Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The historical record goes neg.

Lake et al. 21(David, Distinguished Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, Bianca Freedman, PhD candidate in the Department of Political Science at UC San Diego, D.G. Kim, Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, “Race in International Relations: Beyond the “Norm Against Noticing””, CS)

The critique of IR’s race blindness begins with the Howard School. The tradition of unveiling the modern world from its racialized origins was proffered by Howard University–based African American IR scholars beginning in the late nineteenth century (Henderson 2013, 2017; Vitalis2015). Arguably path-breaking, the contributions associated with the Howard School highlight IR’s systematic failure to appreciate race and its inscription into world order. Silence about racism in IR, imposed in part by the exclusion of work that advanced its critique (Vitalis 2000), obscured race as an orienting worldview in the emergent field. Despite various adaptations of publications like Foreign Affairs—which had been titled the Journal of Race Development from 1910 to 1919—its genealogy implies what early scholars deemed the subject of IR to be. This veneer of substantive change in the discipline was counterpoised by W.E.B. Du Bois’s seminal thesis on the color line, first offered in The Souls of Black Folk[2015 (1903)] and later extended in “The Color Line Belts the World” (1906). Du Bois noted, “The problem of the twentieth century is the problem of the Color Line” [2005 (1906), p. 33]. For Du Bois, White supremacy and anti-Blackness were organizing principles of US expansionism. Similarly, other scholars of the Howard School made plain that theorizing the international required careful scrutiny of its imperial, colonial, and neocolonial foundations [Locke 1992 (1916), Bunche 1936, Tate (1943)]. Notwithstanding, mid-century debates in the field over stability, dependency, and territorial sovereignty were underpinned with racial ontologies, willful or otherwise, that privileged Whiteness in their assumptions about the social world (Vucetic 2016).This early critique of IR’s race blindness was elaborated in opposition to the incipient field’s essentialist notions of race. For Alain Locke and Ralph Bunche, race was what today we recognize as a social construct based on phenotypic characteristics that are themselves socially constructed. By advancing this argument, Locke and Bunche removed race from its biological and anthropological moorings, effectively rejecting the “hierarchy of races” assumption that anchored the developing field of IR (Henderson 2013). Locke’s [1992 (1916)] sociological thesis of race as a product occulture informed Bunche’s (1936) subsequent analysis in A World View of Race. For Bunche, race was arbitrary. Devoid of any scientific meaning, race was a device of national policy that shaped bargaining in class conflict. The Howard School also anticipated much of the postwar scholarship on race and racism in IR. To be sure, it developed some of the earliest theory of modern war as an outcome of imperialist and other racial projects (Du Bois 1915, Tate 1943, Bunche 1936), a point delivered in Henderson’s (2017) critique of Vitalis’s (2015) apparent disassociation of these scholars from the formulation of IR theory. Though met with scant regard, the insights developed by the Howard School unveil an IR that not only noticed race but also highlighted it as a prominent axis of inquiry and theory building. The norm against noticing has since been engaged by scholars, and this confrontation actively informs the present debate. Across interlocking approaches to the study of race, new scholarship coheres around the assertion that race and racism are unavoidable when grappling with the is-sues and methodologies of IR (Persaud & Walker 2000; Shilliam 2013, 2020b). The norm against noticing has been challenged by excavating disciplinary genealogies and unveiling forms of racialization as power in IR. Burgeoning literature on Eurocentrism (Hobson 2012) and new advances in non-Western IR theory, embodied by the “Global IR” project (Acharya & Buzan 2009, Haggard& Kang 2020), similarly examine the imperial conditions that constitute relations between the European “core” and the non-White “peripheries.” Recent contributions in the field also illuminate the racial and gendered patterns of IR canon formation. In a recent essay, for instance, Hutchings & Owens (2021) expose opportunities to theorize race in IR through a fundamental reorientation toward the international thought of women (of color).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.