Their invocation of ecological catastrophe furthers racial violence by narratively cohering it within a linear temporality of progress.
Agathangelou, 21—Associate Professor, Department of Politics, York University (Anna, “On the question of time, racial capitalism, and the planetary,” Globalizations, 18:6, 880-897, dml) [brackets in original]
Physicists, spiritual leaders, and theorists argue ‘time is not real’ (Martin, 2020; Rovelli, 2018). It is a ‘human construct … to help us differentiate between now and our perception of the past’ (Martin, 2020). As a meaning that human groups have given to change (Tabboni, 2001), it organizes our systems of thought and our everyday lives. Time has special meaning in politics, where ‘the very distinction between truth and fiction has been made redundant’ so that ‘the criterion is no longer accuracy – it’s conformity to the needs of the moment’ (Klein, 2014; emphasis added). Our present analytical and political challenge is to grapple with the ways time is entangled with the ‘needs of the moment’ in areas of energy and climate change. Yet the politics of the ecological require understanding time. Notions like succession, simultaneity, duration, urgency, waiting, speed, geological revolutions, money, and death are expressions of time and are entangled with the ecological and its models of development.
The increasing risks to the environment as a result of the extraction of conventional oil and natural gas resources and the increased greenhouse emissions have led to what the experts have called the climate crisis. Yet as Klein says, ‘despite being convinced of the necessity of addressing our behavior as regards energy consumption, collective consciousness appears at once paralyzed and indecisive … frozen in the face of the obstacle’ (Klein, 2014). Instead of frozen time, Bourriaud points to the acceleration of time and what this has wrought: ‘the great acceleration also lies within the process of the naturalization of capitalism: now it has become both organic and universal, it is the natural law of the Anthropocene’ (cited in Chiambaretta, 2017). Mbembe (2021) expands this argument of the relations of time with the planetary by arguing the politics and aesthetics of the ecological require understanding the coloniality of power and its contemporary temporal mutations. Imperial expansion, Mbembe argues, was (is) a planetary project driven by nationalist states and companies to reallocate the earth’s resources through military might and privatization. Colonial epistemes and practices of time block the potentiality and affirmation of a planetary beyond capture and conquest (Marriott, 2011) but national decolonization cannot be ‘what gives deep breathing for the world’ (Mbembe, 2021). Some physicists speak of ‘eternity in relation to time’, wherein ‘atoms and the emptiness of the universe are infinite, uncreated, and imperishable’ (Oestreicher, 2012, p. 435). Others speak of chronological and cyclical time, attributing the first to the West and the latter to the East. Newton (1643–1727) defined time as a mathematical variable with one dimension. The only two ‘topological objects with this characteristic’ are a ‘line and a circle … . It thus follows that time is either infinite or cyclic’ (Oestreicher, 2012, p. 436). Grappling with the question of social death, Frank Wilderson argues that assembling black life into a series of historical events, into a narrative with a plot ‘is a catastrophe for narrative at a meta-level rather than a crisis or aporia within a particular narrative’ (Wilderson, 2015b). For him,
narrative time … marks stasis and change within a [human] paradigm, [but] it does not mark the time of the [human] paradigm, the time of time itself, the time by which the slave’s dramatic clock is set. For the slave, historical ‘time’ is not possible. (Wilderson, 2010, p. 339)
In this article I engage with two dominant logics1 and grammars of time,2 modernity, capitalism, and ecology: time as linear, flowing in a particular direction (determined sequencing separable in measurable units), and time as retrojection, defined as ‘a kind of projection that retrospectively testifies to ‘what comes before’’ (Walker, 2012, p. 268) or after.3 Examining how these two ideas of time become central to the co-production of the planetary as a colonial and imperial project will allow a structural engagement with the emergence and generation of the conditions for decolonial planetary relations as acts of invention (Fanon, 1967; Marriott, 2014).
A Caribbean slave proverb, ‘time is longer dan rope’, challenges the dominant notion of linear time and progress. The state and corporations continue to expropriate black lives and indigenous lands, thus ‘extract[ing] surplus from various processes of social and ecological reproduction’ (McGee & Greiner, 2020), including the obliteration of lives. These structures of death are taken for granted, including the colonial linear structures of progress and growth, their contingent epistemic edifices and the privileges that shape and enable social and ecological reproduction.
Generally speaking, temporal boundaries are drawn to render climate change or ecological crisis theorizable within certain fields, such as environmental, governance, and conservation studies. However, that which is ‘inside’ or embodies a temporal trajectory connotes what is present in the economy, while the ‘outside’ connotes a void (without time). Rather than seeing contemporary readers as always irrevocably distanced from such events, if those who write on climate change focus the language of time, they may open up new possibilities for bringing to the fore substantial structures whose temporality or lived experience is occluded or does not even register as time. In fact, the pervasive tapestries of violence and their temporal structures are challenged by theorists of black thought, indigenous studies, postcolonialism, and Fanonian studies (Rifkin 2017; Wilderson 2015a, 2015b, 2016; Fanon, 1967). They challenge historical and linear time, orienting the reader toward a reality that is neither graspable nor conquerable but a flickering reality of sensed and unsensed ‘actualities, the moment under the moment’ (Hoban, 1992). They problematize easy readings of structures and dominant systems of thought and their entanglement with notions of time, and they query the collective amnesia of temporal productions and the racial capitalist-enslaving-colonial global order where, on the one hand, things are written on water and evaporate (Shafak, 2014, p. 2) and, on the other, certain ecologies and lives are dead on arrival.
