Cyber security reform is seen as authoritarian surveillance legislation.
Peter Hess 16, writer for Scienceline, "Controversial new cybersecurity law may compromise privacy"; Scienceline; Published: 1-24-2016; Accessed: 2-5-2022; https://scienceline.org/2016/01/controversial-new-cybersecurity-law-may-compromise-privacy/
The recent, highly publicized cyberattacks on Sony and the U.S. government’s Office of Personnel Management exposed sensitive data about millions of people. In Congress, lawmakers responded by approving the Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act, or CISA. But some critics say the bill, which President Obama signed into law on Dec. 18, not only would have done nothing to prevent those attacks, but also erodes personal privacy.
CISA encourages companies to share digital signatures — unique codes that track the origins of electronic communications, including the sender’s IP address — associated with possible security threats, both with each other and with the U.S. government. Supporters say this information sharing makes it easier for companies and the government to quickly get out ahead of security threats by alerting each other to the origin and nature of potential breaches. Opposition to the new law has come from technology companies, along with advocacy groups, such as the American Civil Liberties Union, that are worried about protecting privacy.
Critics say CISA’s focus on digital signatures is invasive and fails to include more current and relevant threats. Some even question whether the slow-moving machinery of lawmaking can ever keep up with the breakneck pace of the online world, where entirely new kinds of security threats regularly arise in an instant, seemingly out of nowhere.
“It was the intention of our founding fathers that policy should be slow because it prevents tyranny,” says Elissa Shevinsky, head of product at Brave, a company that focuses on easy-to-use privacy software. “If policy were fast, we’d be in a surveillance state. We’d have CISA already. It’s on us to fight hackers at the pace of hacking.” Private cybersecurity companies like hers, she adds, are better positioned to handle these security issues.
Privacy concerns are a key issue for critics like Shevinsky, who say CISA erodes privacy rights by going too far in encouraging companies to share private information with the U.S. government. An important element of the bill would protect companies from liability if they shared such data. According to Shevinsky, that would encourage companies to flout their own privacy policies by sharing their customers’ personal information. Before the bill passed, federal agencies could penalize companies for betraying their privacy policies, she says. CISA in its current form would not require companies to scrub customers’ identifying information from the data before sending it to other companies or the government. “CISA makes it so they can [share private information] in broad daylight,” Shevinsky says.