Realism is bad, ensures racialization is cemented in all areas of IR.
Vitalis 2K(Robert, Professor of Political Science at the University of Pennsylvania, “The Graceful and Generous Liberal Gesture: Making Racism Invisible in American International Relations”, CS)
IR theorists have often hidden behind realism’s wings to face these kinds of criticism; they have argued that the distinctiveness of their subject matter sets them apart and makes the ‘norm against noticing’ irrelevant in this case. In relations among states, where material power and interest govern the behaviour of actors bent on survival in a violence-prone environment, an overarching logic of security and the national interest prevails. Even a ‘domestic politics’ of white supremacy, to use a familiar adage, stops at ‘the water’s edge’. Pursuit of this particular line of thought, however, would quickly take the naïve defender of an American-invented tradition down a slippery slope. The empirical quandary remains. ‘Until recently, race was a central category in international relations’ for statesmen, intellectuals, and the white working classes of the colonial powers and the industrialising colonial-settler states.17 More crucially still, realism’s own proximate indigenous roots in the US may be found in part in the ‘rising tide of colour’ theory in the 1920s and related strains of Anglo-Saxon declinism.18 Realism was not so much ‘founded’ in the 1940s by a wave of émigré continental European scholars, but recast in line with Cold War imperatives, which included the jettisoning of what was coming to be recognised as overt racist doctrines by whites who ruled the ‘kingdom of culture’ and the writing of a more useable past for their adopted discipline.19 What needs to be explained is not how a particular domain of intellectual life somehow escaped the bounds of ascriptive Americanism—it didn’t—but why the ‘norm against noticing’ appears to work so much more powerfully there than elsewhere inside the academy until now? The question, I believe, involves ‘domestic institutions’. Few signs remain of the academy’s insurgent moment inside professional IR in the US.20 The oppositional and anti-imperialist values that constituted the original identity of political economy in the 1960s and 1970s are reflected more powerfully today in parts of Anthropology, Cultural Studies, Gender Studies, Literature, and History than in Political Science, and more in British Political Science than in the American Political Science Association. This might be gauged by comparing the renaissance in the study of the culture of empire and American expansionism with the paucity of work by political scientists. One might look at the index of the New Left Review over the past two decades for a sense of what is ‘left’ in Political Science and who in American IR might be publishing there, aside from Richard Falk (answer: no one). Last, and undoubtedly most important, one might look around the room at the next seminar, conference plenary, or talk for insight into the culture of American IR and the operation of the ‘norm against noticing’. The absence of virtually any, let alone a critical mass of, black thinkers and writers in the field today goes a long way toward explaining why white supremacy remains an unexposed foundation of the field and why the Black Atlantic remains an unrecognised source (for mostly white IR scholars that is) of the emancipatory counter-currents that we know today as imperialism theory, ‘underdevelopment’ ‘postcolonial theory’, dependencia, world systems analysis, and so on.