Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

--Extend – Ban LAWs Solvency

The best solution is to ban lethal autonomous weapons. Empirically, it has worked for other weapons and has broad international support.

Garcia, 2019 – International Panel for the Regulation of Autonomous Weapons at Northeastern Univ [Denise, with Justin Haner – PhD student Global Policy, Sept 26 “The Artificial Intelligence Arms Race: Trends and World Leaders in Autonomous Weapons Development” Acc 12/27/20 TA]

Ending the artificial intelligence arms race with a ban on killer robots As the AI arms race rages on, the stakes remain high yet public debate is lacking. Sixty‐one per cent of citizens polled across more than twenty countries oppose the development of lethal AWS, and yet billions of their tax dollars are being spent on their development each year (CSKR, 2019). France, Germany, and others have advocated use of the Convention on Certain Weapons (CCW) process to develop ‘Possible Guiding Principles’ as a code of conduct to encourage AWS development to stay in accordance with existing international law (Convention on Certain Weapons, 2018). Beyond that, 28 states have called for a ban on killer robots, and further the Non‐aligned Movement and a group of African states desire to negotiate a new international treaty to set limits on robotic killing. Previous weapons bans, from chemical and biological weapons to landmines and cluster munitions, have been effective policy tools which significantly curtailed the use of these problematic weapons. While the United States is not currently in a position to lead with its ill‐fated ‘America First’ policy, the EU and other forward‐thinking countries should attempt to set solid global norms and push for a ban on the use of AWS now. China announced last year that it wishes to ban the battlefield use of AWS, but not their development and production. This could serve as a basis for coalition negotiations with the rest of the world and would represent a key step forward in preventative security governance (Garcia, 2018).

A Treaty mandating Human control is necessary for safe AI because AI lacks a conscience

Miller, 2021 - Flight Chief, US Air Force [Amanda, Dec 14 Air Force Magazine “UN Addresses Lethal Autonomous Weapons—aka ‘Killer Robots’—Amid Calls for a Treaty” https://www.airforcemag.com/un-addresses-lethal-autonomous-weapons-aka-killer-robots-amid-calls-for-a-treaty/ Acc. 4/5/22 TA]

Van Weel represented a minority on the panel. His counterparts—an Oxford scholar and a tech attorney—supported a treaty to “de-weaponize” AI. The University of Oxford’s Xiaolan Fu, professor of technology and international development, thought that even to start a dialog would amount to progress. Considering AI to have “the risk to be as toxic as a nuclear weapon, if not more,” Tech Group co-head Jonathan Kewley of the firm Clifford Chance said AI-enabled weapons need people in the loop the same way nuclear weapons do. AI “doesn’t have a conscience. It doesn’t have a moral fiber unless it’s programmed in,” Kewley said. “AI has the risk to be as toxic as a nuclear weapon, if not more, and if we don’t have the equivalent of that moral compass, the finger on the button designed in through a treaty—because we’re not going to design the technology to prevent this unless there is a treaty involving China, the U.S., and others—we’re going to have a similar issue to nuclear risk.”

Regulating LAWs does not protect dignity – only a ban solves. Regulation maintains robot decision making over human life – it just tries to make those decisions better. But Dignity requires that they not make those decisions at all.

Docherty, 2018 - senior researcher in the Arms Division of Human Rights Watch [Bonnie August 21, “Heed the Call A Moral and Legal Imperative to Ban Killer Robots” Acc 12/27/20 TA]

There is no way to regulate fully autonomous weapons short of a ban that would ensure compliance with the principles of humanity. Fully autonomous weapons would lack the compassion and legal and ethical judgment that facilitate humane treatment of humans. They would face significant challenges in respecting human life. Even if they could comply with legal rules of protection, they would not have the capacity to respect human dignity. Limiting the use of fully autonomous weapons to certain locations, such as those where civilians are rare, would not sufficiently address these problems. “Harm to others,” which the principle of humane treatment seeks to avoid, encompasses harm to civilian objects, which might be present where civilians themselves are not. The requirement to respect human dignity applies to combatants as well as civilians, so the weapons should not be permitted where enemy troops are positioned. Furthermore, allowing fully autonomous weapons to be developed and to enter national arsenals would raise the possibility of their misuse. They would likely proliferate to actors with no regard for human suffering and no respect for human life or dignity. The 2017 letter from technology company CEOs warned that the weapons could be “weapons of terror, weapons that despots and terrorists use against innocent populations, and weapons hacked to behave in undesirable ways.”[178] Regulation that allowed for the existence of fully autonomous weapons would open the door to violations of the principles of humanity.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.