IR is utilized to establish a system of racial logics that overcodes the globe
Lake et al. 21(David, Distinguished Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, Bianca Freedman, PhD candidate in the Department of Political Science at UC San Diego, D.G. Kim, Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, “Race in International Relations: Beyond the “Norm Against Noticing””, CS)
As the Howard School knew, race is a social construct that categorizes or classifies humans ac-cording to contrived differences. Its categories—races—are always and everywhere contested, a product of social struggle. As such, race is nearly always vertically stratified, entitling members of the ranked categories different rights and privileges within society. Omi & Winant (1994, p. 60)center this idea of racial hierarchy in their theory of racial formation. They explain that hierarchy is established and sustained as a racial project such that “everybody learns...the rules of racial classification and of her racial identity...inserted in a comprehensively racialized social structure. Race becomes ‘common sense’—a way of comprehending, explaining, and acting in the world.” As Bonilla-Silva (1997) suggests, racialization—the process by which groups are attributed racial meaning—conditions how actors relate to the social structures and institutional systems they in-habit. As an organizing principle of super- and subordination, it orders race hierarchically and engenders behaviors and interests to fit the position of the groups in the racial regime. Fanon [2008 (1952)] perceived racial hierarchy and the process of racialization in the language of colonial domination. To internalize the norms of the colonizer was to participate in one’s own oppression, to reflect the very hierarchical structures of alienation. Once racial stratification is established and its “racial logics” are absorbed (Hobson & Sharman 2005), race becomes an in-dependent criterion for vertical hierarchy in a society, both domestic and international. And to be sure, race as a hierarchy is international. Wynter (2003) argues that a globally expanding West used race to define and order the human. The color line encoded deserving and undeserving status within Western imperial orders. Racial hierarchy becomes important in IR in at least two fundamental ways, explored in more detail below. Though the coin may eventually be revealed as multisided, we see perceived deficiency and hostility as the two faces of racism in world politics. In the first face, countries below the color line are perceived to be deficient in some essential attribute. Through the mid-twentieth century, this face of racism was manifested in the “standard of civilization” criteria for establishing sovereignty and acceptance into the family of nations. As the norm of juridical sovereignty took hold after the formation of the United Nations, conferring sovereignty on any recognized member of the international community regardless of their capacity to govern their territory effectively ( Jackson 1990), the same projection of deficiency onto countries with majorities of people of color continued in the practice and interpretation of international law. In the second face, non-White-majority countries are perceived by White-majority countries to be inherently aggressive or threatening. Within a racialized global order, dominant actors perceive racially “inferior” foreign countries as potentially destabilizing to the status quo. This is precisely how Du Bois [2005(1906), p. 34] construed the problem of the color line: the prospect of war and peace hinges upon how White-majority countries cope with perceived challenges from the “awakening of the brown and black races.” The integrated analytic framework in Figure 1 illustrates the intersections of racial hierarchy, international law, and foreign policy. First, norms, including the norm of racial hierarchy, are so deeply woven into the fabric of social life that they appear natural, effectively conditioning the design and enforcement of an international legal order (i). Once the embedded social norm(in this case, the norm of racial hierarchy) is codified, international law further authorizes and promotes it (ii), which is often the intended goal of norms entrepreneurs in international politics In other words, international law, racialized in its content and enforcement, helps consolidate what Reus-Smit (2017, p. 875) calls the “authorized forms of difference” along the color line. As discussed in more detail below, uneven application of law brace plagues international politics. Providing rules that order relations between states with different status, rights, and responsibilities, international law thus guides the practice of foreign policy making (Figure 1, iii), which in turn reproduces an unequal global order that is underwritten by the international legal system as well as the racial hierarchy embedded within it (iv). Racial hierarchy also implicates foreign policy and practice more directly. The racial norm shapes foreign policies by conditioning how actors perceive their interests, interpret the position and interests of racial others, and act accordingly. As emphasized by Jackson (2006, p. 16), racial hierarchy affects foreign policy making through the process of legitimation, defined as “the process of drawing and (re)establishing boundaries, ruling some courses of action acceptable and others unacceptable.” By supplying the language of legitimation that shapes predominant foreign policy discourses, racial hierarchy thus renders certain foreign policies acceptable and therefore possible (Figure 1, v). Similar to how international law facilitates the authorization of racial hierarchy (ii), foreign policy and practice in turn further reinforce the norm of racial hierarchy, reifying the contrived racial categories and differences (vi). Below, we provide a more in-depth discussion on how racial hierarchy shapes the formulation of foreign policy. Altogether, the interactions of racial hierarchy, international law, and foreign policy reaffirm one another and produce a racialized world that is taken for granted.