Existential warming is inevitable AND causes a collapse into extreme authoritarianism---only transitioning from democracy solves
Dr. Chien-Yi Lu 21, PhD and MA in Government from the University of Texas, Austin, Visiting Scholar at Harvard University, Associate Research Fellow at the Institute of European and American Studies of Academia Sinica, Surviving Democracy: Mitigating Climate Change in a Neoliberalized World, Paperback Edition, 12/13/2021, p. 1-2
The fact that the scientific knowledge on the human contribution to climate change entered human society through the most advanced democratic societies should have been a cause for celebration. Given the congruence of climate mitigation and public interests, the problem of climate change should have been considered solved decades ago. Several decades of inaction later, however, arguments are proliferating that democracy is exactly the reason for inaction.
In The Collapse of Western Civilization, historians Naomi Oreskes and Erik Conway travel to the future to look back and offer a forensic analysis on the climate-induced Great Collapse of Western Civilization of 2074 (2014: 63). The future historians’ forensic report states that “[a]s the devastating effects of the Great Collapse began to appear, the nation-states with democratic governments… were at first unwilling and then unable” to deal with the crisis. These democratic governments realized that they had no “infrastructure and organizational ability to quarantine and relocate people” as “food shortages and disease outbreaks spread and sea level[s] rose.” In China, where there was centralized government, the crisis was handled much more adequately, leading to survival rates exceeding 80%, a development that “vindicated the necessity of centralized government” (2014: 51–2). The gist of The Collapse of Western Civilization is not about critiquing democracy per se but a warning against the stubborn inaction mandated by market fundamentalism that has hijacked Western democracies.1 In their previous book, Merchants of Doubt, Oreskes and Conway documented the way that climate deniers sowed the seeds of doubt about climate change and successfully staved off implementations of mitigation measures. For the authors, the anticommunist ideology that had kept actors vigilant about government encroachment in the marketplace occupied a central place in climate denial (2014: 69). Ironically, this sort of ideology-informed calculation meant that preventative action was blocked, increasing the risk that disruptive climate disasters would eventually necessitate the suspension of democracy and legitimating the sort of heavy-handed authoritarian interventions that the conservatives most abhorred (2014: 52; 69).
An appeal to suspend democracy for the sake of survival can be found in The Climate Change Challenge and the Failure of Democracy, where Shearman and Smith argue that liberal democracy is incompatible with the urgent necessity to prevent catastrophic climate change. The vested interests of politicians, corporations, and media lie in continuing with business as usual and in keeping the public ignorant. Instead of bottom-up reforms to improve democracy and bring about sensible climate policies, Shearman and Smith see a transformation into authoritarian regimes as the only responsible way forward when faced with the extreme ecological stress of climate change. They point out that, as Plato foresaw, those in power in a democracy are seldom able to resist the demands of the populace for long, but as a mass, the populace is seldom able to focus on complex problems and to perceive threats that lie over the horizon. Hence, those able to see further—scientists, experts, and the knowledgeable— should be entrusted with steering the course while there is still time to avoid disaster. It is only under a benign authoritarian rule of the knowledgeable that a saner, fairer, and more rational means of weighing social goods against evils can be introduced (Shearman and Smith, 2007).