Vote negative for post-racist critical IR scholarship – revealing the Westphilian epistemologies present in the aff is critical to holding them accountable for their double standards and working towards decolonization
Hobson 07(John, Professor of Politics and International Relations at the University of Sheffield, “Is critical theory always for the white West and for Western imperialism? Beyond Westphilian towards a post-racist critical IR”, CS)
If Eurocentrism portrays the West as bringing the world to heel, post-racist emancipatory politics seeks to bring the world to heal. How, then, might we begin to imagine this? Post-racist IR singles out analyses of identity-formation and civilisational dialogues/dialectics as the first port of call for a global emancipatory politics. The centre-piece of racism as it has been constructed in the West is a repressing of the Other in the Self. It is precisely this that underpins the Eurocentric construction of a line of civilisational apartheid, which creates the illusion of a pure, self-generating, supremacist White Western Self. Accepting the Other in the Self and recognising that the Self is therefore hybrid must be central to the process of global reconciliation. The second step is, however, much more fraught but all the more pressing nevertheless – namely the creation of a political dialogue between East and West.100 This can take the form of a counter-hegemonic bloc comprising a rainbow coalition of groups from the West though mainly from the East, which can articulate an alternative discourse to challenge Eurocentric post-racism. Still, there are undoubtedly many hurdles that stand in its way. These include the not inconsiderable spiritual capital that Westerners have invested in their Eurocentric identity; the economic interests of capital in maintaining post-racist neo-colonialism; and, ironically, those Eastern political elites who embrace Eurocentrism in order to hold on to power. But global reconciliation need not be portrayed as an impossible dawn, for there is historical precedent here in the shape of the Eastern nationalist movements that successfully challenged the discourse of empire. And while decolonisation has been succeeded by the imposition of post-racist policies this should not detract from the success of Eastern resistance agency in terminating formal empire. Decolonisation also provides a crucial precedent given that ‘the setting of the sun on the British empire’ was always portrayed by the British elites as an impossible dusk. Salutary too is that Nelson Mandela’s long walk to freedom would also have appeared prior to its success as a feat too far. Naeem Inayatullah and David Blaney argue that this political dialogue needs to work on an empathic approach in which both sides appeal to their own experiences of suffering.101 This needs to be coupled with a major injection of humility in the West, which can be enabled by revealing, and facing up to, the massive moral debt that it owes the East (given that the East did so much to enable the West’s rise through both dialogue and sacrifice). In any case, failure to do this is to be complicit with that which went on not just in the past but also in the last fifty years. But alongside these rhetorical manoeuvres, the Eastern and Western spokespersons need to emphasise the contradictions and double standards that underpin contemporary post-racist Western foreign policy. Here they need to engage not simply in dialogue but a dialogical dialectic wherein the East prosecutes the unfair and hypocritical practices of the post-racist West in what might be called the ‘global court of social justice’. This is not a legal entity, though it is governed like any (formal) court by a certain set of (social) norms that adjudicate over what is right and wrong. The nationalist movements effectively prosecuted the West in the global court of social justice through ‘mimetic challenge’,102 or ‘rhetorical entrapment’,103 where they rendered empire illegitimate by appealing to Western social norms of justice, since there was no other way of revealing the racist double standards that the West committed in its imperial policies (much as the Black Jacobins had done in the earlier Haitian revolution).104 Crucially, if revealing the racism of empire had such powerful import in effecting decolonisation, then why cannot the strategy of revealing post-racism today equally be used to decolonise contemporary neo-colonialism? Thus a counter-hegemonic bloc needs to work within the interstices of Western discourse to reveal the postracist contradictions and double standards that it consciously and subconsciously smoothes over, in order to demonstrate how the West currently fails to uphold its own self-referential norms of human justice. Appealing only to Eastern norms would most likely be rejected out of hand by the West with no progress forward possible. Indeed, ‘[f]or the oppressed it is a strategic necessity to address the oppressor in its own language, the language which it knows and understands: indeed the point is to manipulate the self-understanding of the oppressor’.105 Besides, no court can operate according to conflicting norms. And it is to the West that the East must turn if only because it currently holds disproportionate (though not anthropomorphic) power. Still, this dialogical project is one that can simultaneously benefit the West.106 For as noted, Eurocentrism leads to the repression and sublimation of the Other in the Self. Thus doing away with Eurocentrism can end the sociopsychological angst and alienation that necessarily occurs through such sublimation. Indeed, the ultimate irony is that racist/post-racist Western imperialism has underdeveloped the Western Self. And so, hopes for Western emancipation must to an important extent lie with the ‘Eastern civilising mission’ and the associated ‘Black Human’s Burden’, which can launch the Western peoples on an ethnographic maiden Voyage of Self-discovery that, with humility, empathy and above all sincerity, steers around the icebergs of tragic self-deception to return fully humanised. In the process, we take one giant leap towards a global dream that exorcises the global nightmare of cycles of war and Western civilising missions – a dream in which the dusk of post-racism brings in its wake the dawn of a new era wherein the peoples of the world can finally sit down at the table of global humanity and communicate together as equal partners.