We turn war into models in every debate, our impacts are our enemies, and we plan carefully the precise tactics needed to eliminate them. This schematization is an effort not to fix the ends but to solely engage with the means themselves- we try to make war into a knowable moment but only end up sanitizing war, killing becomes justified as precise, understandable, and clean thus rationalizing all violence and legitimizing it. The more we try to know war the more war will know us.
Bousquet et al 20 (Antoine Bousquet, Jairus Grove, Nisha Shah, “Becoming War: Towards a Martial Empiricism”,2020) GP
If mobilization addresses the marshalling of resources – bodies, affects and materiel – towards violent ends, we propose design as the frame by which to investigate the concretization of war’s means – or what is generally referred to as warfare. Given its realization in destructive techniques and tools for the purpose of obliterating life and the will to resist with maximum efficiency, the philosophical shadow cast over the activity of design renders it a particularly apposite concept. 108 Security Dialogue 51(2-3) Indeed, as Singleton (2011) shows, design has always been associated with deviousness and duplicity, a realm of schemes, plots and contrivances, where craft is synonymous with craftiness. Recovering the specific ‘cunning intelligence’ known to the ancient Greeks as metis, Detienne and Vernant (1991: 47) highlight those ‘activities in which man [sic] must learn to manipulate hostile forces too powerful to be controlled directly but which can be exploited despite themselves’. Alongside the machinations against nature that ‘give craftsmen their control over material which is always more or less intractable to their designs’, they identify ‘the stratagems used by the warrior the success of whose attack hinges on surprise, trickery or ambush’ (Detienne and Vernant, 1991: 47–48). Characterized by remarkable, wicked feats of technical and tactical ingenuity and decisively shaped by existential confrontation with an enemy that must be outwitted – if necessary, by means of trickery and deception – war is arguably the field of human activity that most accords with the conspiratorial spirit of design. This provocation of ‘war by design’ is inspired by Simone Weil’s (1987: 241) insistence that ‘the most defective method possible’ for apprehending war is ‘in terms of the ends pursued, and not by the nature of the means employed’. Armed conflicts cannot be reduced to the political motivations or moral justifications that legitimate them. Ends are pursued with specific means, generating war as a particular kind of force. Little, therefore, can be gleaned or done about war without ‘having first of all taken apart the mechanism of the military struggle’ (Weil, 1987: 241). Grégoire Chamayou (2015) accordingly calls for ‘political technicians’ to uncover and expose war’s core operations in all their intelligibility and compulsion. Indeed, in grasping the functioning of an actual device, the technical study of war can ‘discover the implications of how it works for the action that it implements’ (Chamayou, 2015: 15). Attention is thereby directed towards war’s mechanisms and the apparatuses through which warfare is assembled and executed. Design implies a remit much broader than the obvious instruments of warfare, such as weapons or other such material objects inserted in the wider machinations of war. Nor can design be confined to formal military institutions and their associated research-and-development complexes, particularly in an age of proliferating ‘dual-use’ technologies, improvised explosive devices (IEDs), 3D-printed firearms, dark-web supply chains, cyberhacking and paramilitary swarm tactics. Rather, a focus on the instrumentality of warfare should be broadened to ‘the ways in which the art of war – its tools, its tactics and its tenor – is generated and governed’ (Shah, 2017: 90). To this end, design allows war to be ‘glimpsed in action’ (Singleton, 2011: 5) in the concatenation of actors, objects and operations that are not just implicated in but generative of a ‘savage ecology’ (Grove, 2019). A focus on design pries open the concrete activities of organized violence, revealing how they cohere and combine to make certain forms of war possible or impossible. Attention is brought to contours (the spaces and objects that delineate the stage within which war is set) and repertoires (the registers of permissible actions that can be performed), revealing how form and function are implied in one another in schemes, signatures and subterfuges. At a first pass, the schemes of war can be recognized within the tactical directives, operational procedures and strategic manoeuvres that animate military organizations and are subject to continuous reflexive exercises.9 More fundamentally still, schemes can be thought of as schematics, diagrams of operation through which bodies, implements and terrains are arranged into apparatuses of war. While all these various elements may not have been designed from the outset to serve war, as they fall within its ambit they acquire new martial functions, all the while exerting their own respective influences on the resulting ensembles. One can evoke here the human–spear–shield assemblage of the Nguni warrior, the human–stirrup–horse of cavalry, or the human–radio–rifle of the modern platoon, in their various tactical deployments (Deleuze and Guattari, 1987; Protevi, 2013). Denman (2020) addresses the architectural topographies of war, a history encompassing rudimentary