Thus to become war we must affirm war- only an affective switch out of the squo creates the opportunity for bifurcation.
Groves 11, (Jairus Victor Groves, BECOMING WAR: ECOLOGY, ETHICS, AND THE GLOBALIZATION OF VIOLENCE, 2011, A dissertation submitted to John Hopkins for a PhD)GP
Not so, becoming war is a suspended present. Like the bullet time of The Matrix in which the incredible speed of moment produces an interminable slowness there must a 219 moment of duration just before war that makes possible no-war. To understand war as a becoming is not only lay bare the facile and destitute liberal understanding of peace but to open exploration of a becoming otherwise than war. Such a becoming cannot be peace and is apt to be illegible to the current indexes of war and peace. The normative markers of peace—the absence of conflict—need not define the limit of possible becomings otherwise than war. Becoming agonistic, becoming active, becoming rage, becoming justice, becoming quiet, becoming still, becoming disobedient, becoming graceful, becoming kind, becoming indifferent, becoming defiant, becoming gentle, becoming sacrifice, becoming fire (as many monks in Vietnam did and at least three individuals in the US have in the face of the Iraq war), becoming generous, becoming courageous... The restoration of belief in the world requires an affirmation of being in excess of a regulative or repressive model of peace. We must reject the model of peace exemplified by peacekeeping. War cannot be restrained, repressed, or deferred. The return of the repressed is often the outcome of managerial practices of peace. To approach peace of this kind is to translate war into standing reserve—saved up, stockpiled, trained, honed, targeted, scenario planned. Each model of peace defines a pole of international politics. One can see at the heart of the attempt to distinguish peace from war the absurdity of deterrence or hegemony. After all, peace is a funny way to characterize either the nuclear threat of the United States—the only country to use an atomic weapon—or the racial division of Israel and Palestine watched over by the Blue Helmets of the UN. War cannot be disowned or expelled It must be diverted by other incipient becomings. Other forks must be taken, the moment just before war must be extended and 220 inhabited so such that the otherwise becomes apparent. This does not require that the world slow down. It might require that we unblock certain flows corralled by the aborescent strategies of fortress state craft. Redirecting the affective economies of war towards other attachments—arguments, justice, compassion, forgiveness, politics, resistance, grief, art, beauty, the world—cannot be accomplished by repression or separation—that is a recipe for ressentiment. In refugee camps, detention camps, on either sides of walled borders, identities assert themselves, harden and intensify. The wasteland grows. War cannot be disavowed or expelled as in the Kantian tradition. Only the affirmative has the power to make the otherwise possible. The seeming intolerability of affirming destitution, battle, conflict, violence as part of life—a becoming of the body— brings into focus the possibility of becoming otherwise than war. War is most present, most under our jurisdiction when it is part of us rather than exterior or external to us. To understand the process of becoming war is to understand the possibility of becoming something else. If we externalize or banish war to the place of evil or outside we lose our grasp on its most vital, generative lifeline: ourselves. Affirming war as being human, all to human brings into focus the subtle changes in ourselves that draw us to the moments between war and otherwise than war. In this moment—returned to us by a kind of attunement—we find the other practices, bodily dispositions, emotions: grief rather than rage, compassion rather than revenge, determination rather than resignation. For some the otherwise will only give contrast to the power of hate or rage to overcome other impulses, but in others it may spawn other directions; new questions, alternatives to the dissatisfaction or burn out from rage, hate, and revenge. 221 Desperation may not always lead to the same result if returned to a fork in the stream of becoming rather than the inevitable requirements of the stultified responses of bombing, killing, starving, incarcerating, deterring, sanctioning, hating. New machines can be released into an assemblage, new cutting edges, new transfigurations and modifications—metamorphoses. Something imperceptible to the liberal eye that sees war as contrary to human nature and imperceptible to the Realist eye that sees war as the tragic inevitability of human nature. Each is a commitment to the human as being rather than becoming. Each fails to see possibilities contained in a body that evolves and carries potential to continue evolving. This is how we should read Nietzsche's aphorism that to deny war is to deny biology, to deny evolution. It is not as Fascists and those that dismiss Nietzsche as Fascist (these two schools of thinkers being in agreement. It is telling that Richard Wolin and Adolf Hitler read Nietzsche the same way, badly, violently) would read this aphorism that war is necessary and inevitable, but that war is the result of subtle, contingent, not inevitable, selections. When one blurs or confounds the culture/nature divide, as Jane Bennett, Alfred North Whitehead, William E. Connolly, Henri Bergson, Manuel DeLanda Brian Goodwin and others have (the list grows longer each day), one discerns the practices that give rise to tendencies such of war. And one also sees the subtle possibilities of selecting other tendencies, other practices, and other dispositions. This view of Evolution is not determinism. It is the condition and insistence of modification and change. Each modification confronting the possibility of multiple directions, trajectories, lines of flight, new practices, and experiments. Like all experiments from winged reptiles to speech, some fall flat on their face and others 222 produce sonnets. But at each moment of modification time forks, slows to a near halt, like a drop of water just before it separates from its source. In complexity theory such a moment is called a bifurcation. Delanda explains: Futhermore, even if we are destined to follow the attractors guiding our dynamical behavior, there are also bifurcations, critical points at which we may be able to change our destiny (that is modify our long-term tendencies). And because minuscule fluctuations in the environment in which bifurcations occur may decide the exact nature of the resulting attractors, on can hardly conclude that all actions we undertake—as individuals or collectively—are irrelevant in the face of these deterministic forces. Bifurcations may not be a "guarantee of freedom," but they certainly do provide a means of experimenting with—and perhaps even modifying our destinies.347 For those attuned to such possibilities—the succession of moments passing from one alteration to the next—the inevitability of the next moment cascades into a set of possibilities. The Israeli soldiers who suddenly won't pull the trigger; the flinch of a silo Captain when confronted by an incoming nuclear missile saving the world from a nuclear war almost triggered by an unusually rapid weather balloon rocket launched in Finland; Republican Governor George Ryan's sudden and unprecedented conviction of mercy and another justice; the inexplicable generosity of an Algerian Jew who returned the hatred of anti-Semitism with the impossible generosity and affirmation of deconstruction rather than the self-destructive drive of Zionism; love amongst state enemies; the impossible gesture of the ANC refusing to expel Afrikaners who once tortured and murdered them; career military officer William "Fox" Fallon who sacrificed his prestigious position as head of Central Command because he would not go along with the plan to attack Iran; the Delanda, 139, Incorporations, Zone 6. 348 In an act of defiance during the peak of Bush's war wongering leading up the release of the National Intelligence Report that revealed that Iran was not pursuing nuclear weapons Fallon public announced, "This constant drumbeat of conflict is not helpful and not useful. I expect that there will be no war, and that is what we ought to be working for. We ought to try to do our utmost to create different conditions." See Thomas P.M. Barnett," The Man Between War and Peace," Esquire, March 11th, 2008. 223 cascading events of the Arab Spring. The miracle need not be transcendent—coming from outside the world, from a god—the incipient chaos of possibilities contained in every moment of becoming expresses my belief in immanent miracles or unpredictable moments of bifurcation.