Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

IR scholarship is founded on racial omission.

Lake et al. 21(David, Distinguished Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, Bianca Freedman, PhD candidate in the Department of Political Science at UC San Diego, D.G. Kim, Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, “Race in International Relations: Beyond the “Norm Against Noticing””, CS)

The field of IR is grappling with renewed calls to reform its longstanding elision of race, manifested most recently in Foreign Policy(Bhambra et al. 2020, Shilliam 2020a, Zvobgo & Loken2020) and Foreign Affairs(Blain 2020). These interventions have since been complemented by various public speaker series, webinars, and discussion forums, each retrieving important contributions that criticize IR scholarship as silent on race. Those that expose and contest this silence aptly describe it as particularly tenacious in mainstream IR, especially research that appears in the discipline’s top journals. While new efforts are being made to take race seriously, such as Búzás’s(2021) piece in the 75th anniversary special issue of International Organization and the special issue calls on race by Security Studies and Security Dialogue, IR scholars are still coming to terms with a discipline that is historically reluctant to address questions of race. The notion that IR is colorblind has long been interrogated. Seminal critiques of this notion, of which the norm against noticing is a contemporary interpretation, lay bare the centrality of race and racism in the making of an intellectual and professional discipline. The mythology of a colorblind tradition in American IR was rendered explicit by early disciplinary work on the role of White supremacy in world making. To the forebears of this critique, what was often taken to be race neutral was, in practice, silence and evasion about the African presence in world politics. As Krishna (2001) explains, race constitutes a crucial epistemic silence around which modern IR is continuously made and coheres. For Krishna, contemporary IR discourse is predicated on a systematic politics of forgetting, an abstraction from the role of racialized violence in the construction of nation-states and the system they inhabit. As the discipline developed, the timeless problems of anarchy and the security dilemma came to define the core questions of IR in line with Cold War imperatives, making race irrelevant for many scholars. Relations between states, where material power and national interest shape behavior, were assumed to occur above the supposedly domestic issue of race. Intellectual commitment to the assumption of anarchy in world politics, however, was coterminous with the discipline’s willful amnesia about race. Indeed, while implicitly equating anarchy with the primitive, and equating the resulting state of nature with supposedly violent peoples outside Europe, scholars stripped anarchy of any notion of race and racism (Sampson 2002). For some, the norm against noticing reflects a common difficulty in accepting the idea that the “international” in international relations was imagined along the color line (Vitalis 2015).For critical theorists, forgetting race cannot be reduced to discomfort, disinterest, or unaware-ness among scholars (Sabaratnam 2020). By implication, the invisibility of race in IR was not accidental but designed. Similar observations have been made about the makeup of the IR as mostly White and male, an institutionalized feature that produces and reproduces itself (Doty1993; Henderson 2007, 2013; Lake 2016; Rutazibwa 2020). That which was made most visible in IR—its distinguishing intuitions and methodologies—is also that which conceals race, denying the possibility of its explanatory power.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.