Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Attacks are too hard

Rebecca Slayton 17, Assistant Professor at Cornell University with a joint appointment in the Science and Technology Studies Department and the Judith Reppy Institute for Peace and Conflict Studies., Slayton, Rebecca. “What Is the Cyber Offense-Defense Balance? Conceptions, Causes, and Assessment.” International Security, vol. 41, no. 3, Jan. 2017, pp. 72–109.

Conclusion This article has shown that widespread claims about the offense dominance of cyberspace are fundamentally flawed; the offense-defense balance can be understood only in the context of specific adversaries with distinctive goals and levels of capability in managing complex information technology. In many cases, particularly those in which the goal is to achieve complex kinetic effects, cyber operations may well be less costly for the defense than the offense I have presented this argument in four parts. First, I have argued that conceptions of offensive advantage need to include valuations of the goals as well as the costs of cyber operations. The goals of cyber operations are much more varied than are battles for territory and may include propaganda, espionage, counter-espionage, and sabotage, in addition to assistance with territorial military operations. This article has focused on the relative utility of offense and defense—the value of the goals of offense less the costs of offense, and the value of the goals of defense less the costs of defense. A more complete analysis would consider expected utility—that is, it would include the probability of success for offense or defense as a function of offensive and defensive expenditures. The statistics for empirically predicting the probability of success for offense or defense under various conditions do not exist, however, and there is reason to doubt that such calculations will reach a useful level of accuracy or precision. Nonetheless, decisionmakers’ beliefs about the probability of success will shape behavior, and thus both theoretical and empirical analysis of the factors that make cyber offense and defense costly and valuable is crucial to informing policy. Second, I have theorized what makes cyber operations costly and valuable, arguing that the resulting offense-defense balance is a characteristic not of cyberspace, but rather of the relationship between two adversaries; the balance is not systemic, but dyadic. Although software does have an essential characteristic—arbitrary complexity—which provides the offense with many vulnerabilities to exploit, technology alone does not determine the balance. Nor is technology one of several independent factors to be summed up in a net assessment. Instead, it is the processes that govern the interactions between skilled users and technology that determine an organization’s readiness for offense or defense. Research on the capability maturity model shows that the cost of managing complex software decreases as the maturity of an organization’s processes increases. Nonetheless, cost grows with complexity. The skills and organizational capabilities needed for offense and defense are very similar, but offensive capabilities often require less coordination and therefore are less costly than defensive operations. Nonetheless, an offensive operation that aims to precisely control a complex system is much more difficult than one that merely aims to disrupt the system, and may be costlier than defense. Additionally, the advantages that complex software offers attackers diminish rapidly at the “edges” of cyberspace, where computers are used to control physical systems, because knowledge of the physical systems is needed to exercise careful control. Such knowledge is often tacit and therefore unavailable through cyber espionage. Thus, although information technology offers unprecedented efªciency for espionage, it is not the most cost-effective means of destruction. Cyberweapons are primarily advantageous for their covertness, and they become expensive when physical systems are the target.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.