Modernist nationalist and capitalist iterations of time focus on linear teleologies/eschatologies. This orientation of the temporal operates through causality, stories of progress and growth, the plausible and possible, and ideas about movement from past to present to future and evolution (Wilk, 2007). However, another orientation, retrojection, I argue, is vital to racial ecological capitalism’s dominant power. Without engaging with both of these structures and operation of time simultaneously, we cannot understand power and its entanglements with the planetary. The temporality of capital’s projection retrospectively testifies to what comes before its current organizing. Retrojection requires us to ‘relocate ourselves into the past’, while ‘assigning purposes and ends to [such] actions’ (Motzkin, 1992) as well as a mythical agency to capital. These two expressions of temporality co-exist, at times in tension. They are inflected in our institutions and our social life.
In this piece, I look at the structure of time and ecology to trace how social sciences, humanities, and natural sciences draw on such structures to colonize, enslave, and imperialize the planetary. I trace how and when time and temporality bound the Anthropocene. The search is not for a start date but for the ways the ‘date’ or the ‘when’ is a political, economic, scientific, and ethical question (Davis & Todd, 2017, p. 761; Rifkin 2017; Whyte, 2017; Saldanha, 2020) entangled with the structure of time and what Fanon calls the invention or new beginning beyond global capital’s projects. I draw on a 2018 report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and work by Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway to register the co-production of the temporal with ‘the domains of nature, facts, objectivity, reason … policy [and] culture, values, subjectivity, emotions and politics’ (Jasanoff, 2004, p. 12).4 I use these works as a springboard for thinking how this temporal co-production expresses the tension between the reproduction of capital and the generation of life. To conclude the piece, in conversation with Octavia E. Butler, I suggest instead of dreading an impending crisis, we should read radically for the ruptures in the dominant structures of time (i.e. in narratives, dialectics, etc.) (Marriott, 2011; Wilderson, 2010) and their entanglement with questions of the planetary and climate change. Such fractal readings may yield insights into possible disinvestment from the fossil economy and open up the possibility for an indeterminate world, the passionate and living experimenting with and harnessing of the flux of energy into a vision of a decolonial whose basic premise is not conquest and enslavement.
Liberalism: always too late, or capitalism’s colonial and enslaving proactivity?
In the IPCC reports, time as a linear human orientation is placed in the context of timescales of forces requiring human intervention but out of human control: climate change. The recent SRl.5 (IPCC, 2018), ‘Global Warming of 1.5°C’, representing the ‘newer instalment of the scientisation of climate change’, situates ‘the issue beyond democratic debate by declaring it a matter for the scientific expertise of the IPCC’, and inscribes it as an emergency (Garrard, 2020, p. 1). The report suggests ‘climate change is moving faster than we are’ (Masson-Delmotte et al., 2018, p. v), and its urgency demands our intervention. However, the moral and ethical articulation of the climate as a linear temporal ‘urgency’ does not allow us to understand ecological shifts or even climate change in a larger trajectory, including human conquest, property relations, and competition. Rather, the report’s ‘foreshortened timeframe’ speaks to the urgent need of global concerted efforts to mitigate climate change and signals how temporary responses and procrastination are not going to do the trick (Garrard, 2020, p. 2).
John Mecklin, Editor of Bulletin of Atomic Scientists, similarly reminds us that time is running out:
Faced with this daunting threat landscape and a new willingness of political leaders to reject the negotiations and institutions that can protect civilization over the long term, the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists Science and Security Board today moves the Doomsday Clock 20 s closer to midnight - closer to apocalypse than ever. (Mecklin, 2020)
The moving of the clock makes the ‘climate emergency’ public, especially for those proponents of liberalism whose ‘macroscopic exclusion clauses’ have been written to ‘displace … unfreedom’ onto all marginalized, enslaved, and colonized peoples and those ‘primitive’ and ‘undeveloped’ sites ‘from a white male bourgeois European who was the historical agent in the narrative’ (Mann, 2019). Yet this moving of the clock does not address the root of the problem. It allows the positing of a secular/humanist eschatological story (Rothe, 2020, p. 162) whose temporal structure is one of immanent destruction, informed by an analysis of existence as being-towards-death (i.e. of the human and the planet) or catastrophe.