earthworks, Vauban’s geometric fortifications and today’s wider enlistment of the Bousquet, Grove and Shah 109 built environment, all of which exist in relation to topologies of terrain and territory (see also Elden, 2013; Hirst, 2005; Scott, 2016; Weizman, 2007). As diagrams of power (Deleuze, 1986), schemes should not be viewed in terms of mere technical exercises, which is how their own designers are frequently prone to regarding them, but as micropolitical activities through which forms of warfare are summoned, conducted, reproduced and even anticipated (Öberg, 2020). Every war has its signature features. These range from the fashioned characteristics of its infrastructure, weaponry and soldiers to the more emergent traits of its collisions, injuries and devastations. All are subject to attempts at calibrating them, with the resulting expressions of armed conflict the product of intentional design’s encounter with both wilful resistance and recalcitrant reality.10 At stake is not merely the optimal allocation of limited resources towards instrumental ends but also the legitimation of the act of killing through conformity with established norms or laws. A firearm must efficiently convert a thermodynamic explosion into directed lethality, yet it must also not result in injury that is superfluous or unnecessary (Ford, 2019; Shah, 2017). The dead body is not just the net outcome of a direct hit, but an ideal, the pursuit of a legitimate kind of killing through the effect of military engineering, scientific experimentation and medical observation under legal and moral judgement. Attending to such details as the calibre of bullets is thus not a way of sanitizing the study of war from its deadly effects but, on the contrary, a means to understanding how those effects are ‘standardized’ within the military repertoire (Dittmer, 2017). More broadly, standardization alludes to the broader role of protocol in warfare, ranging from seemingly mundane quotidian routines or sartorial requirements to the standard operating procedures by which lethal violence is executed (Monk, 2020). In each of these instances, specific protocols impart on war particular styles that cannot be apprehended solely by reference to instrumental designs but are also necessarily expressive of a particular aesthetic or ethos (Meiches, 2017). Finally, war is the realm of subterfuge. Returning to the roots of design in deception and trickery, we recall that war is conducted through an encounter with an opposing force that must be anticipated and negated. As Lisle’s study of bomb disposal robots illustrates (2020), advanced militaries are prone to losing sight of this, obsessed with optimizing their own processes and perfecting their technologies, but are invariably reminded of it, not least because it is the principal way by which they are foiled by supposedly inferior adversaries. Throughout the ages, belligerents have devised countless stratagems towards the dissimulation of their presence, movements and intentions, as well as the proactive disinformation and misdirection of their antagonists. The particular instantiations of these can be found in the various techniques of camouflage, stealth, disguise, decoy and deception that populate the history of war (Bousquet, 2018). The more general figure here is that of the trap, laid to lure the target by exploiting its habits and proclivities so as to ensnare it in a situation in which its strengths can be offset or even turned against itself. Chamayou (2012) has coined the term ‘cynegetics’ to denote the kinship between war and hunting – the predatory character of power counterposed to the commonly inherited image of pastoral care under biopolitics. War is a hunt, the pursuit of another that can hunt you back. Last but not least, with etymological roots in the Latin for ‘flight’, subterfuge also hints at the elusive becoming of war that no snare can ever wholly capture, however carefully designed. Encountering war Through the mobilizations and designs of armed force, martial empiricism leads us ultimately to the encounter with war understood at its paroxysm as the fulminant meeting of hostile forces, the searing immersion into its experiential crucible. The forces of becoming are at their most unbridled here in their forbidding convulsions of intertwined destruction and creation. Events are permeated with contingency and unpredictability, or that which Clausewitz referred to as the ineradicable 110 Security Dialogue 51(2-3) element of ‘chance’ in war. At ground level, the encounter with war directs us to its very sensate experience. After all, war is equally waged by the senses (the weapon as extension of the eye), through the senses (its surfeit of sensations ranging from excruciating pain to sublime exaltation) and on the senses (the blinding, bewildering and enervation of perception). We take inspiration from Michel Serres (2016), who opens his book on the senses with a recollection of his time in the French Navy. Through extensive fire training on his ship, he learns to breathe in smoky rooms, crawl through cramped, dark, crowded tunnels and navigate his surroundings using only his sense of touch. Yet all of this knowledge remains ‘academic’ until the moment an actual fire declares itself in the vessel’s hull. Upon hearing the munitions on the ship detonate, he realizes his only chance for survival is to push through a small, rusty porthole. The moment of theoretical illumination comes as he finds himself stuck in the porthole, staring out at a glacial sea with his back exposed to the searing flames, one half of his body freezing while the other is burning. Serres (2016: 19) writes, ‘I was inside, I was outside. Who was this “I”?’ In that instant, the ‘I’ became a body that ‘proclaims, calls, announces, sometimes howls the I like a wounded animal’. In that moment of desperation, the body fissures, another ‘I’ emerges, not the ‘I’ of the cogito but that of pure experience. The confrontation with existential peril is for Serres not just one more experience among others collected and indexed by a persistent ‘I’ but one that forges an altogether new ‘I’ from within it. The subject revealed during those fateful minutes resonates with James’s counter-intuitive claim that we are, in each fleeting moment, nothing more than a bundle of experience in the flux of becoming. In the moment of pain and crisis, the disjunctive character of Serres’s legs, arms, torso, head and sensations dismembers Kant’s supposed ‘spontaneous accord of the faculties’. What Serres learnt that day is that there is nothing spontaneous or necessary about the habituated accord of the faculties. The faculties and our sense of self are, like everything else, transitory coalescences drawn from the stream of experience. Cardinal as it may be, the encounter with war does not reduce to the conflagration of battle but encompasses a multiplicity of locales, durations and affects. War is diversely experienced by its participants as a cacophony of fear, anxiety, love, grief, rage, boredom, reminiscence, longing and elation, to which sleep offers merely a temporary respite (Kinsella, 2020). Many soldiers describe missing war and its unparalleled heightening of human existence, but all wrestle with its fundamental unintelligibility and foreignness, one way or another. In Michael Herr’s (1991) Dispatches from the Vietnam War, war appears as a kind of collective insanity in which soldiers struggle to make sense of the absurd situations the designs of war have placed them in. William Spanos (1993) notes that the entire Vietnamese earth came to be experienced as hostile by US soldiers. These soldiers could feel the enmity of trees, mosquitos, humidity, shadows and small children. What is it to feel enmity as opposed to merely acquiescing to its legal declaration or semiotic identification by official uniforms? The realm of feeling in war in all its complexities and gradations is one that has still received insufficient attention in our disciplines. The study of war experience goes well beyond collecting and relaying the combat testimonies or personal narratives of participants, however. Navigating the field of martial experience demands close attention to the depersonalizing shock of pure experience, the complex interactions between various affects, and the modes of intelligibility that attempt to make sense of and commandeer those affects. Through his enquiry into affective excess in total war, Ben Anderson (2010: 168) enjoins us to move beyond an amorphous general category of affect to understand how specific affects are ‘imbricated with mutable and variable modes of power that differ in their targets, desired and actual outcomes, hinges, and spatial forms’. Attending to the sensory and affective dimensions of war requires inspecting both the battlescapes in which combat occurs and all the other spaces in which bodies are primed and conditioned for fighting in the first place. Kinsella’s contribution (2020) on the regulation of sleep in war and the successes and failures of military interventions in Bousquet, Grove and Shah 111 the governance of slumber is exemplary. To consider sleep or its privation as part of the formative milieu of war draws us to the rhythms and processes of the body that both set the stage for martial experience and themselves constitute sites of power and contestation. In turn, Kirby’s unsettling investigation into sexual violence (2020) troubles our understandings of corporeal investments and mobilizations in the most intimate and traumatic of encounters. The supple affective terrain of experience certainly has not escaped the cunning intelligence of war. Tactics of ‘shock and awe’ and campaigns to ‘win hearts and minds’ seek to modulate the experience of war to produce specific outcomes. Bombs and bullets are made to persuade, convert and inspire as much as to kill and destroy. Peter Sloterdijk (2011) refers to the invasive ecology of warfare – the targeting of the material and immaterial connective tissues of our life-worlds – as ‘atmoterrorism’. From this perspective, the progress of war is nothing less than the ceaseless search for ‘new surfaces of vulnerability’ (Sloterdijk, 2011: 28), from breathable air and drinkable water to ideological beliefs and psychological states. For Massumi (2015), colour-coded terror levels, mutual assured destruction, and IEDs all trade on the volatile stock market of affective intensities that are no less real for their ethereal character. Atmospheres of war that extend far beyond the identifiable physicality of conflict are always enveloping us. By virtue of violence’s ‘super-empirical’ character – its immaterial affective charge – a witness can be ‘struck by the performed remainder of force as certainly as the recipient of the blow’ (Massumi, 2015: 87). Violence does not reduce to the infliction of broken bodies and bleeding wounds. War cuts deeper. It is through the affective register that scholars like McSorley (2012) or Daggett (2015) are able to convey the militarized sensorium of helmetcams or the queering embodiments of drone