Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

--Net Benefit - UN Modelling

OSCE CBMs are the first step toward building consensus in the UN – it demonstrates that the political will exists.

Nadibaidze, 2021 - Ph.D. Student at the University of Southern Denmark [Anna Entry submitted for the Second OSCE-IFSH Essay Competition “Commitment to Control over Weaponised Artificial Intelligence: A Step Forward for the OSCE and European Security” https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/8/3/507341.pdf Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

As a realistic starting point, the OSCE’s Confidence and Security Building Measures (CBMs) could provide a framework to exchange information and observations on the use of weaponised AI, in order to facilitate communication and dialogue (Egel 2021). The OSCE already has CBMs for Information Communication Technologies (ICTs), which, like weaponised AI, create “an area with much room for speculation, doubt, and ambiguity”, and “increase the potential for tensions between States” (OSCE website). There is also potential to go further than exchanging information informally within the CBMs framework. The next step should be, based on the recommendations of the International Panel on the Regulation of Autonomous Weapons (iPRAW), to “focus on the obligation to maintain human control over the use of force” which would “apply to all conventional weapons” (2021, 6). Taking this path will avoid the debate on defining LAWS, which has been hindering the progress of the CCW discussions. Based on the GGE Guiding Principles, the commitment to human control should be enshrined into a normative framework, for example a political declaration or a manual of best practices. Any document with a soft law standing, or a politically binding status, would already be a step forward. Such a political declaration could be part of the Vienna Document, or the result of a new Working Group established at the OSCE. Importantly, an OSCE political declaration or guiding code on weaponised AI would not go against the efforts at the CCW but would complement and build upon them. Shifting the discussion towards the current impacts of weaponised AI, rather than the potential future impact of ‘killer robots’ would be a progressive step to mitigate the risks coming from this emerging technology. An agreement at the OSCE would also be a preliminary step towards building consensus at the UN. It would demonstrate that finding consensus, especially in an atmosphere of political distrust, is possible. This is a relevant and crucial step for European and international security. While debates at the CCW continue, the operational trend towards further autonomy in the armed forces of OSCE participating States continues. As noted in the previous section, practices related to the use of weaponised AI have the potential to shape warfare norms. Yet, this trajectory is not inevitable and with the right approach, a political declaration committing to a common definition of human control is a realistic achievement.

UN AI governance is failing now – OSCE declarations would reinvigorate it – empirically proven by the Small Arms Treaty.

Egel, 2021 - Nuclear Security Visiting Fellow at the Truman Center for National Policy [Naomi, PhD candidate at Cornell, January, Geneva Centre for Security Policy Strategic Security Analysis” Issue 16, “Reducing Military Risks through OSCE Instruments: The Untapped Potential in the European Arms Control Framework” https://www.gcsp.ch/publications/reducing-military-risks-through-osce-instruments-the-untapped-potential-in-the-European-arms-control-framework Acc 2/27/22 TA]

The OSCE’s contribution to risk reduction Currently, global governance of AWS is under discussion within the framework of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW). This process, however, has been slow moving and fraught with disagreement over what AWS are, particularly regarding the distinction between fully and partially autonomous weapons systems. Rather than relying solely on the CCW to address the risks posed by AWS, regional organisations could develop mechanisms to reduce risks and build confidence that states’ increasing use of partially autonomous weapons would not be destabilising and escalatory. Such efforts could also help to energise the process under way in the CCW and facilitate a global agreement there. The OSCE has made such contributions before: OSCE information exchanges on small arms and light weapons, beginning with the 1993 OSCE Principles Governing Conventional Arms Transfers, helped pave the way for the 2013 Arms Trade Treaty.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.