Of course, this schematic presumes death and ecological catastrophe (collapsed into one). It represents a never-reached horizon of experience, where authentic and moral decisions must be made through a theory or ‘concept of crisis or emergency’ (Mann, 2019). Liberal leaders of the international political system ‘inch toward’ an implementation of a regulatory system, what Mann and Wainwright call climate Leviathan, instead of addressing the root causes of global warming. These leaders are not creative but ‘fumble … for solutions’, continuing to argue that ‘climate change’ is a ‘market failure, without considering the limiting structures of the ‘market’ itself (Osaka, 2019, p. 2; citing Mann & Wainwright, 2018). When the moment for organized challenge emerges, white hegemony rushes to squander the creative energy and reorients social relations toward its consolidation. It does so by rushing to innovate through the co-production of narratives and an emerging ecological order.
The present as a fracture of notions of history and ‘historical natures’
Apocalypse is ‘the single most powerful master metaphor that the contemporary environmental imagination has at its disposal’ (Buell, 1995, p. 285). As such, it deranges capital and its entanglements with ecological problems, ranging from the climate change, to the extinction of species, the loss of pollinating insects, and other ecological disasters. These challenges or this ecology of environmental concerns cannot be considered in a partitioned manner.
The focus on temporality has been picked up by historians and others grappling with what the authors of the Anthropocene name a crisis and emergency. One text that speaks to the global climate change as apocalyptic temporality is Oreskes and Conway’s The Collapse of Western Civilization. In theorizing the present and the temporal possibilities for the future otherwise, these authors open the door for us to experiment with what Sheila Jasanoff and Sang-Hyun call sociotechnical imaginaries (2013). The book’s narrator is a Chinese historian in the year 2393. The historian says Western civilization possessed robust information about climate change and the ‘damaging events to unfold’ but was ‘unable to stop’ them (Oreskes & Conway, 2014, p. x, pp. 1-2), thus ‘condemning their successors to the inundation and desertification of the late twenty-first and twentysecond centuries’ (Oreskes & Conway, 2014, pp. 59–60). A second Dark Age descended, and the Period of Penumbra began. The present ignorance, the historian says, is a result of an ‘ideological fixation on ‘free’ markets; another compartmentalization and the practice among the scientific community of demanding an excessively stringent standard for accepting claims of any kind, even those involving imminent threats’ (Oreskes & Conway, 2014, pp. ix-x). In a sense, this future scenario tells nothing about the future and more about the ‘present’ – our moment.
However, the narrator’s historical account is problematic and, as Garrard argues ‘unequivocably dangerous’, as the scenario focuses on ‘catastrophic outcomes’ (Garrard, 2020, p. 3). Gallard’s critique is important to our discussion of temporality. Narrating the present as a given history evades uncertainty and possibilities for the world as a project beyond global capital. In a sense, this dystopian temporality posits itself as the ‘truth’ of our reality as if punctuating a certain kind of imaginary temporal orientation – the only one about the future. This depicted history anticipates the failure of the future by drawing on assembled empirics and technologies of problem-solving as if failure and the future are not up for debate (Jasanoff, 2019), as if the historical codes and genre choices that assemble these dystopia future scenarios are not ‘originary’ to the familiar narratives of history which they ground.
In highlighting that the Anthropocene is actually a ‘liberal managerial term’, Mann (2019) suggests the ideology of liberalism distorts the multiple social reproductions of violence and strategies of failure by sublimating them through temporal means, deploying concepts such as crises, emergencies, and exceptions, and substituting adaptation for progress. We see this in scientific reports, for example, the SRl.5 and others; while they address the metabolic rifts and shifts, they still use the Anthropocene as the social contract (Mann, 2019). In Climate Leviathan, Joel Wainwright and Geoff Mann argue crisis, risk, and uncertainty are asymmetrical, the result of the actions of a minority of humanity, i.e. the white male bourgeois European who claims the agency and writing of the historical narrative of liberalism and imperial capitalism. The Anthropocene is a technology co-productive of temporal regimes of modernity and the planetary order:
[The Anthropocene is] an explicitly future facing instrument of temporal power. Like all contracts, it restarts time on its terms. The distribution of responsibilities it represents is always also the closure of supersession of past arrangements. So, a contract that has no expiration, like a constitution or the Anthropocene, is supposed to mark the end of the past and the beginning of a new time. (Mann & Wainwright, 2018, p. 8)
The Anthropocene is itself a technology of temporal power which orders and organizes social life. In questioning this contract, Mann and Wainwright problematize how time is used to organize global power. They question whether the idea that the Anthropocene marks the end of the past as many claim and the beginning of a new time is accurate. For them, this fetishization of the Anthropocene evades the intensifying challenges to the world. The structure of ‘transition’ of the contemporary global order and the production of history of liberalism as progress (Mann & Wainwright, 2018, p. 9) are problematic and do not acknowledge how such kinds of politics are co-produced with a structure of transcendental time as their major procedural technology of governance. The transformation of the world’s political economy and the fundamental political arrangements most people take for granted thus need to be engaged on the register of the language of temporal power and the global order.