Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Their evidence comes from a position of privilege---their authors ignore the complex racialization of great power relations compromising the quality of their theorizing and the field of IR itself

Peterson 21(V Spike, professor of international relations in the School of Government and Public Policy at the University of Arizona, “Critical privilege studies: Making visible the reproduction of racism in the everyday and international relations”, CS)

Familiar structural inequalities – of race, gender, class, nationality – and corresponding systems of privilege constitute relations of domination and subordination that figure centrally in the social violence and multiple crises that international relations and security scholars struggle to address. These scholars, however, rarely engage a critique of privilege when interpreting these processes, which effectively perpetuates the invisibility (naturalization) of power relations and precludes more adequate critical theorizing. Privilege refers to socially conferred unearned advantages available to some by being constitutively denied to others. Two implications of this structural relationship: the privilege enjoyed by dominant groups is literally at the expense of subordinated groups, and systemic inequalities do not only harm those who are dominated but significantly benefit – every day and over time, intentionally and unintentionally, directly and indirectly – those who are privileged. Failing to ‘see’ this crucial, consequential and structural relationship – and its affective consequences – has enormous implications for how adequately we understand the reproduction of, and responses to, entrenched inequalities and the social violence they generate. Not least, we need to ‘see’ that conditions generating internalized inferiority in those who are subordinated have the effect of naturalizing internalized superiority in those who can, and typically do, assume that the advantages of privilege and their practices of domination are ‘just the way things are’. Given the global expanse of harms, resentments, and violences that we confront, I argue that critical theorists – in security studies, international relations, and elsewhere – cannot afford to persist in neglecting privilege. This neglect perpetuates ignore-ance of consequential power relations and obscures how practices of privilege, every day and everywhere, operate to reinforce, normalize, and reproduce structural inequalities. I assume that critical security studies seeks to further a reduction in emotional and embodied harms produced by, and productive of, structural inequalities, and I argue that doing so requires accurately understanding and actively dismantling the power relations of privilege. Accordingly, I contend that failure to critically engage how privilege operates severely compromises both the quality of current theorizing and the future field of critical security studies. My contribution, then, situates racism in the intersectional matrix of structural inequalities, foregrounds how systems of privilege operate to reproduce this matrix and its many harms, and examines the role of white privilege in reproducing the invisibility and normalization of racism (and its related inequalities). I present a condensed overview of what I call ‘critical privilege studies’2 and indicate how this analytical framing contributes to ‘a radically different, anti- or nonracist [international relations] and everyday’ (Rutazibwa, 2016: 199). I argue that the systematic study of privilege shifts our attention, illuminates unfamiliar patterns, and enriches critical theorizing within and beyond international relations. Critical privilege studies makes distinctive contributions, primarily by examining how those who benefit the most – every day and everywhere – participate in reproducing inequalities, sometimes intentionally but also – most often and most problematically – when not ‘consciously’ intending to do so (but doing so all the same). The specific orientation of critical privilege studies reveals how normalization reproduces – while concealing – the power relations and structural logics of dominant–subordinate relations, and how behaving ‘normally’ in unequal systems reinforces and reproduces their hierarchies, whether intentionally or not. Critical privilege studies clarifies how privilege works to entrench and amplify systemic inequalities, while enabling those with privilege to be unaware of, habitually ignore, and also deny how privilege tilts the playing field in their favor – a reality that fosters feelings of superiority for some and inferiority for others. And by recognizing that everyone occupies multiple social categories, critical privilege studies uniquely engages the complex dynamics of theorizing intersectionality and points to the inadequacy of critical projects that focus exclusively on a single vector of oppression.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.