Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Passive voice is key – it boosts minority participation and expands dominant discourse into critical theory

Dillard-Knox 14 (Tiffany Yvonne Dillard-Knox, Knox is analyzing the History of Black discourse within debate @ U of Louisville, “Against the grain: The Challenge of Black discourse within inter-collegiate policy debate”, https://ir.library.louisville.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3166&context=etd, Published December 2014, Accessed 2/5/19, pg 69-70, Lex RM)

Historically, the topics that have been selected have been constructed utilizing the active voice as opposed to a passive voice. An active voice example would be, ―Resolved: The United States Federal Government should substantially increase statutory and/or judicial restrictions on the war powers authority of the President of the United States. A passive voice example would be, ―Resolved: The war powers authority of the President of the United States should be substantially restricted. The active voice topics require debaters to defend that the United States Federal Government ―do something in a more limited capacity, whereas a passive voice topic could allow debaters the opportunity to defend a variety of interpretations of ―something being done by or to the United States Federal Government. The active voice topic always gives the agency to act to the United States Government. For students that see themselves as having the possibility to access these positions of power, acquiring these skills become empowering. However, many marginalized students come to Debate from communities that have historically been excluded from these positions of power. Having a passive topic that removes the agency from the United States Federal Government and allows debaters the flexibility to choose who has agency thus becomes more empowering to this population of students. These students would then be more motivated to participate in the process of debate through which they can acquire a variety of skill sets from politician to community activists. Secondly, the literature base used to construct the topic has failed to include perspectives found within the race literature, such as the legal and political scholarship of Derrick Bell (1992), Cornel West (1994), and bell hooks (1995). Very little, if any, attention has been given to Critical Race Theory or Critical Legal Studies within the chosen controversy areas, such as Immigration and Supreme Court Cases. Even when topic papers are submitted that do include this literature, they are rarely, if ever selected in the voting process. This is important to the conversation of debating the topic in that the topic paper sets the definitional guidelines of what is considered topical. If the topic paper is limited to the language and perspective of the dominant, then so too will the debates be limited to the language and perspective of the dominant. Thus, it could be argued that the topic does not account for the discourse strategies of marginalized populations and could be an additional source of exclusion from Debate.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.