Some DA
Bousquet 09, (Antoine Bousquet is reader in international relations at Birkbeck, University of London. He is author of The Scientific Way of Warfare: Order and Chaos on the Battlefields of Modernity, 2009)
Although security is primarily analyzed by Foucault as a series of conducts or discursive practices it is not constructed ex nihilo out of language. Instead security emerges as a problem because of an encounter with a "space in which a series of uncertain elements unfolds...a circular link between effects and causes."224 He calls this alleatory space the milieu. Here I would like to read Foucault as a critic that sees discourse not as the formative or generative site of production but as the element of conductivity through which generation and formation pass. For Foucault language and nonlinguistic discursive practice are joined by many different means. Meaning and power circulate amongst rivers, cities, grain shortages, and disease outbreaks.225 In Foucault's account there is not a strict separation between things and the inter-subjective economies of discourse that make things into meaning but there is a difference of emphasis. I am wary of discourse analysis because it is too readily available to an anthropocentrism enamored with its own facility with words. Foucault reveals that facility to be facile, too easy. The world is neither fully grasped by the subject of enunciation, the speaker of discourse, nor does it exhaust the creative input of things and events exceeding or resisting human signification.226 When asked by Lacan's protege J.A. Miller whether the task of criticism requires the presupposition of an unconscious or at least an individual Foucault responds by saying that there are individuals but also subindividuals all contending with each other in what Foucault calls a "creative...and 997 heterogeneous ensemble." Therefore the speaking of language or the resistance of a particular conduct is not entirely human in the sense of unified or even coordinated. Foucault is not even willing to cede the ground to Jacques Lacan of a governing unconscious to organize the 'ensemble.'
It is crucial in this context that discourse should not be reduced to the semantical field of spoken interaction and written text. Paul Edwards makes clear that "discourse goes beyond speech acts to refer to the entire field of signifying or meaningful practices: these social interactions - material, institutional, and linguistic - through which human knowledge is produced and reproduced. A discourse, then, is a way of knowledge, a background of assumptions and agreements about how reality is to be interpreted and expressed, supported by paradigmatic metaphors, techniques, and technologies and potentially embodied in social institutions."15 In accordance with this broad understanding of discourse as a nexus of ideas and practices which (re)produce social reality and a certain set of power relations with it, modernity is to be viewed in Philip Lawrence's terms as "a structural organisation of state, economy, society and culture; a power complex and a mode of consciousness." 16