--Extend - - Bans Solves Instability
Regulations fail to solve accountability or technology concerns.
Human Rights Watch, 2018 [August 21, News Release “Killer Robots Fail Key Moral, Legal Test Principles and Public Conscience Call for Preemptive Ban” https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/08/21/killer-robots-fail-key-moral-legal-test# Acc 12/27/20 TA]
The groups found that fully autonomous weapons would undermine the principles of humanity, because they would be unable to apply either compassion or nuanced legal and ethical judgment to decisions to use lethal force. Without these human qualities, the weapons would face significant obstacles in ensuring the humane treatment of others and showing respect for human life and dignity. Fully autonomous weapons would also run contrary to the dictates of public conscience. Governments, experts, and the broader public have widely condemned the loss of human control over the use of force. Partial measures, such as regulations or political declarations short of a legally binding prohibition, would fail to eliminate the many dangers posed by fully autonomous weapons. In addition to violating the Martens Clause, the weapons raise other legal, accountability, security, and technological concerns.