Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Cyber being distinct is a reason to err neg – ambiguity’s necessary to respond to unpredictable threats with maximum flexibility.

Ken Jones 15; MS in Cyber Systems and Operations from the Naval Postgraduate School; March 2015; "Cyber War: The Next Frontier for NATO," https://calhoun.nps.edu/bitstream/handle/10945/45201/15Mar_Jones_Ken.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

To answer this question, it is important to look at the first (and only) time NATO invoked an Article 5 response; namely, following the 9/11 attacks on the United States. When the partners of the alliance first wrote the Washington Treaty, it was initially to deter the Russians from expanding and to deter nuclear warfare at the onset of the Cold War. Article 5 is purposefully vague to give NATO considerable room to maneuver. Before the 9/11 attacks led by Al Qaida, it would have been nearly impossible for anyone, anywhere, including the framers of the Washington Treaty, to imagine such an attack. Likewise, at the 2014 summit in Wales, NATO announced that it would and could invoke an Article 5 response to a cyber-attack, and that the ambiguity would stand.158 NATO’s Ambassador Sorin Ducaru, NATO’s assistant secretary general for “emerging security challenges,” made the following remarks:

[T]here’s no predetermined threshold…there was a conscious decision by the allies in this policy that there is benefit in keeping flexibility and ambiguity…article 5 was by design something that should be invoked politically by [member] nations in a specific context, on a case by case basis…article 5 was never designed to be triggered by a certain threshold. The only time it was invoked was after 9/11, which was a scenario that had never been contemplated by the founding partners.159 In this same vein, Christopher Painter, the U.S.’ State Department cyber coordinator said:

The NATO leaders’ declaration that international law including the UN Charter, the Law of Armed Conflict, international humanitarian law, etc. applies in cyberspace just like it does in the physical world…[t]his is a clear statement that this is not a lawless space. There was some doubt before. There was some thought you had different rules entirely for the cyber world than the physical world, which made no sense and in fact would be very destabilizing.160

In light of the recent developments of NATO, it would seem to be in NATO’s best interest to remain ambiguous and allow the organization to approach its response to a cyber-attack on a case-by-case basis. For instance, the attacks on Estonia might require intervention on behalf of the Estonian people due to the fact they are a smaller, lesser defensible state. Estonia would not be successful standing up against Russia, and as Russia becomes more aggressive in the former-Soviet bloc region, small states like Estonia are at risk. If another attack were to occur against Estonia, the attacks would have to be more severe to invoke an Article 5 response. Such a response would enable NATO states to act as if they too have been attacked as per the mutual defense announcement against cyber-attacks at the Wales Summit. Yet, if the United States is attacked in a similar manner, there likely does not need to be the same scale of defense taken, because the United States has more resources and capabilities to respond on its own. Remaining ambiguous allows NATO to choose the best opportunities for supporting and defending member states.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.