--Extend - Civilian Links
The Affirmative focuses on distinguishing Autonomous from Non-autonomous weapons is counterproductive - it prevents us from focusing on how to use them effectively and responsibly.
Noyes, 2019 - Major, US Army Reserve [Matthew MPP, Harvard Kennedy School 14-06-2019 “Autonomous Weapons: The Future Behind Us” https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/AD1085435.pdf Acc 12/27/20 TA]
Militaries have long used weapons with autonomous capabilities and are likely to increasingly use autonomous weapons as their effectiveness is demonstrated. Autonomous weapons predate remotely operated weapons in most domains. The air domain is instructive in this regard, as the invention of television in the 1930s disrupted prior work on more autonomous aircraft by allowing for the remote operation of aircraft out of sight from the pilot. Remotely operated systems are likely to continue to be generally preferred by militaries, but those systems will have increasingly autonomous capabilities, particularly in targeting enemy systems that disrupt their command and control links. This suggests rather than viewing “autonomous weapons” as a distinct class of systems, instead we should consider the autonomous capabilities of a weapon and how it is controlled by its user. Correctly considering autonomy in weapons begins with recognizing weapons are tools, and like all tools have a user. “Full autonomy,” in the sense of absolute independence, is not a desirable property of a tool. Rather, users will maintain some control over their tools to ensure they are accomplishing their desired purpose. Instead of trying to distinguish between what is autonomous and what is not, we should focus on the relationship between the user and the tool. To paraphrase David Mindell: “Where are the [users]? Who are they? What are they doing? When? Why does it matter?”152 Unencumbered with trying to distinguish between what is autonomous and non-autonomous allows analysis to instead focus on autonomy in executing particular functions. Recognizing militaries have long used autonomous weapons makes predicting their future use a matter of identifying the capabilities militaries have sought to achieve through autonomous weapons in the past, and how technology is changing what is possible. Considering this history, autonomous weapons have predominately been used to address at least one of four challenges: the mundane, the fast, the denied, and mass. Autonomous weapons aid militaries in addressing the mundane, or long duration, by providing greater persistence in observing and reacting to events over an extended period than is efficiently achieved with a manned system. In terms of both reaction speed and at high accelerations, autonomous weapons can operate at speeds exceeding what people are capable of. A particularly attractive feature of autonomous weapons is the ability to operate in denied environment, either due to environmental conditions or enemy action, that present unacceptable risk to manned systems or to the control channels for remotely operated systems. Finally, autonomous weapons provide increased mass, like most any military technology, by increasing the military power of a state relative to its available population for military service.
Banning autonomous weapons prevents us from focusing on ways to use them to Counter uncontrolled human deaths.
Noyes, 2019 - Major, US Army Reserve [Matthew MPP, Harvard Kennedy School 14-06-2019 “Autonomous Weapons: The Future Behind Us” https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/AD1085435.pdf Acc 12/27/20 TA]
The normative and ethical considerations related to autonomous weapons are an area that needs further research. Existing literature on the ethics of autonomous weapons tends to describe them as a potential future capability not an existing capability, which may create a status quo bias in arguing against autonomous weapons. It also appears a substantial element in some moral arguments against autonomous weapons is a reaction to a challenge in what it means to be human. There seems to be a deeply held moral intuition that humans ought to have control over killing other humans. Autonomous weapons may be a key means for providing for that control, for example by targeting systems to disrupt command and control channels. If autonomous weapons are seen not as a means to kill humans, but as a means to target adversarial military systems that undermine control over who is killed, I suspect it fundamentally alters normative perspectives. It also suggests rather than seeking to ban autonomous weapons, to seek banning electronic warfare and other systems that erode control over the use of force.