Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The affirmatives claims that democracy creates peace ignore the colonial violence democracies perpetuate and valorize the sovereign state in order to justify an unquestionable Western authority

Del Negro 20(Justin, third-year student pursuing a dual degree in International Relations at Western University and Business Administration at Ivey Business School, “Confronting the Racist Roots of International Relations”, CS)

In 1944, Karl Polanyi described the nineteenth century world as a dictum that has become the of this period in global affairs. It is true that conflict between the six or even twelve prominent Western powers when compared to previous or later centuries. However, considering conquests against weaker states and colonial wars against non-state actors produces approximately in which major powers were involved. Britain was almost during this period – either via territorial expansion or suppressing violent colonial uprisings. The Indian Revolt of 1857 alone resulted in over due to the violence and resulting famine. How can such consistent conflict occur during a period supposedly marked for its enduring peace? In international relations discourse, war is almost as an act between “sovereign powers.” Violent acts on any political entity other than a “state” (i.e. native territories, proto-states, warlords, etc.), or those committed by political entities other than a “state”, such as the British East India Company, are conveniently removed from the purview of international relations. This abstraction instantly sanitizes a violent world history, committed overwhelmingly against non-whites, that the modern international order is built upon. The distortionary impact of such a model is exemplified by the widely popular democratic peace theory, which proposes that democracies are less likely to engage in war than non-democracies. This proposition is if one simply includes a democracy’s colonial conflicts, and yet democratic peace theory has been by Western leaders during the invasion of Iraq and in other occupations of non-democratic, non-white countries. The valorization of the sovereign state, which , serves to privilege the Western model in international affairs and justify colonial and neo-colonial violence today. Both liberalism and realism, the dominant paradigms of contemporary international relations, operate from a conception of global anarchy which in many ways enforces the hierarchical racial dualism associated with early international relations theory. International relations’ conception of anarchy in the Hobbesian state of nature, which is presumed to occur in the absence of the state. However, Hobbes’ only real-life example of those in the state of nature can be found in Implicit in this analysis is the belief that while civilized democratic states established international order among themselves, the undesirable condition of anarchy was found in the backwards, non-white areas, which relied upon civilized people to impose order for them. Sampson argues that underlying the definition of anarchy is a trope of African primitivism, a developed by British anthropologists in the 1930s and 1940s which imagines a decentralized, depersonalized and uncivilized society. This representation of international politics inserts an implicit theoretical narrative which assumes racist and of a primitivism and civility, suggesting that only civilized Western powers have the authority to initiate meaningful change at the international level. The inability of international relations as an academic field to confront its Eurocentric, colonial biases makes it unfit to provide an accurate understanding of the modern state system. Just as racism impacted colonial policies abroad and domestic attitudes towards imperialism, anti-Japanese racism American engagement in World War II, and domestic racism has America’s willingness to adopt a leadership role in promoting international human rights. Race has and continues to , which shapes innumerable international decisions. The wave of white nationalism and Islamophobia across Europe in response to the Syrian refugee crisis is a testament to the modern impact of racism on foreign policy. To evolve past its harmful Eurocentric biases, international relations must abandon its colonial-era precepts and formally integrate the critical role of race within its theoretical framework.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.