Notions of US leadership further racialized governance and interventions.
Lake et al. 21(David, Distinguished Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, Bianca Freedman, PhD candidate in the Department of Political Science at UC San Diego, D.G. Kim, Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, “Race in International Relations: Beyond the “Norm Against Noticing””, CS)
Although engagement varies across the movement of critical race theories and Third World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL), much of the work within these reconstructive traditions has sought to uncover the ongoing dynamics of racialized power that constitute international law and relations. The racialization of international law can be seen in several contemporary legal and political trends that are at least implicitly premised on a conception of non-White-majority countries as being deficient and in need of assistance or corrective action by North American or European states. Good governance. The program of good governance and its strategic promotion in the non-European world illustrates this point. A term that gained considerable prominence in the field during the 1990s, good governance became a way of organizing, interpreting, and deploying legal doctrines in international politics. While norms entrepreneurs in various international and non-governmental organizations herald the concept as an advance in international law, critics note that it bears an old lineage of racialized dispossession. Influential development institutions such as the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund, as well as human rights groups, promote standards of governance that are seen as already perfected in the European world. On the other hand, non-White-majority societies are imagined in perpetual lack of the good governance needed for stability and progress. Countries that lack good governance, thus, are understood as lacking some quality implicitly assigned to White countries. According to Anghie (2006), good governance was invoked to create non-European governments that would facilitate European commercial expansion. Grovogui (1996) similarly explicates international law as “outside administration” by a West that seeks to maintain its imperial holdings long after its withdrawal. Status of Forces Agreements. Extraterritoriality in US Status of Forces Agreements (SOFAs) betrays similar assumptions about state capacity and governance. SOFAs establish when and how the domestic laws of host governments are applied to US military personnel stationed in those countries (Yeo 2014, Efrat 2022). While these agreements stop short of immunizing US troops against criminal sanctions, SOFAs effectively constrain the legal authority host countries exercise over US forces. At their core, SOFAs attempt to reconcile US interest in safeguarding soldiers’ rights with deeply held beliefs about the inferiority of non-European institutions and courts (Freeman 2021).Foreign basing contracts like SOFAs—a bargained concept of hierarchy—are not beyond prevailing symbols of subordination that reinforce pathologies of colonial legal regimes (Cooley 2017,Allen et al. 2020). The notion that non-Europeans lack “government suited to the white man” has long been embraced as “just cause” for extraterritorial jurisdiction, and in some cases, capitulation(Grovogui 1996, p. 51). A hallmark of Western foreign policy, extraterritoriality declares a kind of state of emergency where normal rules do not apply (Ruskola 2008). Variation in US SOFA jurisdiction conveys a similar story. The United States imposes concurrent jurisdiction to govern its interactions with predominantly European host states, allowing these peer countries to try US personnel while withholding this same right from most non-European host partners, ceteris pribus (Freeman 2021). Since immunity relies on the premise of inherent difference between peoples and societies (Cassel 2011), it affirms prevailing beliefs about racial difference. Thus, hierarchical conceptions of race are reified through extraterritorial jurisdiction and its codification into the SOFA Responsibility to Protect. Unanimously endorsed at the UN World Summit in 2005, the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) represents a collective commitment to atrocity prevention. Viewing authorized intervention as responsibility constitutes a departure from the norm of nonintervention established in the Montevideo Convention of 1933 and incorporated into the UN Char-ter. R2P engenders and reproduces international hierarchy through its normative diminution of sovereignty (Getachew 2019a). Integral to this process is the recasting of sovereignty as responsibility, a concept that invents the conditions for intervention in ways that are racially biased. Notwithstanding the African origins of R2P, often cited to thwart charges of neo-imperialism, the doctrine of responsibility appeals to the paternal protection common in colonial philosophy. To be sure, the shadow of racial hierarchy in international law is long. From the Berlin Treaty, which “enshrined the responsibility of Europe in watching over and improving the conditions of native populations” (Gathii 1998, p. 202; emphasis original), to the League of Nations settlement, which excluded those lowest in the race hierarchy from its international supervisory mechanism (the mandate system), racism and the rhetoric of responsibility are constitutive of the principle and need for intervention (Gathii 1998, Grovogui 1996). R2P is no exception. The principle renders sovereignty conditional upon the evaluations of international institutions (like the UN Security Council) that are empowered to decide when a state has failed to fulfill its responsibility (Getachew2019a). At its core, R2P reflects the same projection of deficiency onto non-White countries, promoting the idea that countries lack either the will or the capacity to treat their domestic populations equitably and fairly. The fruit of this alleged failure of responsibility is the near-exclusive application of R2P toward African states