The alt is a prerequisite to ethical IR scholarship – discomfort is necessary to deter institutions from employing the politics of denial
Vitalis 2K(Robert, Professor of Political Science at the University of Pennsylvania, “The Graceful and Generous Liberal Gesture: Making Racism Invisible in American International Relations”, CS)
Once, after I presented an account of the Saudi case, a colleague asked: ‘why do you seem surprised by any of this, what did you expect?’ This question tells us something about how the Cold War ‘norm against noticing’, the ‘graceful and generous liberal gesture’ proceeds, what it presumes. Race is already known, banal and commonplace, not worth noticing. Race is ‘really’ something else. Race is a ‘language that most would today find offensive and inappropriate’. This last statement sums up how the best history we have to date of the discipline of IR, Political Discourse of Anarchy, by Brian Schmidt, deals with the most significant force in American politics and culture. Schmidt dismisses in a single sentence in a self-styled discursive history what was known at the time to be basic to understanding world politics, the ‘conflict of color’.89 More recently, a colleague politely pressed me to name a single work by the towering intellect of the twentieth century that was significant for any aspect of IR. This form of question is a well-known reflex that is triggered when canons of seemingly timeless truths come under interrogation. But the truth is that ‘African Roots of War’, Du Bois’ bold attempt to theorise on imperialism and global conflict, which his biographer Levering Lewis calls ‘one of the analytical triumphs of the early twentieth century’, has never been anthologised or discussed in any IR theory text in the US.90 While ‘African Roots’ was celebrated then, and Du Bois lectured widely to black and white audiences at home and abroad on the topic, we are much more likely now to reference white writers—E.D. Morel’s Africa and the Peace of Europe, and especially, Lenin’s Imperialism: The Highest Stage of Capitalism—when creating our genealogies and canons of anti-imperialism and ‘radical’ theory traditions in world politics. Lord Zimmern, in contrast to Du Bois, is almost always included in one story IR tells about World War I and its putative impact on the emerging discipline in Great Britain and the US.91 But the transcripts of Lord Zimmern’s deeply rooted, extended, and quite serious conversations with his many colleagues about race as a fundamental part of world order, ‘the most urgent problem of our time’, inevitably go unreported, and so the questions they raise for Zimmern’s successors remain unresolved. The first post-war generation of émigré theorists was equally successful in mythmaking of its own. They created a world where realist thought in its classic geopolitical mode is a coherent and continuous tradition across space and time. Today’s national security debates and self-serving ‘strategic justifications’ are represented as the close echoes of earlier debates inside imperial states and societies. At key moments, the promotion of civilisation, greatness, and modernity (or, now, democracy and market economies), the preservation of a hegemon’s credibility, and other expansionist credos trump the arguments of those who really understand the true strategic or security value inhering in one course over that of another. Old metaphors are compared with new ones, for instance, a row of falling dominoes, a barrel contaminated by one rotten apple, and the like.92 Representatives of the American geopolitics tradition, such as Ellsworth Huntington and Alfred Thayer Mahan, can be summoned and selectively quoted without ever acknowledging their concern with the world racial balance of power that launched the quest for a whitewater Navy as defence against the teeming Asian multitudes who threatened from land and sea.93 It is in the forgotten, yet vast literature and the terms of the ongoing public debate on ‘race war’ that we can trace the roots of what is later recast as an American realist tradition in IR theory. We have to acknowledge, nonetheless, that the collectivity that identifies itself as ‘the field of International Relations’ in the US is tightly, organically bound to a particular place, history, and social formation.94 This inescapable fact, which applies equally across ‘schools’ of thought and methodological ‘approaches’, goes far to explain why IR today has little to say about racism as an international institution or white supremacy as the identity of the American state that the field’s founders embraced and elaborated. Certainly, this problematique would provide a better explanation than one that would simply erase racism from the historical record else deny its importance. It would place the post-Holocaust, post-World War II invention of realism as a tradition that argues against the explanatory significance of ideas (and morality) in world politics in a new and disturbing light. Critical alternatives need to be elaborated in opposition to the ‘norm against noticing’ and to the wider so-called ‘realist’ strains in American life (defined against hopelessly utopian visions about ‘ending war’ or ‘transcending capitalism’) that, without a hint of irony, insist that a ‘colour blind’ society is now within easy reach.95 Such are the terms today in which privilege is defended and hierarchy reconstituted. The embeddedness of writers and readers in a particular cultural formation is inescapable. But so too is the work of ‘clearing intellectual and moral space’ in this particular part of the increasingly globalised academy: Racial constructs are being forced to reveal their struts and bolts, their technology and their carapace, so that political action, legal and social thought, and cultural production can be generated sans racist cant, explicit or in disguise.96 Political Science, like other institutions, is constituted and regulated by a set of norms and armoured by a repertoire of material awards and sanctions that can affect the likelihood that members of the profession themselves will pursue the work that Toni Morrison writes about in ‘Home’.97 My interest in writing on racism is the chance that it offers to imagine what can be done to make it less easy and less safe for others to practice the politics of its denial.