--Extend – OSCE CBM Solvency
OSCE declarations are a confidence building measure – OSCE CBMs are more legitimate due to their broad membership. Empirically proven.
Egel, 2021 - Nuclear Security Visiting Fellow at the Truman Center for National Policy [Naomi, PhD candidate at Cornell, January, Geneva Centre for Security Policy Strategic Security Analysis” Issue 16, “Reducing Military Risks through OSCE Instruments: The Untapped Potential in the European Arms Control Framework” https://www.gcsp.ch/publications/reducing-military-risks-through-osce-instruments-the-untapped-potential-in-the-European-arms-control-framework Acc 2/27/22 TA]
CBMs are voluntary measures designed to communicate ‘credible evidence of the absence of feared threats by reducing uncertainties and by constraining opportunities for exerting pressure through military activity’. Given the OSCE’s membership and history, OSCE CBMs would make a particularly significant contribution to reducing the risks posed by AWS. The OSCE’s membership is both broad (the organisation has 57 participating States, encompassing not only all European states, but Central Asian and North American states as well) and includes seven of the top ten arms producers in the period 2015-2019. OSCE CBMs, thus, have a legitimacy based on both the breadth and number of states that subscribe to them and the involvement of key arms producers. Among international organisations (both regional and global), the OSCE is distinctive for its history of establishing strong norms for using CBMs as tools for risk reduction. AWS CBMs would build on the OSCE’s robust record of reducing military risk through CBMs. The Vienna Document - the cornerstone of OSCE CBMs - has provided a strong framework for building confidence among OSCE participating states, reducing military risks and increasing security in the OSCE region. Other OSCE instruments like the Conventional Forces in Europe Treaty and the Open Skies Treaty provide further information about states’ activities and are thus able to build trust among OSCE members (even though both treaties are currently under strain). However, these agreements are designed to address the risks posed by conventional weapons rather than risks from AWS. Still, the OSCE’s recent adoption of CBMs for Information and Communication Technologies (adopted in 2013 and updated in 2016) demonstrates that the OSCE and its approach to CBMs are well suited to developing risk-reduction CBMs applicable to advanced technologies. The OSCE’s cyber CBMs have also provided a template for other states or regional organisations to develop their own cyber CBMs, building confidence and reducing risk both within and beyond the OSCE’s membership; CBMs for AWS could play a similar role. Although the original Vienna Document was negotiated at the end of the Cold War, its updates and revisions, together with the development of other OSCE CBMs, reflect how CBMs are not merely an outdated Cold War legacy, but continue to play an important role in building confidence and reducing risks.
OSCE CBMs build trust and transparency – this helps establish global norms for AI autonomy.
Egel, 2021 - Nuclear Security Visiting Fellow at the Truman Center for National Policy [Naomi, PhD candidate at Cornell, January, Geneva Centre for Security Policy Strategic Security Analysis” Issue 16, “Reducing Military Risks through OSCE Instruments: The Untapped Potential in the European Arms Control Framework” https://www.gcsp.ch/publications/reducing-military-risks-through-osce-instruments-the-untapped-potential-in-the-European-arms-control-framework Acc 2/27/22 TA]
• As autonomous weapons systems (AWS) increase in military importance, they pose significant risks of miscommunication, miscalculation and inadvertent conflict escalation. • The Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) has a strong history of developing confidence-building measures (CBMs) to reduce military risks stemming from other types of weapons. • The OSCE should develop CBMs for partially autonomous weapons systems. Such CBMs should provide information about AWS features and doctrine for their use, to increase transparency and build trust between states. • OSCE CBMs could provide a foundation for the global governance of autonomous weapons in other multilateral venues. Autonomous weapons systems (AWS) are widely regarded as a game changer in the field of international security and an increasingly important element of military operations. However, they pose heightened risks of miscommunication, miscalculation, and the inadvertent escalation of a conflict that could increase tensions and conflict between states. Although the development of AWS and their use in military operations vary widely among Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) states, many states both within and outside the OSCE are incorporating increasing numbers of AWS into their armed forces, raising concerns over the unintended risks associated with these weapons systems. Even states that do not currently employ AWS have concerns over other states’ use of this technology and the implications of AWS for international security and strategic stability. In the absence of formal treaties governing the use of AWS, confidence-building measures (CBMs) would provide a valuable tool for reducing military risks associated with AWS. This essay proposes that the OSCE develop CBMs for partially autonomous weapons systems, building on its successful history of developing CBMs to reduce other military risks.