Offshoring worsens AI danger---it’ll be constrained by U.S. social norms, but not if it moves abroad
John O. McGinnis 17, George C. Dix Professor in Constitutional Law at Northwestern University and a Contributing Editor at Law & Liberty, Graduate of Harvard College, Balliol College, Oxford, and Harvard Law School, “Accelerate Rather than Regulate Artificial Intelligence”, Law & Liberty, 7/19/2017, https://lawliberty.org/accelerate-rather-than-regulate-artificial-intelligence/ [language modified]
But trying to slow down or have the government direct and restrict AI (which is much the same thing) in the United States would only allow other nations to advance AI faster. And since AI is at the heart of modern military operations, the United States would lose its essential military advantage. If the United States remains the best hope for freedom for [hu]mankind, certainly as compared to China, our greatest competitor in AI, that is a disastrous geopolitical policy.
Indeed, even without regulation my great fear is that the United States will fall behind China in developing AI. Given that data is what trains modern AI, China’s sheer size gives it an advantage because it generates more data. And even beyond its potentially larger pool of researchers, its universities are more geared to the sciences than are ours. Of course the United States does have advantages, such as finer top universities and a more attractive, more free society. Thus, what the United States can best do to accelerate AI here is to give after an appropriate security vetting a green card to any Ph.D from a bona fide university or to any student who has been accepted here to a doctorate program in computer science. And as I have suggested, it should also accelerate government grants to encourage the development of a friendly AI–one that is not dangerous to humans.
These policies would not only help maintain the security of the United States, but would give us the best chance of forestalling malevolent AI. That kind of AI is more likely to be developed in less free societies, because the social norms of those society will subject researchers to less criticism for such development. Moreover, accelerating the development of friendlier AI would create better machine intelligence to help forestall the less friendly kind.
Ever stronger AI is on the horizon. The only question is where it will be developed most quickly. The world will be better off if that place is the United States.