Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

His push means it passes

Galston 6/14

Wiliam, Wallstreet Journal, “How Good Bills Die in Committee” June 14, 2022

Noting that the Senate bill already represents a true bipartisan compromise, Mr. Young argues that it would be unreasonable to expect the final agreement to split the difference between the House and Senate versions. Instead, it should be much closer to the Senate bill. Mr. Schumer understands this, he said, as do Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo and the White House, but apparently Mrs. Pelosi does not. Mr. Young was candid about the trade provisions of the bill, a major sticking point. During Senate deliberations, he said, some Republican senators insisted on new trade language, and the ensuing disagreement was successfully resolved in negotiations between Senate Finance Committee Chairman Ron Wyden and Mike Crapo, the committee’s ranking Republican. This bipartisan agreement wasn’t acceptable to House Democrats, and the matter is being relitigated between Mr. Crapo and House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Richard Neal. Describing their positions as “principled disagreement,” Mr. Young is “concerned” that their differences might prove difficult to resolve soon. Consumer groups and app developers believe that the Wyden-Crapo trade provisions will undermine the Europe Union’s regulatory framework for digital trade. Mrs. Pelosi also appears to believe this. Mr. Wyden defends his language as a serious effort to fight authoritarian forces engaged in “digital censorship,” although he is open to refinements distinguishing between censorship and regulations addressing data privacy, antitrust enforcement, and antiharassment regulations. Mr. Young says the conferees should focus on resolving disagreements that can be successfully negotiated while setting aside intractable disputes for another day. He expressed optimism that provisions concerning the National Science Foundation, national-security innovation, domestic chip production, regional technology hubs, and workforce development for advanced production fall into the “resolvable” category. He believes the government’s credibility is on the line. “We have an opportunity to show that regular order can produce a broad bipartisan bill,” he says, but this is unlikely to happen, he added, unless President Biden pushes it across the goal line. In remarks on the America Competes Act last month, a frustrated president exclaimed, “Pass the damn bill and send it to me.” Unless he gets directly involved, this probably won’t happen, and America’s best chance in decades to boost domestic innovation and manufacturing could die in committee.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.