Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

AT Cohesion

Ethics principles cannot create cohesion – there are many other issues that must be resolved for the US to coordinate NATO

Trabucco, 2020 - Research Assistant at the Centre for Military Studies at the University of Copenhagen [Lena, May 10 “AI Partnership for Defense is a Step in the Right Direction – But Will Face Challenges” http://opiniojuris.org/2020/10/05/ai-partnership-for-defense-is-a-step-in-the-right-direction-but-will-face-challenges/ Acc 4/17/22 TA]

Which brings me to the third challenge. The AI partnership symposium did not offer a coherent strategy for the partnership beyond advancing core values the participating nations find important to the AI pipeline. Peter Singer, New America Foundation fellow and strategist, noted that the US has not yet offered a coherent strategy to contrast its “near peers.” In one article, Singer said, “China has a fairly clear and robust vision of this [AI and its applications] and it is actively exporting that vision. There is absolutely no way the US can compete without offering a different and compelling vision and one that involves our friends and allies.” On the one hand, the absence of an overarching strategy gives the DoD and the AI partnership latitude to address inevitable issues that will arise. Secretary Esper noted in his address that this kind of partnership is the first of its kind and needs time to operate in the face of unforeseen challenges. But to accomplish the goal as the preferred security partner in AI, the partnership will need to substantiate its agreement with a vision more concrete than just ethical values. The AI partnership accomplishes getting some allies on board, but does not clarify what vision is driving the newfound partnership. At some point, this will need to change. In essence, the AI partnership is a necessary and welcome development in the US AI strategy, but significant legal and policy challenges are on the horizon. The three outlined here – legal interoperability, trans-Atlantic cooperation, and an uncertain coherent strategy – are certainly not exhaustive. But they represent a span of legal and policy issues the partnership are sure to encounter as it moves forward.

No solvency –alternate causalities - adversarial disinformation will undermine cohesion by sowing discord.

Lin-Greenberg, 2020 - member of the MIT Security Studies Program [Erik Vol 3, Iss 2 Spring, Texas National Security Review “Allies and Artificial Intelligence: Obstacles to Operations and Decision-Making” http://dx.doi.org/10.26153/tsw/8866 Acc 4/22/22 TA]

Adversary Manipulation and Interference Even if states were to trust their own AI technologies, rivals and malicious actors can use AI to sow discord that can hamper decision-making. Trust and close relationships are crucial when multiple states coordinate security-related decisions since policymakers must be confident that allies will not renege on commitments. Leaders have long held fears of being abandoned by allies or of being drawn into unwanted conflicts.105 These fears are magnified when leaders suggest they might not follow through with their alliance commitments or engage in provocative actions.106 Trump, for instance, raised questions about Washington’s commitment to its allies when he publicly questioned the value of defending certain NATO member states.107 An adversary could use AI to drive misinformation campaigns that latch onto these concerns in an effort to strain ties or deepen cleavages between allies. Just as adversaries can use deepfakes to interfere with operational-level coordination, they can also use AI technologies to breed confusion and mistrust that hamper strategic decision-making. Actors seeking to disrupt alliance cohesion might create deepfakes depicting leaders of alliance member states questioning the value of an alliance, criticizing other leaders, or threatening to take actions that could draw an alliance into an unwanted conflict. These falsified videos or recordings could boost uncertainty of an ally’s commitments or induce panic over fears of abandonment during a crisis. The decision-making process may be slowed as policymakers try to understand their allies’ true intentions and preferences, or convince domestic publics that an ally’s “statements” are in fact AI-produced misinformation.

France blocks cohesion – French commitment to digital sovereignty prevents collaboration.

Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

On this note, the French conception of controlled AI goes a step further and ties auditability to the core value of sovereignty in French strategic culture.54 This is because the relationship between auditability and control stems from geopolitical concerns. The strategy states, “France cannot resign itself to being dependent on technologies over which it has no control. […] Preserving digital sovereignty therefore also involves controlling the algorithms and their configuration, and the governance of data.”55 This need for control comes from a desire to exert independence from the “stranglehold on AI exerted by China and the United States,” including by strengthening European cooperation.56 While the geopolitical aspects and prospects of France to assert this independence are beyond the scope of this study, it is notable that they trickle into the French approach to trace the provenance of models and data. In particular, weapons are “critical applications” that will need to be auditable.57 If enforced, this means that questions about data rights and legal authorities to transfer data (including from foreign suppliers) could render AI “uncontrolled” per the French definition. Here, protectionism straddles the line of ethics and adoption, with digital sovereignty as a potential factor that determines acceptability of both. This can also be seen in the imperative to maintain “freedom of action.”58

Domestic politics prevent alliance cohesion and interoperability – many nations cannot commit to AI

Lin-Greenberg, 2020 - member of the MIT Security Studies Program [Erik Vol 3, Iss 2 Spring, Texas National Security Review “Allies and Artificial Intelligence: Obstacles to Operations and Decision-Making” http://dx.doi.org/10.26153/tsw/8866 Acc 4/22/22 TA]

Although alliances and multilateral coalitions can bolster the security of member states and the efficiency of their military operations, membership can create complications for decision-making and the coordination of military operations. First, alliances and coalitions must overcome operational challenges surrounding the integration and coordination of military forces. Modern military operations require the close coordination of participating forces, shared intelligence to guide planning and mission execution, and weapon systems capable of communicating with and operating alongside each other. The military of each alliance or coalition member state brings with it different equipment, policies, and tactics, meaning that a state’s forces may not fully integrate with the forces of its allies.42 Moreover, partners are often reluctant to share sensitive operational and intelligence information.43 Beyond these institutional issues, more commonplace matters — such as the different languages and military cultures of each member state — can hinder interoperability during contingency operations.44 Second, alliance and coalition leaders may have trouble deciding what policies their coalition should pursue. Although allies typically face a common threat and share many policy objectives, each state still maintains its own priorities and goals. State leaders therefore respond to domestic constituencies and pursue their own national interests, which, at times, may be at odds with alliance goals.45 At best, these divergent interests result in coordination problems that draw out decision-making timelines.46 At worst, they generate mistrust between partners and raise concerns of being abandoned during a crisis or “chain-ganged” into unwanted wars.47

France is committed to digital sovereignty

Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

54 The French imperative to maintain technological independence is stronger than any other European ally, and largely motivates French defence industrial policy as well as the political agenda of “strategic autonomy” and “digital sovereignty” at the national and European levels. Other documents that reinforce this include those referenced in footnotes 47 and 49, as well as the 2019 Defence Innovation Orientation Document (2019) and the Ministry of Armed Forces Digital Transformation: Key Concepts (2020). 55 AI Task Force, Artificial Intelligence in Support of Defence, 10. 56 This strong language intends to set the political tone for adoption, and is not purely about ethics. Further, while the “stranglehold” motivates sovereignty, there are few specifics in the strategy about hardware components or cloud capabilities, beyond the recognition that these are not French or European strengths. Auditability is only tied, here, to models and data. AI Task Force, Artificial Intelligence in Support of Defence, 10, 24.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.