IR is rooted in racism and eurocentrism
Lake et al. 21(David, Distinguished Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, Bianca Freedman, PhD candidate in the Department of Political Science at UC San Diego, D.G. Kim, Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, “Race in International Relations: Beyond the “Norm Against Noticing””, CS)
In a parallel fashion, as suggested above, race is hidden behind international law and the principle of sovereign equality. Rooted in conceptions of natural law, international law is necessarily universal and based on principles of equality. Yet, race was implicated in the development of international law almost from its very origins (see, e.g., Pitts 2018). The vision of equality at its core was immediately challenged by Europe’s encounter with the rest of the world during the age of discovery. If international law applied universally to peoples, their territory, and their existing governance structures, then Europeans would have to recognize these unfamiliar polities as equal to their own, which in turn would have prevented them from expropriating the land and enslaving those who lived on it. To justify expropriation, international law thus required the creation or application of racialized hierarchies that considered non-European societies as less than human. The interpretation of race as a stable, self-evident difference became the marker from which more elaborate notions of difference, like “civilization,” were constructed (Anghie 2006). In one such justification, John Locke declared the territory occupied by Indigenous peoples in the Americas as forfeit for their failure to enclose and cultivate the land (see Arneil 1996). In short, international law required Europeans to assign a lesser status to others in order to reconcile the conception of equality under the law that governed their own relations with the desire to exploit the “new worlds” they “discovered.” Thus, race was tethered to the rationale for conquest undertaken by European powers. Race continued to animate international law and relations between Europe and the rest of the world well into the twentieth century. In negotiations over the League of Nations in 1919, for instance, Japan’s proposed language on racial equality was rejected. Although it received broad support, US President Woodrow Wilson, who himself had resegregated the US civil service, was in the Chair and summarily declared that such an important change required unanimity, which effectively killed the proposal. Following World War II, renewed calls for formal racial equality at the San Francisco Conference in 1945 and later the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination in 1969 led to the prohibition of racism, but subtly embedded it in the precept of sovereignty and the corresponding doctrine of domestic jurisdiction that allowed member countries to prohibit international oversight of their domestic racial regimes(Búzás 2021). As a shield against foreign interference, sovereignty became a way of preserving racial inequality at home. Its universal standard also gave rise to an international legal order that obscured racism from view. By the mid-twentieth century, non-European societies acquired the status of sovereign state-hood previously denied by international law. On its face, decolonization overcame the notion that racial others were somehow not ready for full sovereignty (Grovogui 1996). In practice, however, writing race out of law was necessary to conceal, and therefore maintain, the uneven application of international norms and rules along constructed racial difference. By implication, formal manifestations of race are no longer permissible. But at the same time, the projection of racial deficiency by White-majority countries onto especially Black-majority states is found in the practice and interpretation of contemporary international law. Although engagement varies across the movement of critical race theories and Third World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL), much of the work within these reconstructive traditions has sought to uncover the ongoing dynamics of racialized power that constitute international law and relations. The racialization of international law can be seen in several contemporary legal and political trends that are at least implicitly premised on a conception of non-White-majority countries as being deficient and in need of assistance or corrective action by North American or European states