space cybersecurity regime that will inform and organize policy efforts and subordinate strategies, while remaining federally networked rather than controlled from a centre or hierarchically driven. Too centralized an approach would give the illicit actors, who are generally unencumbered by process or legislative frameworks, an unassailable advantage simply because their response and decision-making time is more flexible and faster than that of their legitimate opponents. To be successful and durable, the space cybersecurity regime should be one that functions intelligently and responsively, and possesses enough flexibility to be able to react in a coordinated way as the environment and circumstances alter. As noted above, over-zealous central direction by regulators in a market-driven sector tends to lead to the supply chain finding ‘workarounds’, leading to the risk of developing a general culture of cyber insecurity in which the default condition is simply to identify the best way to dodge the rules. This hands another advantage to the adversaries of legitimate users of the space domain. However, the international space community has not yet acted as a coherent system in the area of cybersecurity. This problem is compounded by the fact that the nature of space and its relationship to society are entering a period of fundamental change. The stakeholders required for the space cybersecurity discourse remain essentially segregated (apart from occasional meetings at events such as conferences), and are only concerned with managing risks within their narrow fields of interest. Left unaddressed, this dynamic will in all likelihood continue unless there is an external stimulus. As a result, there will be little recognition that each stakeholder can be affected by another’s security, or lack of it, unless there is a change in perceptions. A significant element of self-help is required to make up for the shortcomings of the regulatory cadre. A space cyber regime, based on a lightly regulated initiative from the supply chain, seems to offer the most suitable and sustainable basis for channelling multinational contributions to an internationalized space cybersecurity capability which has to include an ever greater number of different stakeholders. Such a regime must be agile enough to meet the rapidly evolving security challenge facing the space domain, and to continue to develop as the market is transformed over the next decades. Policy requirements Ideally, the policy needed to establish a space cybersecurity regime would align the needs of all the various concerns: on an already complex international stage this would include the millions of end users, individual scientists, the corporate sector and the military; address technical, political, economic and social interests; and combine the tactical with the strategic and the bottom-up with the top-down approach. To align across and within all sectors, one approach is to adopt a single focus – such as the provision of assured broadband via space – and make that the driving force, organizing all other initiatives around it. But the space domain is now becoming so intrinsic to every human activity, whether government, private-sector or individual, that the foundation of a more robust and coherent space cybersecurity regime requires a common understanding of what is essential to determine both the nature of the problem and threat mitigation responses. The approach must be non-hierarchical, where each stakeholder is empowered by knowledge provided by the regime and feels valued as a contributor. Ensuring security in space must correspondingly be a common ambition for all concerned players. Thus a common approach to cybersecurity can be developed and encouraged by applying the principles of governance, management and inclusiveness as outlined below. Governance There are three paramount dimensions in the governance of a space cybersecurity regime. First, whatever is done to combat space cyber insecurity, policy should be adopted and applied in order to enable legitimate users of space-related capability, while increasing the costs (of entry, for example, or discovery and being subject to law enforcement action) for illegitimate users. A culture of space cybersecurity must lead to the development of an innate instinct for what is safe and what is risky throughout the supply chain. Second, the governance of space cybersecurity needs a collective approach, involving as many legitimate stakeholders as possible and practical. This will also create a progressive and dynamic environment where knowledge is a key ingredient; if participants can share experiences and lessons learned, cybersecurity will become increasingly instinctive, from the boardroom down to the shop floor, and its sum will increase. Third, the regime needs to be based on a self-governing and lightly regulated effort by a wide range of legitimate users of space capability. This is because space infrastructure, with its multiple uses, is a complex and constantly adapting area that defies control, centralized management and oversight by any single stakeholder (except for some very specific processes such as orbit or communications frequency allocation). Experience suggests that there is no other option but to deliver this effort within a business environment of transparency and accountability involving collaboration designed to share knowledge. Effective and durable governance of cyberspace requires a shared awareness that implies a dynamic, common approach to raising cyber capability. A culture of space cybersecurity must lead to the development of an innate instinct for what is safe and what is risky throughout the supply chain.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.