interfaces. Gun sights, night-vision goggles and drone cameras are not so much perceptual extensions to pre-existing subjects as interpolations into the flux of deterritorialized affect from which martial subjectivities emerge. From such points of entry, the primary stuff of war increasingly appears less like an assortment of weapons, drilled bodies and formations than, as per McSorley’s olfactory exploration (2020), a synesthetic congerie of visions, sounds, smells, touches, memories and emotions. The question here is not so much how to make sense of war as how war makes the senses. Accordingly, the apprehension of war’s encounter cannot limit itself to an interpretation of its representations. Through MacLeish’s engagement with the veteran life (2020), we learn that experience exceeds the immediately physical and yet retains a real effectivity on the world over and above the meanings invested in its representations. Even if they cannot be discerned in the discrete, continuous space of the material world, affective intensities overflow any representation we can make of them. The capture of the flux of experience through the media of language, paper, film, museums and monuments has no privilege over scar tissue, synaptic patterns, social relations and the planet’s epidermis. Martial empiricism is no more a naive realism in which everything is directly observable and measurable than it is an endless hermeneutics through which the world is made subservient to our interpretations of it. In war, through war, beyond war, the tumult of conflict periodically unsettles and shatters the reality principle of our understandings. Rather than call the participants of war that undergo such journeys ‘unreliable’ witnesses or ‘unstable’ subjects, we would rather redirect these seismic shifts in perspective onto the myth of recurrent experience. While not its sole privilege, war surely presents an inordinate challenge to the normalization of first world, suburban, sheltered experience, in which repetition and sameness are mistaken for a given principle or norm of both daily existence and scholarly investigation rather than the prerogative of particular dwellings. Yet we have now become painfully aware that city centres and public transportation are everywhere liable to precipitously transmute into sites of carnage that strike at beings in their most quotidian existences. Concurrently, drone pilots in the heart of the Nevada suburbs commute home through rows of box 112 Security Dialogue 51(2-3) stores, returning to their families after putting in a shift hunting men across the rocky terrains of Waziristan. The humdrum domesticity of the everyday coexists with the systemic unleashing of deadly force. Rather than pick a side between thinkers like Veena Das (2007), who underlines the ordinariness of violence, and Adriana Cavarero (2009), who demands that we confront the ‘horrorism’ of our contemporary atrocities, we position martial empiricism in the interval between the normality and the pathology of war. Following this lead highlights how war choreographs the transitions from one field of consistent experience to another, and how the accompanying disruptions congeal into new consistencies. How else can we make sense of the forever and everywhere wars of the 21st century (Filkins, 2008; Gregory, 2011) and the lacerations of remote force projection and pop-up guerrillas that punctually erupt across the globe? An empirical account of war organized by sensuous experience leads us back to the ‘great outdoors’ of Levinas’s opening provocation – war at the crossroads of totality and boundless alterity. However, the other of war, contra Levinas, is not just the problem of other human minds. Consciousness indeterminably bleeds into other forms of life, distributed among animals and machines – the horses, dogs, pigeons or dolphins of war, their biomimetic counterparts, and other algorithmic presences (Cudworth and Hobden, 2015). We already have phenomenological accounts surveying the umwelts of drone operators and their targets (Daggett 2015; Holmqvist, 2013). New frontiers lie beyond in the burgeoning inner lives of our machines and their otherworldly experiences of us. Grounding our study in a speculative and radical account of experience entails an openness to varieties of martial experience that outstrip our imaginations or predictions. War continually struggles to become conscious of itself. If unbridled deregulation of the senses and emergent subjectivities are inherent in war, how are we to realize a philosophical engagement with war? It is not enough to say that philosophical thought should interpret or represent war for us. We are not, in the final instance, interested in a theory of war but in how war provokes thought itself. For the frame of encounter necessarily pushes us deeper into the question of what holds war together. War is no more reducible to the litany of entities that make it up – from bullets, bombs and bandages to battlefields, bodies and battalions – than it is to an unmediated exertion of political will. The promiscuous relations of parts to wholes are an essential research problem, but their apprehension is inchoate without the stream of consciousness that experiences war. The empiricism pursued here – with its emphasis on affect, embodiment and sensation – is a martial empiricism because it is forged in the very crucible of war. Rather than being merely the agent provocateur of some other line of thought, war is permitted to be its own site of inquiry and theoretical elaboration.